|
|
Post by Mistybreeze on Nov 18, 2024 14:38:37 GMT -5
How do we feel about the current cast of characters? Warriors names, new kits, new ships etc? ThunderClan First, there should have been a few deaths between arcs. ThunderClan is so overcrowded.
The new warrior names are pretty boring. Gray has so many good options and they go with -whisker? Seriously??
Most of the new kit prefixes are fine. Really hate Shine though. Especially for a black cat. She should have been called Raven.
As for Myrtlebloom's mate, he could literally be anyone. I actually want an age gap this time. Stormcloud or Molewhisker both need kits. ShadowClan Yay to BlazexLight kits! Solid names too.
There are a ton of options for Red&Spruce's parents. I would assume SpirexFringe if Fringe wasn't a mentor to one. Tigerstar does seem to think out mentor apprentice pairings. I doubt he'd apprentice Sprucepaw to her own mother. Maybe Whorl/Flower with a younger cat?
Warrior names are okay. Birchfeather is weird, and I really don't like -ripple as a suffix. Just looks off to me. Bloompetal is really pretty. WindClan For Fluff&Silky's parents, I prefer CrouchxBrindle or at least Brindle with an older tom. There's a ton of single toms in the Clan.
As for Appleshine's mate, I'm thinking Slightfoot or Hootwhisker. Regardless, yay to BreezexHeather grandkits!
The warrior names are decent, though I see they used -ripple again. RiverClan I have to join the chorus of Floatshimmer is too young to be a mother. I probably would have picked Minnowtail or Shimmerpelt instead. As for her mate, I prefer Owlnose in spite of the big age gap.
RiverClan should have had multiple litter of kits since Star. At least one set of apprentices and a couple litters in the nursery.
I see Icestar prefers lyrical names. Floatshimmer is really pretty. I'd stir clear of using -splash as a suffix for awhile though.
SkyClan Did we really need two -shines in a row? Duskshine doesn't even make sense! Dusk is dull and dreary, not bright and shiny. There are so many better options for Dusk. Beesting is amazing, as is Ridgeglow.
Didn't see KitexNeedle coming. I do love the bird theme for their kits. Such classic SkyClan names.
Glad to see Cherrytail and Sparrowpelt in the elder's den. Everyone older than Harrybrook should be there tbh. |
|
|
|
Post by owlsight on Nov 18, 2024 14:44:11 GMT -5
I thought Crowfeather and Tawnypelt would be elders by now, but I’m certain they will by the end, though I do see a possibility that Crowfeather stays deputy since Tawnypelt is apparently too young to become an elder, and Crowfeather is two years younger then her.
Whatever happens I hope Crowfeather retires eventually, I really don’t want him as leader, not because I dislike him, but I really hate how these grandpas and grandmas keep surviving all the way to leader while they outlive the entirety of their leaders 9 lives, like can we get more deputy deaths? I like Owlnose but maybe he will.
|
|
Non-binary
flipwish
when do we get more hairless warrior cats
|
Post by flipwish on Nov 18, 2024 15:06:52 GMT -5
GET PODLIGHT OUTTA THERE
|
|
|
|
Post by Flanoir on Nov 18, 2024 16:34:14 GMT -5
Ah, NeedlexKite... Pebbleshine's granddaughter and Pebbleshine's nephew getting together 😅
Even weirder when you remember that Violetshine herself is from a cousin x cousin relationship
|
|
|
|
Post by lightfur on Nov 18, 2024 17:37:59 GMT -5
WHY IS FLOATSHIMMER A QUEEN. WHY WHY WHY.
She was a kitten last book, and now she's immediately a mother? It's pretty surprising that all of the SneezeHaven kits are warriors now. I'd expect the other kits to be warriors by then, but I thought they'd still be apprentices, along with the FeatherOat's kits. Bloompetal is described to have been made a warrior recently, which doesn't make much sense because all the younger cats are already warriors.
I'm pretty sure Floatshimmer is 11 moons old. (She's 3 at the end of Star, Sunbeam has her kits so that's two months, and they are apprentice age in TEQ so that's 6 more months, so that adds up to 11 moons.) Which would have meant she was 9 moons when she first got pregnant, which is even WORSE. (I've seen people say it was possible she was pregnant when she was a apprentice and I don't even want to get into that.) That's not getting started on who the father is. I've seen speculation that it's Graysky, and they are related... The best case scenario is for them to not specify the father at all. (but she really shouldn't have been a queen at all...) The worst case scenario is that it's anyone else...
If they wanted more RiverClan members, they could make Gorseclaw x Nightsky a thing. They aren't related and are the same age.
|
|
|
|
Post by Saint Ambrosef on Nov 18, 2024 18:01:26 GMT -5
Do we actually know when NightxSun had their kits? My understanding is that it happened sometime after the events of ASC but that its not actually specified when.
|
|
maggotpaw
boss makes a dollar, i make a dime. that's why i discuss warrior cats on company time
|
Post by maggotpaw on Nov 18, 2024 18:41:39 GMT -5
WHY IS FLOATSHIMMER A QUEEN. WHY WHY WHY. She was a kitten last book, and now she's immediately a mother? It's pretty surprising that all of the SneezeHaven kits are warriors now. I'd expect the other kits to be warriors by then, but I thought they'd still be apprentices, along with the FeatherOat's kits. Bloompetal is described to have been made a warrior recently, which doesn't make much sense because all the younger cats are already warriors. I'm pretty sure Floatshimmer is 11 moons old. (She's 3 at the end of Star, Sunbeam has her kits so that's two months, and they are apprentice age in TEQ so that's 6 more months, so that adds up to 11 moons.) Which would have meant she was 9 moons when she first got pregnant, which is even WORSE. (I've seen people say it was possible she was pregnant when she was a apprentice and I don't even want to get into that.) That's not getting started on who the father is. I've seen speculation that it's Graysky, and they are related... The best case scenario is for them to not specify the father at all. (but she really shouldn't have been a queen at all...) The worst case scenario is that it's anyone else... If they wanted more RiverClan members, they could make Gorseclaw x Nightsky a thing. They aren't related and are the same age. And despite being the best (named) option as the only tom anywhere near her age, Graysky is still too old for her... even if you do the most generous math possible, it's like a 24 year old getting a 14-16 year old pregnant. The whole thing is so odd, even if it's natural for cats. Saint Ambrosef There's a time skip, but it's not that long. Star takes place at the start of leaf-bare, and the last chapter is like... mid leaf-bare? (Nightheart remarks that it's still a "long way to newleaf") and Sunbeam is pregnant by then. |
|
|
|
Post by Galestorm on Nov 18, 2024 19:29:22 GMT -5
I’m happy to see Golden- be used again. I think it’s adorable Oakkit and Hazelkit share white spots although many cats born recently are spotted: Graywhisker, Leafcurl, and Troutshine.
I’m a little disappointed in some of the newer names, -shines just being overly used right now across all the Clans. I like the -ripple suffix a lot but I hate to see it given to two cats of the same age. I also don’t like Branchleap’s name because his older sister is named Songleap, and we were so worried about Whistlepaw being named Whistlesong.
As for Leafcurl and Rapidsplash, the names are lovely and visually appealing, but WHY would Icestar name Rapidkit that name when her older brother, Splashtail, took over RiverClan and nearly destroyed it. As for Harestar, why use -curl when Curlfeather was orchestrated the whole thing. Floatshimmer is a beautiful name though. |
|
|
|
Post by Saint Ambrosef on Nov 19, 2024 2:03:24 GMT -5
WHY IS FLOATSHIMMER A QUEEN. WHY WHY WHY. She was a kitten last book, and now she's immediately a mother? It's pretty surprising that all of the SneezeHaven kits are warriors now. I'd expect the other kits to be warriors by then, but I thought they'd still be apprentices, along with the FeatherOat's kits. Bloompetal is described to have been made a warrior recently, which doesn't make much sense because all the younger cats are already warriors. I'm pretty sure Floatshimmer is 11 moons old. (She's 3 at the end of Star, Sunbeam has her kits so that's two months, and they are apprentice age in TEQ so that's 6 more months, so that adds up to 11 moons.) Which would have meant she was 9 moons when she first got pregnant, which is even WORSE. (I've seen people say it was possible she was pregnant when she was a apprentice and I don't even want to get into that.) That's not getting started on who the father is. I've seen speculation that it's Graysky, and they are related... The best case scenario is for them to not specify the father at all. (but she really shouldn't have been a queen at all...) The worst case scenario is that it's anyone else... If they wanted more RiverClan members, they could make Gorseclaw x Nightsky a thing. They aren't related and are the same age. And despite being the best (named) option as the only tom anywhere near her age, Graysky is still too old for her... even if you do the most generous math possible, it's like a 24 year old getting a 14-16 year old pregnant. The whole thing is so odd, even if it's natural for cats. Saint Ambrosef There's a time skip, but it's not that long. Star takes place at the start of leaf-bare, and the last chapter is like... mid leaf-bare? (Nightheart remarks that it's still a "long way to newleaf") and Sunbeam is pregnant by then. Is there any reason this couldn’t be the following leaf-bare rather than the same one that the events of Star occur? That would perhaps make more sense with a few things. |
|
|
|
Post by *Faith* on Nov 24, 2024 18:19:13 GMT -5
ThunderClan: I was hoping for Grayspots, personally. As for Myrtlebloom's mate, right now, until said otherwise, I headcanon it as Stemtail. He and Sunkit are both ginger tabby toms. I love how Oakkit is basically a mix of her mother and uncle Bayshine's description, though. ShadowClan: I so far really love Poolkit. She's a cutie! I think this is the first pool since Poolcloud. As for Sprucepaw and Redpaw, either Grassheart and Stonewing had another litter, or Flowerpaw/Whorlpelt (like you said) is the parent. I LOVE Bloompetal's name! I honestly thought that Streamripple would be the one to get a fast suffix as she was said to be really fast in Star. Unless ripple is also supposed to mean fast, like the movement of the river. WindClan: Both of Appleshine's kits are brown and white, so I was thinking Flutterfoot. They are around the same age. Silkypaw is gray. while Fluffpaw is brown. If FeatherxOat didn't just have another litter, I'd think them. Lol! SedgexEmber also fits. Though, I like the idea of Brindlewing or Woodsong also having kits. I personally see Slightfoot as Larkwing's mate because of Brookripple. Oh, well. Maybe the family tree will give us a mate for Appleshine. It did for both Reedclaw and Blossomheart. Also, Nightcloud is now an elder. RiverClan: Yeah, Floatshimmer isn't even a year yet. She was born in leaf-bare and now it's leaf-fall. Also, they changed her description from tawny she-kit to black she-cat. It they wanted a dark furred queen, Minnowtail and Nightsky are both dark gray. Graysky might be the father since one of the kits is silver, like him. SkyClan: Robinpaw and Starlingpaw don't just look like their parents, but continue on with their father's bird theme naming. Yep, Cherry and Sparrow are now elders. I'm a little surprised that Tinycloud isn't there, though.
|
|
Pansexual
Dawn Sunlight
I love the RiverClan that lives in my head
|
Post by Dawn Sunlight on Nov 24, 2024 23:39:55 GMT -5
WHY IS FLOATSHIMMER A QUEEN. WHY WHY WHY. She was a kitten last book, and now she's immediately a mother? It's pretty surprising that all of the SneezeHaven kits are warriors now. I'd expect the other kits to be warriors by then, but I thought they'd still be apprentices, along with the FeatherOat's kits. Bloompetal is described to have been made a warrior recently, which doesn't make much sense because all the younger cats are already warriors. I'm pretty sure Floatshimmer is 11 moons old. (She's 3 at the end of Star, Sunbeam has her kits so that's two months, and they are apprentice age in TEQ so that's 6 more months, so that adds up to 11 moons.) Which would have meant she was 9 moons when she first got pregnant, which is even WORSE. (I've seen people say it was possible she was pregnant when she was a apprentice and I don't even want to get into that.) That's not getting started on who the father is. I've seen speculation that it's Graysky, and they are related... The best case scenario is for them to not specify the father at all. (but she really shouldn't have been a queen at all...) The worst case scenario is that it's anyone else... If they wanted more RiverClan members, they could make Gorseclaw x Nightsky a thing. They aren't related and are the same age. I genuinely can't believe it's looking like the Erins are never going to pair a LakeLizard kit with Nightsky or Breezeheart. They're about the same age and not related at all, so I thought it was only a matter of time before it happened, especially since RiverClan desperately needs more kits. But at this point there's only Nightsky and Gorseclaw left, and if they were going to pair them up, this would have been the perfect time to do it. But they didn't for some reason.
Also as much as I hate the idea because it smashes my headcanons, Brackenpelt x Podlight would have also worked perfectly fine.
|
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Nov 25, 2024 0:26:07 GMT -5
SkyClan: Robinpaw and Starlingpaw don't just look like their parents, but continue on with their father's bird theme naming. Yep, Cherry and Sparrow are now elders. I'm a little surprised that Tinycloud isn't there, though. Well, Tinycloud IS Sparrowpelt's former apprentice. It would be a little weird if they ended up elders at the same time (I think). |
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Nov 25, 2024 1:03:12 GMT -5
Do we actually know when NightxSun had their kits? My understanding is that it happened sometime after the events of ASC but that its not actually specified when. They become apprentices basically at the beginning of TEQ, making them about six moons old at the start of Chapter 3. So six months prior to TEQ I guess, which is definitely after Star finished. Sorry, that proably wasn't much help. |
|
|
|
Post by Mistybreeze on Nov 25, 2024 5:39:55 GMT -5
All things considered, it makes the most sense for the Star timeskip to be a year instead of a moon. The season TEQ starts in, the existence of older apprentices, Floatshimmer being a queen etc. I don't recall reading anything about how many moons it had been since the earlier events of Star in that last chapter either.
It would also mean Night&Sun stuck to their word and waited to have kits. Now if only FinxTwig would finally have some. |
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Nov 25, 2024 5:57:25 GMT -5
All things considered, it makes the most sense for the Star timeskip to be a year instead of a moon. The season TEQ starts in, the existence of older apprentices, Floatshimmer being a queen etc. I don't recall reading anything about how many moons it had been since the earlier events of Star in that last chapter either.
It would also mean Night&Sun stuck to their word and waited to have kits. Now if only FinxTwig would finally have some. I hope they don't. |
|
|
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Nov 25, 2024 7:25:52 GMT -5
what is buddy doing still there😭😭 is he like camping in the back of riverclan not making eye contact with anyone or something?? He's probably keeping his head pretty low. That's the only thing that makes sense... |
|
Aroace
#b6efff
Name Colour
Dɾҽαɱƈʅσυԃ
Villain Enjoyer
Arcane Season 2 has got me in a chokehold once again (do not send help)
|
Post by Dɾҽαɱƈʅσυԃ on Nov 25, 2024 9:03:25 GMT -5
Glad that -glow is a canon suffix now because I just love it <3
|
|
duskflower
I can talk about these cats all day and that is a problem
|
Post by duskflower on Nov 26, 2024 8:37:00 GMT -5
omg imagine one of the elders saw Shinekit (maybe Brambleclaw or Brackenfur) and was like "omg she looks like Ravenpaw. remind our old friend?" and they told his story and then Nightheart, even tho he didnt like being named after a cat, would be moved by Ravenpaw's underdog story and name his daughter after him. oh what a fanfiction that would be.
|
|
