Needletail and the others *TAS spoilers*
Sept 7, 2016 6:38:06 GMT -5
via mobile
❅Maplefrost❅ likes this
Post by 𝕡𝕖𝕡𝕡𝕖𝕣𝕞𝕚𝕟𝕥 on Sept 7, 2016 6:38:06 GMT -5
Will Needletail and the rest of the ShadowClan traitors go to the Dark Forest when they die, even if they rejoin the Clan?
My answer: possibly.
According to the wiki,
Though this may be somewhat subjective, I believe that most of us can agree that treachery falls under "great crimes". Needletail and the others openly reject the code, claiming that it brings nothing but bloodshed. Even if they decide to atone later down the line, they started a rebellion against their leader, disobeyed him more often than obeying him, and brought their former Clan's security crashing to the ground.
This probably doesn't apply to the cats who stayed behind without supporting the rebellion, since they were pressured into it and scared out of their wits.
This probably doesn't apply to Violetpaw or not. She was forced into the rogue's ranks as a kit, but returned to the Clan. However, we can assume that she engaged in anti-code behavior with full knowledge of the consequences, without much of a choice.
What do you think?
My answer: possibly.
According to the wiki,
It is a place where cats that have committed great crimes against their Clans and against the Warrior Code go when they die. However, cats who commit crimes but believe they are following the Warrior Code by doing them can usually join the ranks of StarClan instead, like Mudclaw or Ashfur.
Though this may be somewhat subjective, I believe that most of us can agree that treachery falls under "great crimes". Needletail and the others openly reject the code, claiming that it brings nothing but bloodshed. Even if they decide to atone later down the line, they started a rebellion against their leader, disobeyed him more often than obeying him, and brought their former Clan's security crashing to the ground.
This probably doesn't apply to the cats who stayed behind without supporting the rebellion, since they were pressured into it and scared out of their wits.
This probably doesn't apply to Violetpaw or not. She was forced into the rogue's ranks as a kit, but returned to the Clan. However, we can assume that she engaged in anti-code behavior with full knowledge of the consequences, without much of a choice.
What do you think?
