Moon's CMM

Honestly, Jessy rubbed me the wrong way right off the bat. I mean, Bramblestar tries to help her, and she the cat equivalent of punches him? For trying to help save a life? Honestly. Later on, she seemed a bit pushy/possessive of Bramblestar, moving her nest right next to his and shooing away other cats while he was sleeping.

As for some outside-the-books reasons: I used to think that she was a bit *too* good at everything, even though there are some logical- albeit offscreen- reasons for these qualities. Some of that may be kind of lurking around messing with my opinion of her anyways. I was also pretty annoyed at the Erins for throwing in another love interest to disrupt BramblexSquirrel.

I don't actually think they needed to, tbh. I'm honestly a bit annoyed that Bramblestar held on to a grudge for that long, and that he needed Jessy to point out that he still loved Sauirrelflight in order to get back with her. They could have worked it out a different way, but I suppose that Jessy served the purpose she was intended for.

I dislike Berrynose because he has always been arrogant- he's been slipped into many conversaitons as an example of bossiness. He mistrusted the former DF cats- including his own brother!- when they had helped the Clans fight. He literally had no reason to mistrust them, but he pointedly avoided going on patrols with them. His attitude even influenced his kits to set that trap with the fox for the DF cats- endangering their own Clanmates.
He has not matured nearly as much as some would suggest. In TAQ, he is still mentioned as being bossy (at the beginning, where Alder and Spark are discussing mentors they wouldn't want), indicating that his personality hasn't changed much. I consider that scene with Rosepetal in BrS to be rather questionable, as well, since they're half-siblings.

All in all, he is only a background character, so clearly I don't hate him with a passion as I do several other cats. But his personality has always been somewhat unpleasant to me, what with his arrogance and suspicion. The fact that some would suggest that he's matured- when in reality there is sparse evidence for this- also irks me a little bit.

While I do not believe her to be a Mary-Sue like some, many of her qualities rub me the wrong way.

-She is hypocritical, claiming that "Oh, I do really like you, Thunder!" One moment and going off to flirt with his dad the next. 
-I do not believe that she was good for Clear Sky in any case. Clear Sky was just starting to feel sorry for what he'd done, and then along comes Star Flower, whispering in his ear about what an amazing leader he was. I agree that she supported him well later on (interacting with Quiet Rain), but that careless attitude toward what he had done in the past was not what he needed. I understand that this point may not be entirely relevant, but it does give me a certain measure of dislike toward her.
-She seems to get away with everything. She may have been distrusted initially, but nothing really was done to her punishment-wise, like everyone (especially Clear Sky??) had just forgotten that she betrayed the future Clan cats. That doesn't sit well with me, because even though she had a change of heart later on, she still never owned up to what she had done, settling comfortably into her life in a powerful position- as a leader's mate.

Because they're villains

Seriously though, nothing excuses killing cats because of their parentage or turning kittens into child soldiers. Scourge's rough childhood doesn't excuse his transformation into a tyrant and a murderer.

Oh yeah, they're great as villains. They offer some nice sentimental value for me as well. :> but as cats, as characters, I can't do anything but despise them.

Sure ^u^

To be honest, I feel like she's pretty overhyped. I see lots of people who like her because she was an "awesome spy," and while her POV was interesting, she honestly didn't pass on much information at all- if any. And while her bitterness early on was somewhat understandable, it was still pretty unpleasant and got seriously out of hand. Those aspects aside, her character never stuck to me, if you know what I mean? 

I like Daisy because she's matured a whole lot since joining the Clan. She originally came to ThunderClan expecting to be sheltered and cared for, but after her kits grew up she started pulling her weight a bit more, even though she remained in the nursery. She even fought in the DF battle. I like how her character has progressed.

Bwahaha >:3

Millie-
First, let me just say that I loved her in the mangas. She was a great character, and I'm genuinely sad to see what the Erins have brought her to. My reasons for disliking her are likely fairly clear- the blatant favoritism and disregard for her other kits' health, smothering poor Briarlight, and adopting a "dead-would-be-better-than-alive-and-crippled" mentality in a number of confrontation scenes with Jayfeather. I wish we could have seen an on-screen apology to Blossomfall, because that sub-plot was, well, a sub-plot, and I wish it had been wrapped up in a better way. The kindness she showed to the kittypets in BrS makes me kind of sad too, because it's clear that the Erins were trying to redeem her in the readers' eyes.

what is your final opinion of yellowfang? i know you have a love/hate relationship but there must be some overall opinion you have.

Don't forget that he also threatened to tear Oakheart's throat for trespassing.