What If: Needletail was Dovewing and Tigerheart's daughter?
Apr 2, 2018 15:12:20 GMT -5
via mobile
Tas, gonxkillua, and 3 more like this
Post by ๐ฃ๐ฒ๐ท๐พ๐ฟ๐ฒ๐ฎ๐ต on Apr 2, 2018 15:12:20 GMT -5
RULES: 1) Sometimes I'll add a description to the topic of the week, so nake sure to check if there's one instead of just reading the title of the thread.
2) Try to suspend your disbelief. This is a "What-If" thread, and I'd like for it to be treated as such. So if, for example, the topic is "What if Dovewing trained in the Dark Forest," don't say she would never do that or she'd get killed soon after joining; instead, consider what was going on at the time and use your imagination!
Even the smallest of actions may have a big impact on someone's life, and that's exactly what this thread is about. Each week will discuss what if a character had made a different choice or if the Erins had done a certain thing differently, and what sort of impact it would have on the series.
Past Topics:
New Topic: What if Needletail was Dovewing and Tigerheart's daughter?
Description: Let's say that Dovewing and Tigerheart actually got back together after Bramblestar's Storm, and they become the parents of Needletail instead. What would happen?
2) Try to suspend your disbelief. This is a "What-If" thread, and I'd like for it to be treated as such. So if, for example, the topic is "What if Dovewing trained in the Dark Forest," don't say she would never do that or she'd get killed soon after joining; instead, consider what was going on at the time and use your imagination!
Even the smallest of actions may have a big impact on someone's life, and that's exactly what this thread is about. Each week will discuss what if a character had made a different choice or if the Erins had done a certain thing differently, and what sort of impact it would have on the series.
Past Topics:
What if Silverstream refused?
Description: According to The Ultimate Guide (ignoring its inconsistencies), Graystripe had begged Silverstream to see each other again, and she agreed out of curiosity. What if Silverstream had refused?
What if Dovewing had found out later?
Description: Lionblaze and Jayfeather told Dovepaw about the Prophecy of the Three not long after she started her training. What if she had found out a little later on instead, like as an older apprentice or warrior?
What if Firestar led SkyClan back to the forest?
Description: At one point in Firestar's Quest, Firestar suggested leading SkyClan back to the forest. What if he managed to do this?
What if Crookedstar and Bluestar had fallen in love?
Description: When they were younger, Crookedstar and Bluestar had been friends. What if they became more than that?
What if Jayfeather had stayed with the Tribe?
Description: In Sign of the Moon, Jayfeather wishes to stay with Half Moon, but Rock convinces him to return to his own time. What if he had stayed?
What if Firestar and Sandstorm stayed in SkyClan?
Description: What if Firestar and Sandstorm stayed in SkyClan instead of returning to ThunderClan?
What if Ashfur and Leafpool were mates?
Description: Let's say Ashfur and Leafpool comforted each other over losing their love interests shortly after Ashfur got rejected by Squirrelflight. What if they fell in love and became mates?
What if Leopardstar was the mother of Tigerstar's second litter?
Description: What if Leopardstar had Hawkfrost, Mothwing, and Tadpole instead of Sasha?
What if Dovewing trained in the Dark Forest?
Description: In Fading Echoes, Tigerstar tells Hawkfrost to visit an apprentice with great power. What if instead of recruiting Ivypaw, he actually recruited Dovepaw?
What if Firestar and Graystripe fell in love?
Description: In honor of Pride Month, I'll be doing "What-Ifs" on some popular and semi-popular LGBT ships. So, what if Firestar and Graystripe had fallen in love?
What if Jake joined WindClan and became mates with Tallstar?
What if Leafpool and Mothwing fell in love?
What if Silverstream and Millie fell in love?
Description: Let's say Silverstream lived and was captured instead of Graystripe (whether he's alive or not by this point is up to you). What if she and Millie had fallen in love on their way back to the Clans?
What if the Dark Forest could corrupt StarClan cats?
Description: What if the Dark Forest cats could corrupt StarClan cats by taking advantage of any negative emotions (ex: Yellowfang's uneasiness towards Brokenstar when she visited the Dark Foresy, or Flametail's resentment), thus bringing them over to their side by the time of the Great Battle? Furthermore, how do you think this would've affected the outcome of the battle (if at all), and which StarClan cats do you think would've been corrupted had this happened?
What if Hawkwing joined Darktail?
Description: According to The Ultimate Guide (ignoring its inconsistencies), Graystripe had begged Silverstream to see each other again, and she agreed out of curiosity. What if Silverstream had refused?
What if Dovewing had found out later?
Description: Lionblaze and Jayfeather told Dovepaw about the Prophecy of the Three not long after she started her training. What if she had found out a little later on instead, like as an older apprentice or warrior?
What if Firestar led SkyClan back to the forest?
Description: At one point in Firestar's Quest, Firestar suggested leading SkyClan back to the forest. What if he managed to do this?
What if Crookedstar and Bluestar had fallen in love?
Description: When they were younger, Crookedstar and Bluestar had been friends. What if they became more than that?
What if Jayfeather had stayed with the Tribe?
Description: In Sign of the Moon, Jayfeather wishes to stay with Half Moon, but Rock convinces him to return to his own time. What if he had stayed?
What if Firestar and Sandstorm stayed in SkyClan?
Description: What if Firestar and Sandstorm stayed in SkyClan instead of returning to ThunderClan?
What if Ashfur and Leafpool were mates?
Description: Let's say Ashfur and Leafpool comforted each other over losing their love interests shortly after Ashfur got rejected by Squirrelflight. What if they fell in love and became mates?
What if Leopardstar was the mother of Tigerstar's second litter?
Description: What if Leopardstar had Hawkfrost, Mothwing, and Tadpole instead of Sasha?
What if Dovewing trained in the Dark Forest?
Description: In Fading Echoes, Tigerstar tells Hawkfrost to visit an apprentice with great power. What if instead of recruiting Ivypaw, he actually recruited Dovepaw?
What if Firestar and Graystripe fell in love?
Description: In honor of Pride Month, I'll be doing "What-Ifs" on some popular and semi-popular LGBT ships. So, what if Firestar and Graystripe had fallen in love?
What if Jake joined WindClan and became mates with Tallstar?
What if Leafpool and Mothwing fell in love?
What if Silverstream and Millie fell in love?
Description: Let's say Silverstream lived and was captured instead of Graystripe (whether he's alive or not by this point is up to you). What if she and Millie had fallen in love on their way back to the Clans?
What if the Dark Forest could corrupt StarClan cats?
Description: What if the Dark Forest cats could corrupt StarClan cats by taking advantage of any negative emotions (ex: Yellowfang's uneasiness towards Brokenstar when she visited the Dark Foresy, or Flametail's resentment), thus bringing them over to their side by the time of the Great Battle? Furthermore, how do you think this would've affected the outcome of the battle (if at all), and which StarClan cats do you think would've been corrupted had this happened?
What if Hawkwing joined Darktail?
New Topic: What if Needletail was Dovewing and Tigerheart's daughter?
Description: Let's say that Dovewing and Tigerheart actually got back together after Bramblestar's Storm, and they become the parents of Needletail instead. What would happen?