Post by BҽɾɾყႦʅσσɱ on Aug 5, 2023 13:24:49 GMT -5
So um, I know this will probably not happen but still wanted to make a thread on it regardless.
I mentioned on this thread that I've had a bit of an ominous feeling regarding Bramblestar and Squirrelflight going to the Moonpool at the end of Shadow. And then, when the Wind blurb got posted and revealed so much about what happens in Thunder except for anything regarding the future leadership of ThunderClan, that feeling increased.
Now then, I'm aware they are most likely witholding information to build up suspense and it could still just mean that Squirrelstar will happen or that she will simply retire together with him at some point in the currently ongoing arc. But there's this feeling that something could go terribly wrong for both of them.
Here's my thought from that other thread: "What if BrambleSquirrel go to the Moonpool but don't come back and a patrol or the medicine cats later on find their corpses lying near it?"
I'm aware that is quite a dark thought (was not in a happy mood that day) but an idea as to how this could be possible just got to me today.
Because I remembered the dogs.
The ones who killed Curlfeather while she was on her way to the Moonpool with Frostpaw to get her nine lives near the end of River.
What if those dogs come near the Moonpool while Bramblestar and Squirrelflight are there to speak with StarClan? I don't think ThunderClan is truly aware of them (albeit mostly due to me not remembering wether or not RiverClan revealed just how Curlfeather died at any of the Gatherings in Sky or Shadow).
So perhaps another reason as to why this theory can be seen as highly unlikely is the fact that ThunderClan does know and I just forgot about it.
Just remembered this other thread I made a little more over two years ago, where I (wrongfully) theorized that BrambleSquirrel would die together in the ALitM finale.
It was, for the most part, based on me remembering the vision Leafpool had all the way back during Sunset where she saw Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight walking alongside eachother until they vanished into the starry sky.
Totally aware here that I'm definitely placing far too much faith in the editors and writers to actually even remember that scene when they made the by now infamous mistake of Graystripe calling Mistystar and Stonefur his kits in BrS (when they are BlueOak kits instead) as well as Tigerstar saying to Squirrelflight during TBC that remembered stories about her fighting in the battle against the Dark Forest when he was a kit (even though he himself had been a DF trainee and alleged spy at the time).
Also, I swear that I'm actually hoping for BrambleSquirrel to peacefully retire and not be ripped apart by dogs. But something just makes me think this could still be a possibility even though it's certainly very unlikely.
I mentioned on this thread that I've had a bit of an ominous feeling regarding Bramblestar and Squirrelflight going to the Moonpool at the end of Shadow. And then, when the Wind blurb got posted and revealed so much about what happens in Thunder except for anything regarding the future leadership of ThunderClan, that feeling increased.
Now then, I'm aware they are most likely witholding information to build up suspense and it could still just mean that Squirrelstar will happen or that she will simply retire together with him at some point in the currently ongoing arc. But there's this feeling that something could go terribly wrong for both of them.
Here's my thought from that other thread: "What if BrambleSquirrel go to the Moonpool but don't come back and a patrol or the medicine cats later on find their corpses lying near it?"
I'm aware that is quite a dark thought (was not in a happy mood that day) but an idea as to how this could be possible just got to me today.
Because I remembered the dogs.
The ones who killed Curlfeather while she was on her way to the Moonpool with Frostpaw to get her nine lives near the end of River.
What if those dogs come near the Moonpool while Bramblestar and Squirrelflight are there to speak with StarClan? I don't think ThunderClan is truly aware of them (albeit mostly due to me not remembering wether or not RiverClan revealed just how Curlfeather died at any of the Gatherings in Sky or Shadow).
So perhaps another reason as to why this theory can be seen as highly unlikely is the fact that ThunderClan does know and I just forgot about it.
Just remembered this other thread I made a little more over two years ago, where I (wrongfully) theorized that BrambleSquirrel would die together in the ALitM finale.
It was, for the most part, based on me remembering the vision Leafpool had all the way back during Sunset where she saw Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight walking alongside eachother until they vanished into the starry sky.
Totally aware here that I'm definitely placing far too much faith in the editors and writers to actually even remember that scene when they made the by now infamous mistake of Graystripe calling Mistystar and Stonefur his kits in BrS (when they are BlueOak kits instead) as well as Tigerstar saying to Squirrelflight during TBC that remembered stories about her fighting in the battle against the Dark Forest when he was a kit (even though he himself had been a DF trainee and alleged spy at the time).
Also, I swear that I'm actually hoping for BrambleSquirrel to peacefully retire and not be ripped apart by dogs. But something just makes me think this could still be a possibility even though it's certainly very unlikely.