#a3c5e6
Name Colour
𝓣𝓲𝓷𝓾𝓿𝓲𝓮𝓵
Warrior Fanatic
All hail me, the flower-flushing queen of Prague
|
Post by 𝓣𝓲𝓷𝓾𝓿𝓲𝓮𝓵 on Mar 31, 2017 6:55:19 GMT -5
I didn't say that Ivypool is like Mapleshade, but she is definitely one of the most favored good characters, and Mapleshade is the most favored villian by the authors. I agree that it's too early for Leafshade, Honeyfur and Larksong to have an apprentice, they need to settle down at first. But Snowbush and his siblings? I mean when Snowbush is old enough to have his own kits then why shouldn't he be ready to have an apprentice? The same with Fernsong and his siblings, i think it has nothing to do with how old a cat is. They are all warriors now and should be able to pass their knowledge down on the apprentices. The sooner the better. Just Dovewing and Berrynose as mentors? What about Mousewhisker, Bumblestripe, Rosepetal, Lionblaze, Cinderheart, Poppyfrost and Birchfall. (Birchfall never had an apprentice, just like Dovewing and Berrynose) No, it must be someone special like Ivypool. Being old enough to have a mate and being given the privilege to have an apprentice...are literally two different things. Apprentices aren't allowed to have mates, not because they can't have kits, but because it's deemed as a distraction to their training. Also the Erins went out of their way to even show how bad of an idea it is to give younger warriors apprentices so soon, like Rowanstar for example, and how much disapproval he got for doing this. By your logic, cats should be able to have apprentices as soon as they're warriors, just like being able to have a mate. Any one who's read the first two AVoS books already know how bad of a leader Rowanstar is too. Fernsong and his siblings were just newly made apprentices in BrS, we're literally only in the second book of the series that follows BrS. So yes, he and his siblings are too young imo, the same goes with Snowbush. Having a mate doesn't = being able to have an apprentice. Mousewhisker got Bumblestripe. Bumblestripe got Seedpaw, and after her Leafshade. Rosepetal got Molewhisker, Fernsong and Larksong. Lionblaze got Dovewing. Cinderheart got Ivypool. Poppyfrost got Lilyheart. And I missed Birchfall. But considering what he did in the last arc I doubt Bramble is ready to give him an apprentice just yet. I also think it's strange that you dislike Ivypool geting Twigpaw because she had screentime, when Lionblaze is one of the cats you mentioned, and he has had 2x more screen time than Ivypool ever had. Not to mention Ivypool was in no way special like Lionblaze, Lionblaze literally had powers, lol. I honestly don't understand why it's so bad that Ivypool is Twigpaw's mentor you make it seem like she has some sort of special powers, or she's part of the prophecy, when she wasn't even part of the last prophecy. Ivypool is literally one of the most down to earth protagonist we've had so far in the sereis next to Hollyleaf, who also wasn't part of any prophecies nor had any special powers, etc. Heck, Ivypool isn't even the kit of some forbidden romance drama either, like?? I mean its not like Lionblaze is no longer the strongest cat in the clan and is down right reckless in batter without his powers anymore so Bramblestar wanted to put Twigpaw in the hands of someone he deemed as reliable and also capable of protecting her. Ya know like one of his more skilled fighters, runnerup to Lionblaze with his handicaps. Yeah. I personally ever had a problem with Rowanstar and while I get what you mean, to be fair, it's not like young cats haven't trained apprentices before. Firestar and Graystripe weren't warriors for that long and they got to be mentors (just not very good in Graystripe's case). Same goes for Hawkwing. Sparrowpelt and Cherrytail became mentors literally as soon as they became warriors. Whether Ivypool was a spy or not doesn't change the fact that she still trained in the Dark Forest. Also, Blossomfall might've trained Hollytuft, though it could just as well be a mistake since BrS shows her as Cloudtail's apprentice. It seems to depend on the cat, really. Just because Stonewing and Wasptail had difficulty with it doesn't mean all cats who just became warriors will, sort of like how not all cats are meant to be mentors. That said, I really don't mind Ivypool being Twigpaw's mentor either. It actually makes sense considering the circumstances.
|
|
|
Post by Leafshine on Mar 31, 2017 7:05:55 GMT -5
I didn't say that Ivypool is like Mapleshade, but she is definitely one of the most favored good characters, and Mapleshade is the most favored villian by the authors. I agree that it's too early for Leafshade, Honeyfur and Larksong to have an apprentice, they need to settle down at first. But Snowbush and his siblings? I mean when Snowbush is old enough to have his own kits then why shouldn't he be ready to have an apprentice? The same with Fernsong and his siblings, i think it has nothing to do with how old a cat is. They are all warriors now and should be able to pass their knowledge down on the apprentices. The sooner the better. Just Dovewing and Berrynose as mentors? What about Mousewhisker, Bumblestripe, Rosepetal, Lionblaze, Cinderheart, Poppyfrost and Birchfall. (Birchfall never had an apprentice, just like Dovewing and Berrynose) No, it must be someone special like Ivypool. Being old enough to have a mate and being given the privilege to have an apprentice...are literally two different things. Apprentices aren't allowed to have mates, not because they can't have kits, but because it's deemed as a distraction to their training. Also the Erins went out of their way to even show how bad of an idea it is to give younger warriors apprentices so soon, like Rowanstar for example, and how much disapproval he got for doing this. By your logic, cats should be able to have apprentices as soon as they're warriors, just like being able to have a mate. Any one who's read the first two AVoS books already know how bad of a leader Rowanstar is too. Fernsong and his siblings were just newly made apprentices in BrS, we're literally only in the second book of the series that follows BrS. So yes, he and his siblings are too young imo, the same goes with Snowbush. Having a mate doesn't = being able to have an apprentice. Mousewhisker got Bumblestripe. Bumblestripe got Seedpaw, and after her Leafshade. Rosepetal got Molewhisker, Fernsong and Larksong. Lionblaze got Dovewing. Cinderheart got Ivypool. Poppyfrost got Lilyheart. And I missed Birchfall. But considering what he did in the last arc I doubt Bramble is ready to give him an apprentice just yet. I also think it's strange that you dislike Ivypool geting Twigpaw because she had screentime, when Lionblaze is one of the cats you mentioned, and he has had 2x more screen time than Ivypool ever had. Not to mention Ivypool was in no way special like Lionblaze, Lionblaze literally had powers, lol. I honestly don't understand why it's so bad that Ivypool is Twigpaw's mentor you make it seem like she has some sort of special powers, or she's part of the prophecy, when she wasn't even part of the last prophecy. Ivypool is literally one of the most down to earth protagonist we've had so far in the sereis next to Hollyleaf, who also wasn't part of any prophecies nor had any special powers, etc. Heck, Ivypool isn't even the kit of some forbidden romance drama either, like?? I mean its not like Lionblaze is no longer the strongest cat in the clan and is down right reckless in batter without his powers anymore so Bramblestar wanted to put Twigpaw in the hands of someone he deemed as reliable and also capable of protecting her. Ya know like one of his more skilled fighters, runnerup to Lionblaze with his handicaps. Yeah. Fernsong and his sibling are not that young, they are much longer warriors than Wasptail and Stonewing were at that time. Both were newly made warriors just like Leafshade, Honeyfur and Larksong. And i don't see a reason why Snowbush, Fernsong and the others shouldn't get an apprentice. They are all competent warriors. And it doesn't matter that Poppyfrost or Rosepetal had already apprentices, anyone could have been Twigpaw's mentor. It's not like Ivypool is the only one able to protect Twigpaw. I just said that i think Lionblaze will be ThunderClans next leader before Ivypool. I know her life wasn't easy but that's not the point. She is one of the favored characters of the authors like Lionblaze, Dovewing etc. I just wish that they give the background characters a bit more spotlight you know. And not always use the same ones we already know.
|
|
|
Post by pastelpills on Mar 31, 2017 7:06:11 GMT -5
No offense but I can't see Twigstar. Not now, not ever. If anything she is fit to be the medicine cat, maybe warrior, but anything higher than that.... Just no. But Twigpaw would be a good choice too, because she is young and loyal. She choosed ThunderClan over her sister even when she missed her so much. And with Ivypool as mentor she is going to be a good warrior. Just because she is a good warrior doesn't mean she has a good leadership skills. For example - Cloudtail. He is a skilled warrior, but he could never be a leader.
|
|
|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Mar 31, 2017 7:24:20 GMT -5
Being old enough to have a mate and being given the privilege to have an apprentice...are literally two different things. Apprentices aren't allowed to have mates, not because they can't have kits, but because it's deemed as a distraction to their training. Also the Erins went out of their way to even show how bad of an idea it is to give younger warriors apprentices so soon, like Rowanstar for example, and how much disapproval he got for doing this. By your logic, cats should be able to have apprentices as soon as they're warriors, just like being able to have a mate. Any one who's read the first two AVoS books already know how bad of a leader Rowanstar is too. Fernsong and his siblings were just newly made apprentices in BrS, we're literally only in the second book of the series that follows BrS. So yes, he and his siblings are too young imo, the same goes with Snowbush. Having a mate doesn't = being able to have an apprentice. Mousewhisker got Bumblestripe. Bumblestripe got Seedpaw, and after her Leafshade. Rosepetal got Molewhisker, Fernsong and Larksong. Lionblaze got Dovewing. Cinderheart got Ivypool. Poppyfrost got Lilyheart. And I missed Birchfall. But considering what he did in the last arc I doubt Bramble is ready to give him an apprentice just yet. I also think it's strange that you dislike Ivypool geting Twigpaw because she had screentime, when Lionblaze is one of the cats you mentioned, and he has had 2x more screen time than Ivypool ever had. Not to mention Ivypool was in no way special like Lionblaze, Lionblaze literally had powers, lol. I honestly don't understand why it's so bad that Ivypool is Twigpaw's mentor you make it seem like she has some sort of special powers, or she's part of the prophecy, when she wasn't even part of the last prophecy. Ivypool is literally one of the most down to earth protagonist we've had so far in the sereis next to Hollyleaf, who also wasn't part of any prophecies nor had any special powers, etc. Heck, Ivypool isn't even the kit of some forbidden romance drama either, like?? I mean its not like Lionblaze is no longer the strongest cat in the clan and is down right reckless in batter without his powers anymore so Bramblestar wanted to put Twigpaw in the hands of someone he deemed as reliable and also capable of protecting her. Ya know like one of his more skilled fighters, runnerup to Lionblaze with his handicaps. Yeah. I personally ever had a problem with Rowanstar and while I get what you mean, to be fair, it's not like young cats haven't trained apprentices before. Firestar and Graystripe weren't warriors for that long and they got to be mentors (just not very good in Graystripe's case). Same goes for Hawkwing. Sparrowpelt and Cherrytail became mentors literally as soon as they became warriors. Whether Ivypool was a spy or not doesn't change the fact that she still trained in the Dark Forest. Also, Blossomfall might've trained Hollytuft, though it could just as well be a mistake since BrS shows her as Cloudtail's apprentice. It seems to depend on the cat, really. Just because Stonewing and Wasptail had difficulty with it doesn't mean all cats who just became warriors will, sort of like how not all cats are meant to be mentors. That said, I really don't mind Ivypool being Twigpaw's mentor either. It actually makes sense considering the circumstances. Firestar and Graystripe were mentors ages ago irl. That's at least 11 years for the Erins to improve on writing. Hawking, Sparrowpelt and Cherrytail are SkyClan cats, they live by different rules. When I talk about Birchfall, it's because he was an older cat, hew knew about Tigerstar, he honestly should have known better. When it comes to him and Thornclaw, imo they really had no real business being one of the DF trainees.
|
|
|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Mar 31, 2017 7:37:18 GMT -5
Being old enough to have a mate and being given the privilege to have an apprentice...are literally two different things. Apprentices aren't allowed to have mates, not because they can't have kits, but because it's deemed as a distraction to their training. Also the Erins went out of their way to even show how bad of an idea it is to give younger warriors apprentices so soon, like Rowanstar for example, and how much disapproval he got for doing this. By your logic, cats should be able to have apprentices as soon as they're warriors, just like being able to have a mate. Any one who's read the first two AVoS books already know how bad of a leader Rowanstar is too. Fernsong and his siblings were just newly made apprentices in BrS, we're literally only in the second book of the series that follows BrS. So yes, he and his siblings are too young imo, the same goes with Snowbush. Having a mate doesn't = being able to have an apprentice. Mousewhisker got Bumblestripe. Bumblestripe got Seedpaw, and after her Leafshade. Rosepetal got Molewhisker, Fernsong and Larksong. Lionblaze got Dovewing. Cinderheart got Ivypool. Poppyfrost got Lilyheart. And I missed Birchfall. But considering what he did in the last arc I doubt Bramble is ready to give him an apprentice just yet. I also think it's strange that you dislike Ivypool geting Twigpaw because she had screentime, when Lionblaze is one of the cats you mentioned, and he has had 2x more screen time than Ivypool ever had. Not to mention Ivypool was in no way special like Lionblaze, Lionblaze literally had powers, lol. I honestly don't understand why it's so bad that Ivypool is Twigpaw's mentor you make it seem like she has some sort of special powers, or she's part of the prophecy, when she wasn't even part of the last prophecy. Ivypool is literally one of the most down to earth protagonist we've had so far in the sereis next to Hollyleaf, who also wasn't part of any prophecies nor had any special powers, etc. Heck, Ivypool isn't even the kit of some forbidden romance drama either, like?? I mean its not like Lionblaze is no longer the strongest cat in the clan and is down right reckless in batter without his powers anymore so Bramblestar wanted to put Twigpaw in the hands of someone he deemed as reliable and also capable of protecting her. Ya know like one of his more skilled fighters, runnerup to Lionblaze with his handicaps. Yeah. Fernsong and his sibling are not that young, they are much longer warriors than Wasptail and Stonewing were at that time. Both were newly made warriors just like Leafshade, Honeyfur and Larksong. And i don't see a reason why Snowbush, Fernsong and the others shouldn't get an apprentice. They are all competent warriors. And it doesn't matter that Poppyfrost or Rosepetal had already apprentices, anyone could have been Twigpaw's mentor. It's not like Ivypool is the only one able to protect Twigpaw. I just said that i think Lionblaze will be ThunderClans next leader before Ivypool. I know her life wasn't easy but that's not the point. She is one of the favored characters of the authors like Lionblaze, Dovewing etc. I just wish that they give the background characters a bit more spotlight you know. And not always use the same ones we already know. They are most definitely still young warriors though lol, but not newly made warriors. Molewhisker and Cherrytail were born in the Fourth Apprentice, they became apprentices in the Forgotten Warrior, the second to last book in OotS, they've been kits for 5 books. They're not warriors until the time skip to BrS, which is around when Amber, Dew, Snow, and Lily are apprentices. They become warriors at the end of BrS, and Fernsong and his littermates are apprentices in the bonus comic. They're warriors by the time AVoS starts, but by then this is JUST NOW when Mole and Cherry are getting apprentices. So yes Snow and his gen are young, but Fern is even younger, and the newest warriors like Spark are even younger, and then the new warriors in TAS are younger then them. Do I see Snow, Amber, Dew and Lily possibly getting their first apprentices before the end of AVoS? Sure. There still like 3 more books to go. But it makes you wonder, by your logic, why didn't any of them get one of Lily's kits. *shrug* I highly doubt Lionblaze will become the next leader considering Bramblestar already easily overlooked him for Squirrelflight when he became leader. I don't get how you're saying that Ivypool should get a break in favor of a background character, but then turn around and say Lionblaze should have gotten Twigpaw because you think he should be the next leader...that's very contradicting.
|
|
|
Post by Leafshine on Mar 31, 2017 8:09:15 GMT -5
Fernsong and his sibling are not that young, they are much longer warriors than Wasptail and Stonewing were at that time. Both were newly made warriors just like Leafshade, Honeyfur and Larksong. And i don't see a reason why Snowbush, Fernsong and the others shouldn't get an apprentice. They are all competent warriors. And it doesn't matter that Poppyfrost or Rosepetal had already apprentices, anyone could have been Twigpaw's mentor. It's not like Ivypool is the only one able to protect Twigpaw. I just said that i think Lionblaze will be ThunderClans next leader before Ivypool. I know her life wasn't easy but that's not the point. She is one of the favored characters of the authors like Lionblaze, Dovewing etc. I just wish that they give the background characters a bit more spotlight you know. And not always use the same ones we already know. They are most definitely still young warriors though lol, but not newly made warriors. Molewhisker and Cherrytail were born in the Fourth Apprentice, they became apprentices in the Forgotten Warrior, the second to last book in OotS, they've been kits for 5 books. They're not warriors until the time skip to BrS, which is around when Amber, Dew, Snow, and Lily are apprentices. They become warriors at the end of BrS, and Fernsong and his littermates are apprentices in the bonus comic. They're warriors by the time AVoS starts, but by then this is JUST NOW when Mole and Cherry are getting apprentices. So yes Snow and his gen are young, but Fern is even younger, and the newest warriors like Spark are even younger, and then the new warriors in TAS are younger then them. Do I see Snow, Amber, Dew and Lily possibly getting their first apprentices before the end of AVoS? Sure. There still like 3 more books to go. But it makes you wonder, by your logic, why didn't any of them get one of Lily's kits. *shrug* I highly doubt Lionblaze will become the next leader considering Bramblestar already easily overlooked him for Squirrelflight when he became leader. I don't get how you're saying that Ivypool should get a break in favor of a background character, but then turn around and say Lionblaze should have gotten Twigpaw because you think he should be the next leader...that's very contradicting. Wasptail and Stonewing were newly made warrios when they got their apprentices. And of course Lilyheart and Snowbush can't mentor their own kits? They became in a very young age parents. And Ambermoon and Dewnose are aunt and uncle to Leafkit, Honeykit and Larkkit. They are kin, therefore they were not choosen as their mentors. I knew that Bramblestar would choose Squirrelflight over Lionblaze. He was too young at that time for deputyship, but that doesn't always matter. (Just remember Hawkwing and Firestar). A clan leader mostly pick up more experienced warrior for deputy. But if Squirrelflight dies it is very possible that he would choose Lionblaze. I did never say that Lionblaze should be Twigpaws mentor instead of Ivypool!
|
|
|
Post by Moonblazer on Mar 31, 2017 8:27:42 GMT -5
Ugh god I would highly dislike Lionblaze as leader...
Ivypool certainly is doing a good job with Twigpaw so far, her personality is good for Twigpaw.
Sure, I'd be fine with Birchfall or Berrynose as her mentor, but Ivypool is doing great and I wouldn't want anyone else other than those as her mentor.
|
|
#a3c5e6
Name Colour
𝓣𝓲𝓷𝓾𝓿𝓲𝓮𝓵
Warrior Fanatic
All hail me, the flower-flushing queen of Prague
|
Post by 𝓣𝓲𝓷𝓾𝓿𝓲𝓮𝓵 on Mar 31, 2017 10:03:43 GMT -5
@maplefrost: That still doesn't change the fact that they became mentors not long after becoming warriors and the young age is sometimes pointed out. Sometimes it works out, sometimes it doesn't. That's the point I'm trying to make. Leafshine: I just want to point out that cats mentoring their kin isn't that uncommon. And I don't just mean cousins either. Kin mentor their own kin all the time. Here are a few examples of cats being mentors to their kits, grandkits, siblings, nieces, or nephews: Poppycloud, Petalnose, Windflight, and Shellheart mentored their own kits. Whitetail temporarily mentored her daughter. Ivypool mentored her uncle. Fireheart mentored his nephew and Tigerheart mentored his niece. Whitewing and Poppycloud mentored their younger siblings and Tawnyspots his half-sister. Brackenfur mentored his granddaughter.
|
|
|
Post by Moonblazer on Mar 31, 2017 10:15:26 GMT -5
May not count in the context, but Leafpool mentored both Hollyleaf for a bit and Jayfeather, though then again, they had no idea Leafpool was their mother, but they do now, and Leafpool and Jayfeather are still technically in mentoring terms. Leafpool is also mentoring her nephew, and Jayfeather his cousin.
|
|
#a3c5e6
Name Colour
𝓣𝓲𝓷𝓾𝓿𝓲𝓮𝓵
Warrior Fanatic
All hail me, the flower-flushing queen of Prague
|
Post by 𝓣𝓲𝓷𝓾𝓿𝓲𝓮𝓵 on Mar 31, 2017 10:37:03 GMT -5
@maplefrost: That still doesn't change the fact that they became mentors not long after becoming warriors and the young age is sometimes pointed out. Sometimes it works out, sometimes it doesn't. That's the point I'm trying to make. Leafshine: I just want to point out that cats mentoring their kin isn't that uncommon. And I don't just mean cousins either. Kin mentor their own kin all the time. And I don't mean cousins either. Here are a few examples of cats being mentors to their kits, grandkits, siblings, nieces, or nephews: Poppycloud, Petalnose, Windflight, and Shellheart mentored their own kits. Whitetail temporarily mentored her daughter. Ivypool mentored her uncle. Fireheart mentored his nephew and Tigerheart mentored his niece. Whitewing and Poppycloud mentored their younger siblings and Tawnyspots his half-sister. Brackenfur mentored his granddaughter. That's odd because i thought it was a rule? Firestar was very young too when he became Cloudpaw's mentor. And i found this on the warriors wiki, a section from the site which explains what a mentor is: However, it does not matter how experienced a warrior is; when a cat is made a warrior, they can then be a mentor at any time. Leaders usually only train the deputy's kits and other kits of important heritage, like Bluestar mentoring Firestar, as he is the subject of an important prophecy. It's not really a rule, it just isn't recommended since some cats can be soft on their kin, like with Petalnose and Sagenose. And though this was before the Clans officially came to be, Jagged Peak mentored one of his sons and even he admitted it wasn't the best idea for that same reason. As for leaders mentoring deputy's kits, that's not necessarily true. But yeah, I agree. Once a cat is a warrior, they can become a mentor no matter their age.
|
|
|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Mar 31, 2017 22:32:09 GMT -5
They are most definitely still young warriors though lol, but not newly made warriors. Molewhisker and Cherrytail were born in the Fourth Apprentice, they became apprentices in the Forgotten Warrior, the second to last book in OotS, they've been kits for 5 books. They're not warriors until the time skip to BrS, which is around when Amber, Dew, Snow, and Lily are apprentices. They become warriors at the end of BrS, and Fernsong and his littermates are apprentices in the bonus comic. They're warriors by the time AVoS starts, but by then this is JUST NOW when Mole and Cherry are getting apprentices. So yes Snow and his gen are young, but Fern is even younger, and the newest warriors like Spark are even younger, and then the new warriors in TAS are younger then them. Do I see Snow, Amber, Dew and Lily possibly getting their first apprentices before the end of AVoS? Sure. There still like 3 more books to go. But it makes you wonder, by your logic, why didn't any of them get one of Lily's kits. *shrug* I highly doubt Lionblaze will become the next leader considering Bramblestar already easily overlooked him for Squirrelflight when he became leader. I don't get how you're saying that Ivypool should get a break in favor of a background character, but then turn around and say Lionblaze should have gotten Twigpaw because you think he should be the next leader...that's very contradicting. Wasptail and Stonewing were newly made warrios when they got their apprentices. And of course Lilyheart and Snowbush can't mentor their own kits? They became in a very young age parents. And Ambermoon and Dewnose are aunt and uncle to Leafkit, Honeykit and Larkkit. They are kin, therefore they were not choosen as their mentors. I knew that Bramblestar would choose Squirrelflight over Lionblaze. He was too young at that time for deputyship, but that doesn't always matter. (Just remember Hawkwing and Firestar). A clan leader mostly pick up more experienced warrior for deputy. But if Squirrelflight dies it is very possible that he would choose Lionblaze. I did never say that Lionblaze should be Twigpaws mentor instead of Ivypool! There's been cases of aunt/uncle having kin apprentices, even older siblings. It's just that parents don't get apprentices that are their own kits because they believed they'd be too soft on them. SkyClan goes by different rules than the other clans. And Bluestar chose Firestar due to her paranoia after Tigerstar tried to kill her, Firestar was the only cat she trusted. But you mentioned Lionblaze as one of the cats that could have gotten Twigpaw as an apprentices.....
|
|
|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Mar 31, 2017 22:35:47 GMT -5
I personally still think newly made warriors shouldn't be given apprentices so quickly. I feel like they should earn that privilege first, not thinking they automatically get it with the warrior title.
|
|
|
Post by Leafshine on Apr 1, 2017 4:34:42 GMT -5
Wasptail and Stonewing were newly made warrios when they got their apprentices. And of course Lilyheart and Snowbush can't mentor their own kits? They became in a very young age parents. And Ambermoon and Dewnose are aunt and uncle to Leafkit, Honeykit and Larkkit. They are kin, therefore they were not choosen as their mentors. I knew that Bramblestar would choose Squirrelflight over Lionblaze. He was too young at that time for deputyship, but that doesn't always matter. (Just remember Hawkwing and Firestar). A clan leader mostly pick up more experienced warrior for deputy. But if Squirrelflight dies it is very possible that he would choose Lionblaze. I did never say that Lionblaze should be Twigpaws mentor instead of Ivypool! There's been cases of aunt/uncle having kin apprentices, even older siblings. It's just that parents don't get apprentices that are their own kits because they believed they'd be too soft on them. SkyClan goes by different rules than the other clans. And Bluestar chose Firestar due to her paranoia after Tigerstar tried to kill her, Firestar was the only cat she trusted. But you mentioned Lionblaze as one of the cats that could have gotten Twigpaw as an apprentices..... I never mentioned Lionblaze directly, i just said that anyone could have been Twigpaw's mentor.
|
|