Pixie
2024 is already bad; 2025 will be my year fr
|
Post by Pixie on Apr 7, 2024 13:25:09 GMT -5
How would you rank these cats: Tigerstar, Brokenstar, Scourge, Hawkfrost, Mapleshade, One Eye, Slash, Darktail, Ashfur, Curlfeather, Berryheart, and Splashtail. If you want to add in any extra ones, go ahead.
|
|
|
Post by cygna on Apr 7, 2024 14:15:19 GMT -5
Mapleshade - Just in CP & MV though. I don’t care about her anywhere else.
Tigerstar - He was good, but nothing special.
Darktail - Actually insane. He was so brutal & actually a threat. Him going to the DF and dying felt so pointless though, he’s not a clan cat and it would’ve been more impactful to never see him again like Scourge.
Ashfur - Super Chaotic.
Scourge - Not enough time but he was fun while we had him.
Hawkfrost - He’s all right I guess. Wasted potential overall but his dynamic with Ivypool was fun & he was enjoyable in Mothwing’s Secret.
Brokenstar - His ridiculously stupid but the way he killed his father was super grotesque and the was he treated kits was impactful in a horrifying way. Yellowfang killing him both times was so satisfying though.
Splashtail - I think he could be higher by the end of the arc, his impact wasn’t big enough yet though.
Sleekwhisker - I wish she was more prominent ngl.
Berryheart - I don’t care about her enough honestly. She’s just kinda annoying.
Thistleclaw - Genuinely creepy in SH, barely any impact as a villain though.
Sol/Darkstripe - I just don’t think about them a lot.
Those forgettable dudes from DOTC - I think their names were One Eye & Slash or something. I just kinda forgot everything they did.
|
|
|
Post by Hollyfall on Apr 7, 2024 15:21:41 GMT -5
1. Ashfur - Didn't think much of him in PoT but loved him in TBC. Absolutely unhinged and chaotic, and I love how they wrote him. I think he's also a rather complex character, for what it's worth. 2. Tigerstar I - A classic but still good. 3. Darktail - He had potential but they killed him off too soon. At the height of his power he controlled half of the lake territories and had two Clans on the backfoot. 4. Splashtail - He's a much better written version of Hawkfrost imo. I like his rise to power and he's really compelling. 5. Curlfeather - She's awesome but she was in one book, so sadly she's lower than I'd like her to be. I wish she got more time on the page. 6. Mapleshade - She's good but feels way overused. She really just should have stayed as someone who wanted to end Appledusk's bloodline and not get shoehorned into other books. 7. Scourge - Might be more nostolgia talking but I like how he just rocked up, killed Tigerstar, and proved to be quite a threat. 8. Hawkfrost - I don't hate him, but he honestly felt just like a discount Tigerstar. A redemption arc for him would have better, at least to me. 9. Brokenstar - Very one dimensional and a rather generic cookie-cutter villain, but I didn't mind him? I like the small amounts of hidden depths he got in Yellowfang's and Blackfoot's depths, but overall his personality just being straight up "evil" detracts a lot. 10. Thistleclaw - I preferred him when he just seemed to be a ThunderClan nationalist and not a creep like he is in SH. 11. Sleekwhisker - Kind of a one-note villain. If she appeared more, or even did anything beyond being Darktail's lackey, then maybe. 12. One Eye & Slash - I like One Eye a little more but tbh I found them dull and rather uninteresting. With Slash especially, it felt like they were just injected into the story for the sake of having a villain. 13. Berryheart - Only because I think she's teetering on the border between "antagonist" and "villain", leaning towards villain as of Wind.
|
|
|
Post by NightFrostSun on Apr 7, 2024 16:26:03 GMT -5
Ashfur, then Darktail, then Brokenstar, then Tigerstar, then Curlfeather, then Mapleshade, then Scourge, then Sol, then Thistleclaw, then Darkstripe, then Sleekwhisker, then Splashtail, then Hawkfrost, then One Eye, then Slash, then Berryheart.
|
|