Hey all!
So last night, I was reading responses to my "
Was Tigerstar II Justified?" poll, and it gave me an interesting idea for a thread that I wanted to gauge interest for. In this thread, people would provide their opinions on a certain event or character's actions in the series, explaining whether or not it was justified. Some of these topics might be broad, some very specific, some may be minor and others major. After a few days, I would tally up the responses and give a final verdict: Justified or Unjustified.
For example, consider this prompt: "In
Into the Wild, Longtail challenges Rusty for wanting to leave his kittypet life to join ThunderClan, casting doubt on Rusty's ability to become a strong warrior. This leads to a fight between the two cats. Was Longtail justified in challenging Rusty?"
People would then say whether or not Longtail's actions are justified and explain their reasoning.
I'm still ironing out some of the details but I wrote up a draft and I'm working on it.
This idea is similar to and takes inspiration from ❅Maplefrost❅'s "Innocent or Guilty?" thread series, and credit goes to them for the original concept. They gave me permission to bring this idea back. Thanks, Maplefrost!What do you all think? Is this a good idea? Would people participate in this?
Note: Inevitably, some of the topics I choose may be controversial by nature. This thread will be intended for peaceful, civil conversation and to be a space for people to share their opinions safely. This thread will
not be an invitation to start arguments and cause trouble for your fellow users.