|
Post by Chicken on Apr 6, 2024 19:58:45 GMT -5
If you could kill off 3 non-elder cats per clan, who would they be and why?
|
|
|
Post by .: pouncefeather :. on Apr 6, 2024 21:17:10 GMT -5
TC: Eaglewing, what does she do?? Whitewing, her or her parents gotta go, i'm not gonna let them be in the elders den at the same time Lionblaze, don't see him much and it would stir up some good drama ShC: Tawnypelt, i love her so much but istg she's a fossil Snowbird, I love her sm, but, shes also getting a little old, i mean her daughter is berryheart is described as old Blazefire- just for fun and to also get some drama going, maybe lightleap being reckless got him killed SkC: Harrybrook- old Sparrowpelt- Idk (i think he's weird bc his mate was his apprentice) Nettlesplash- who? WC: Slightfoot- Too many "foot" suffixes in WC, might make Harestar extra sad Crouchfoot- I only need two "foot" names in this clan Kestrelflight- Just for drama, leave Whistlepaw mentorless RC (finally): Mothwing- she's old and i need drama Duskfur- more old, more drama, now related to frostpaw! Mallownose- also old sorta (this took me 30+ mins help)
|
|
|
Post by Katanaheart on Apr 6, 2024 21:32:54 GMT -5
TC: Squirrelstar to get her out of the narrative. Ivypool as I don’t really want her to ascend to leadership. Throw in a more interesting character like Cinderheart, Eaglewing, Plumstone, or give someone like Honeyfur or Leafshade personality as deputy or leader. Bayshine or Myrtlebloom, there’s enough Lionblaze blood around so either sibling can go.
SC: Tigerstar II: Give me Cloverstar already. Scorchfur Snowbird The latter two are too old and are likely better off dead if they can’t be elders. If one becomes an elder and the other dies, Dovewing or Lightleap would be my other choices.
SkyClan: Leafstar: While I appreciate her as the only sane man most days, she’s too old and needs to kick the bucket. Harrybrook-I just don’t like your name and your sisters were superior. Sparrowpelt/Cherrytail-Both need to go to the elder’s den or shoved into coffins if neither retire.
RiverClan: Sneezecloud-Never liked his name. Mallownose-I’m just not big on the nose suffix. Icewing-I just don’t like how she’s a kinda Tigerstar II puppet, I’m still in the middle of Shadow and everyone else needs to be kept around for plot reasons or I like their names too much. If not needed for plot reasons, Fognose should be here.
WindClan: Crowfeather-To death with you since you won’t retire. Crouchfoot-I really hate the crouch prefix, just throw this entire man in the trash. Slightfoot or Breezepelt-I don’t like the Slight prefix either but I’d also be fine with Breezepelt losing further narrative relevance. I’m more interested in your daughters having screentime before another one dies and you and your dad keep hogging WindClan spotlight.
|
|
|
Post by Snowfire on Apr 7, 2024 0:38:45 GMT -5
TC: Leafshade- is she even alive at this point? She hasn't shown up since TPONS, what's the purpose of having her name in the allegiance? Lionblaze- Honestly it's been a while since we had a former protagonist died, I think he's an interesting pick. I could definitely see him dying during battle Plumstone- There are so many BlossomThorn kits, plus I don't like her after what she tried doing during Thunder ShC: Tigerstar II- CLOVERSTAR 2024 Blazefire and/or Lightleap, I'm with Pouncefeather, I want Lightleap's recklessness to have a consequence, whether it's getting Blaze or herself killed, maybe both. I also do not want anymore potential Tigerclones, or any TigerFirekin POVs in that matter. If only one of the former is killed, Tawnypelt- she's old, she deserves some rest
SkC: Leafstar- Sorry Leafstar I love you but I think it's time you are put to rest Sparrowpelt- probably very old at this point Gravelnose- Similar to Leafshade, he has only three appearences in the series, his last one being VOS
WC: Crowfeather- Sorry dude but I want Deputy Sedgewhisker, Hootwhisker, or Breezepelt Emberfoot- Too many -foots Slightfoot- ^
RC: Podlight- I just don't like him after how he treated Frostpaw Duskfur- Super old Mothwing- ^
|
|
|
Post by ~Phoenixwing~ on Apr 7, 2024 1:36:47 GMT -5
Hm, good question, because a lot of the backgrounds aren't really all the special ThC: -Hollytuft, please put her to rest. Having a replacement Hollyleaf has always been wrong. -Mousewhisker, if you're not gonna do anything by this point, just.. idk -Fernsong, I just don't like him. He never was even shown to follow through with his words and he's just a generic legacy name character RvC: -Owlnose, you coward -Podlight, just because -I don't even know who to put here. Fognose? Mallownose? Sneezecloud? Take your pick. WdC: -Crouchfoot, what is that name even -Oatclaw, let's have Harelight's kits have some shared loss to bond over next arc -Flutterfoot, I guess, there's too many members of this family. ShC: -Yarrowleaf, they've served their purpose. -Gullswoop, just because I'd rather keep Spireclaw and Hollowspring alive, but there are too many Berrykin -Flowerstem, who even is this, have they ever done anything SkC: -Hawkwing, I don't want a Hawkstar, make things interesting -Leafstar, I do want her to die though. She's been kinda antagonistic lately too. -Needleclaw, again, I am so tired of legacy names, and basically 'replacing' dead characters, it's wrong. Edit: Me here trying to figure out how people even like this series if they want to kill off all the former protags so badly
|
|
|
Post by moongloweevee on Apr 7, 2024 1:49:49 GMT -5
Thunderclan: Squirrelstar- for obvious reasons Jayfeather- seriously, everytime we get a medicine cat pov; he's always 'come on, we don't have all night!' Whitewing- she's becoming ancient
Shadowclan: Tigerstar Flaxfoot Lightleap
Skyclan: Leafstar Pigeonfoot (what's with all the -foot suffixes?) Nettlesplash
Windclan: Crowfeather Nightcloud Crouchfoot
Riverclan: Mothwing Podlight Owlnose
|
|
|
Post by cygna on Apr 7, 2024 2:11:14 GMT -5
Thunderclan: Thornclaw, Bramblestar, Squirrelflight
Riverclan: Idgaf as long as it’s not Frostpaw, Mothwing, or Gorseclaw
Skyclan: Mintfur, Nettlesplash, Leafstar
Shadowclan: Snowbird, Dovewing, Tigerstar II
Windclan: Anyone other than the Crowfeather family, Heathertail, & Harestar because they’re the ONLY not boring characters there.
|
|
|
Post by dahliadove - #1 nightpelt fan on Apr 7, 2024 3:09:03 GMT -5
big paragraphs under the spoilers, also spoilers for ASC. none for Wind though ThunderClan: - Jayfeather. I know I hate him so this seems biased, but Lionblaze has done almost nothing this arc and it wouldn't have the same shock factor if he were to suddenly drop dead. The current arc would seem 100x more serious if it randomly killed off a former protagonist and fan favourite. That being said, killing off Squirrelstar or Brambleclaw would have a similar effect, but I think they're more important than Jayfeather to the current plot, so I don't think killing them off would be a good move at this point in the story. - Alderheart. Sorry for the medcat attack. I actually don't mind Alderheart, but I don't think he's very important to the story right now and taking out one of ThunderClan's medcats would be a good move, maybe even both. I wanna see CRISIS, more than just what's happening now. - Maybe Twigbranch or Finleap? Have them be a target of Berryheart's little anti-"clanhopper" group that she left back at ShadowClan. I think that group has more potential as villains, and again I wanna see CRISIS. ShadowClan: - I guess Blazefire? There's nobody that I really want to see dead in ShadowClan. Blazefire's a background character with loose ties to a protagonist. Throw him to Splashtail or something. Same goes for the rest of this list. - Tawnypelt - Oakfur? No ties to a protagonist but he's really old. RiverClan: - Owlnose. Had potential and now it's gone. This arc loves wasted potential. He's done nothing despite literally being elected leader a few books ago, now he's just some background warrior. - Sneezecloud? - Podlight WindClan: - Crowfeather. I hate him so, so much. With Breezepelt's maturing, I think he'd be a better deputy than Crowfeather. I don't think we need any more second arc protagonists in positions of power than we already have. - Nightcloud. Sorry Breezepelt. I actually don't mind Nightcloud, but she hasn't really done anything in a while and I want all these older characters that have done nothing in recent arcs to get killed off, so the younger cats that haven't done anything yet can have spotlight. - Gorsetail or Whiskernose. These elders are ancient, we need a few gone. Though I wish we'd have gotten backstory on Gorsetail and Beechfur, cause apparently that was a thing. Which doesn't seem right, Gorsetail had a half-clan relationship and she hasn't said anything on current matters? SkyClan: - Leafstar. She's been leader for way too long and she's also been irritating me in the current arc. If you're annoying you get killed. Someone execute her please - Tree. The authors invented a massive conflict and then completely forgot they created a character to prevent conflicts. This is obvious by how Tree randomly shows up mid-arc to completely eradicate the conflict mostly off-screen. Seems like an asspull to get rid of a potentially really interesting conflict between ShadowClan and RiverClan. I genuinely thought it'd be the focus of the arc. And again, when the Clans are literally on the verge of war he disappears. Just kill him off already, the potential for conflict is being held back by him being alive, and it seems like they forget about him half the time anyways. - Rootspring. I thought he'd be more prominent this arc when he went on the journey with Sunbeam and Nightheart in Sky(?). But he wasn't. I really wanted insight on him grieving for Bristlefrost and him speaking out against the anti-"clanhoppers" but I have been let down yet again. It makes NO sense that he wasn't actively fighting against them. Also former protagonist. Kill him.
|
|
|
Post by Katanaheart on Apr 7, 2024 8:10:27 GMT -5
And now added in the other Clans! I also enjoy the irony of the first post mentioning that killing elders weren’t allowed but some elders were thrown in anyway for other people’s lists.
|
|
Asexual
#E0C6FF
Name Colour
Slightdapple
✨your local book nerd ✨
|
Post by Slightdapple on Apr 7, 2024 9:51:51 GMT -5
ThunderClan: Leafshade, or pretty much any other useless background character. Also Jayfeather and Lionblaze should at least retire if they don’t die. RiverClan: Splashtail and Podlight will likely be dead by the end of the arc, but other than that Mothwing. WindClan: Crowfeather. Please, please let some other cat be WC deputy. Heathertail or Sedgewhisker would be so much better. ShadowClan: TIGERSTAR II. Other than that, probably Flaxfoot or some other random background cats because ShadowClan is starting to have the same background cat problem as ThunderClan. SkyClan: Leafstar, but I hope she kills Tigerstar in Star.
|
|
|
Post by Ivyfalcon on Apr 7, 2024 10:49:19 GMT -5
ThunderClan: - Bumblestripe - dislike his name and him - Blossomfall - really don’t like her - Thriftear - hate this name
ShadowClan: - Scorchfur - don’t care for him, even though he’s done nothing recently - Snowbird - she’s old - Lightleap - never liked her much and Sunbeam’s reaction could be interesting
SkyClan: - Leafstar - we need a new leader (Hawkstar, though I am a bit worried they’ll ruin him) - Frecklewish - I hate her name - Fidgetflake - also hate his name, sorry SkyClan you get no medicine cats
WindClan: - Crowfeather - I don’t want him to become leader - Crouchfoot - dislike prefix - Hootwhisker - not a fan of this name either
RiverClan: - Podlight - dislike name and his personality in recent books - Sneezecloud - I hate his name - Owlnose - not a fan of his name and he’s not interesting anymore
I honestly don’t dislike that many cats so I guess I’ll just get rid of ones with names I don’t like if I need more
|
|