|
Post by moonwisker on Mar 21, 2017 13:31:15 GMT -5
Yes me too. Though I at first though it was about Wind Clan's medican cat before they left the forest for the lake. He did have a simaliar name to Hawkwing's. I can't remember it exectaly but it did have "Hawk" in it so I though it would be a book about Wind Clan.
|
|
|
Post by lilaceyes on Apr 4, 2017 21:23:14 GMT -5
The thing that really confused me was the length of the journey itself. I know that they went to Barley's farm..but once they passed by their old home going back, it should have only taken them like 2 or 3 days to find the lake. It only took Alderpaw's group like 2 days to find the old SkyClan home. And shouldn't Alderpaw's group have passed the remaining SkyClan cats?
|
|
|
Post by moonwisker on Apr 5, 2017 17:20:32 GMT -5
Alderpaw's group went straight to their territory. The book made it sound like the never went no where near the old Clan's territory. Plus Alderpaw saw the old Median Cat's den and noticed how all the growing herbs where dead that at least takes more then about 3-5 days to do.
|
|
ωαтєяsнα∂є
it is I!!! Howlingthroat/musical chairs!!!
|
Post by ωαтєяsнα∂є on Jun 4, 2017 20:03:56 GMT -5
I thought it was VERY strange that after the first journey to SkyClan camp, it goes from like 2 moons to 1 moon, to half a moon to get there for the patrols (first squirrelflight's then Dovewing's, then Twigpaws). super weird.
I still think it took at least 3 moons from the time Darktail chased SkyClan out to Alderpaw's patrol to arrive. It takes at least 2 months for plants to truly to get as scrawny as they were and scents to get muddled. And Mistfeather to get so thin
|
|
|
Post by Alpha on Jun 5, 2017 11:25:52 GMT -5
stop trying to apply genetics to the books guys
stop
The Erins are horrible at consistency.
|
|
|
Post by Tas on Jun 5, 2017 11:31:12 GMT -5
Every time any cats have gone anywhere in AVoS and HJ, it hasn't made ANY sense. at all.
i had a thread on it a gooooood long while ago...
|
|
|
Post by sparklepaw on Jun 10, 2017 2:17:07 GMT -5
Every time any cats have gone anywhere in AVoS and HJ, it hasn't made ANY sense. at all. i had a thread on it a gooooood long while ago... Yeah, I understand that! I try not to think about it too much, because then my head just starts to hurt and I accept it doesn't make much sense....it bothered me a little bit at first but then I got used to it and kind of started ignoring those details. I just do NOT understand how the lengths of time it takes these cats to get places based on previous books where things seemed to take much longer? Or maybe I'm just misunderstanding things and misconstruing things in my own mind, haha.
|
|
|
Post by moonwisker on Jun 10, 2017 14:29:55 GMT -5
I think for this book the left out a lot of the details they added to the other Clan's jurany to the new territory.
|
|
|
Post by Katanaheart on Jun 10, 2017 17:05:41 GMT -5
Yes me too. Though I at first though it was about Wind Clan's medican cat before they left the forest for the lake. He did have a simaliar name to Hawkwing's. I can't remember it exectaly but it did have "Hawk" in it so I though it would be a book about Wind Clan. Hawkheart. He was the medicine cat before Barkface. Hawkheart probably died a good while before Firestar joined ThunderClan. (Hawkheart is listed as WindClan's medicine cat in BP, CP, YS, and TR.)
|
|