|
Post by Purdyisbestboi on Nov 21, 2023 17:33:20 GMT -5
Best in plot: Crookedstars Promise. There’s no other option. Best in character development: Tallstars Revenge. Tallstar is the best SE protagonist in my opinion, and he goes through the best arc. Best in villains: Crookedstars Promise. Mapleshade is at her peak in the book. Best in pacing: Firestar Quest. I like that the journey doesn’t take up too much time. Most Important: Bluestars Prophecy. Every single book between mapleshades vengeance and Into the Wild would not have been written if not for this book. Funniest: Graystripes Vow. Who doesn’t love Warriorclan! Best Friendship: Tallstars Revenge. What other option is there? Tall name is awesome! Still, am I the only person who noticed that Talltail called jake dumb a lot in the first few chapters they shared together? Best Traveling SE: Tallstars Revenge/Graystripes Vow. Both have development with their characters throughout the journey. I love journeys that end in failiure, and was really hoping it would happen in RH, but to no avail. Overall best: Came down to Crookedstars promise, only because Tallstars Revenge had horrible pacing. My favorite will always be Crowfeathers Trial.
|
|
|
|
Post by Quill on Nov 21, 2023 21:04:16 GMT -5
Best in plot: Tallstar's Revenge
Best in character development: Tallstar's Revenge
Best in villains: Hawkwing's Journey. Darktail is terrifying
Best in pacing: Crookedstar's Promise
Most Important: Hawkwing's Journey. It set up a lot of important things for AVOS
Funniest: SkyClan's Destinyl
Best Friendship: Tallstar's Revenge
Best Traveling SE: Hawkwing's Journey
Overall best: Tallstar's Revenge
|
|
|
|
|
Post by Slightdapple on Nov 21, 2023 21:24:44 GMT -5
Best in plot: Hawkwing's Journey
Best in character development: Leopardstar's Honor
Best in villains: Crookedstar's Promise
Best in pacing: Hawkwing's Journey
Most important: Firestar's Quest. It provides so much context about SkyClan.
Funniest: SkyClan's Destiny or Graystripe's Vow
Best Friendship: Tallstar's Revenge or Leopardstar's Honor
Best traveling SE: Graystripe's Vow
Overall best: Crookedstar's Promise
|
|
|
Post by Purdyisbestboi on Nov 21, 2023 21:25:18 GMT -5
Tallstar’s Revenge wasn’t a good SE. Sorry if this is controversial. Even though it's my second favorite, I understand why people don't like it. Tallstar is a very unlikeable protag and the pacing is bad.
|
|
Rainbow
oatwhisker
riverclan's med!!
Pronouns: it/it's, he/him
|
Post by oatwhisker on Nov 21, 2023 23:28:49 GMT -5
Tallstar’s Revenge wasn’t a good SE. Sorry if this is controversial. Even though it's my second favorite, I understand why people don't like it. Tallstar is a very unlikeable protag and the pacing is bad. you hit the nail right on the head
|
|
|
Post by Purdyisbestboi on Nov 22, 2023 13:12:44 GMT -5
Even though it's my second favorite, I understand why people don't like it. Tallstar is a very unlikeable protag and the pacing is bad. you hit the nail right on the head I still love it though, mainly for Jake, the message, and Shrewclaw.
|
|
Asexual
#A3E4D7
Name Colour
🍄🎶✨Brambleheart✨🎶🍄
rdj as doctor doom was not on my bingo card
Pronouns: She/her, they/them
|
Post by 🍄🎶✨Brambleheart✨🎶🍄 on Nov 22, 2023 16:15:06 GMT -5
Best in plot: Yellowfang's Secret. (oooo hot take i know) I enjoy the plot on how Yellowfang was unfairly destined to be a medicine cat due to her power, which led to the birth of StarClan's punishment AKA Brokenkit, and it was so sad having Yellowfang watch helplessly as Brokenstar grew up to be a horrible cat. Also I love biography SEs.
Best in character development: Crookedstar's Promise. Crookedkit went from being an insecure and neglected kit, to being trapped into a promise to serve his Clan above all else due to Mapleshade's grooming, to being Clan leader, to feeling like he can't love anyone without losing them. This leads Crookedstar to do to his surviving daughter what his mother did to him, only to have a reality check by Oakheart. Crookedstar realized that he was continuing the cycle and stopping it and disowning Mapleshade. He ended up staying loyal to his Clan but also learning that just because something may disappear doesn't mean you shouldn't cherish it.
Best in villains: Crookedstar's Promise DEFINITELY. Mapleshade is at her peak when it comes to manipulating those she wants revenge on. Also Rainflower is a horrible cat that represents being the child of a narcissist.
Best in pacing: Bluestar's Prophecy. It covers a large span of ThunderClan history without skipping over it (besides between Bluefur being deputy and Into the Wild). A model in biography pacing, imo.
Most Important: Bluestar's Prophecy for introducing so many characters that would be delved into in future books. Also sets the precedence for backstories of important cats.
Funniest: Firestar's Quest solely for Cherry and Boris, tied with Graystripe's Vow for WarriorClan. But the amount of errors in the Leopardstar's Honor is one of the most laughable things on earth.
Best Friendship: Tallstar and Jake. Bluestar and Rosetail. Yellowfang and Cloudpelt. Leopardstar and Sunfish. Graystripe and Gremlin. Onepaw and Brushpaw. Squirrelflight and Leafstar.
Best Traveling SE: Hawkwing's Journey. It is so tragic yet full of hope for SkyClan.
Overall best: Tied between Crookedstar's Promise, Crowfeather's Trial, and Hawkwing's Journey.
|
|
|
Post by mintleaf2 on Nov 22, 2023 18:27:24 GMT -5
Best in making me cry is bluestar’s prophecy
|
|
|
Post by Purdyisbestboi on Nov 22, 2023 22:14:05 GMT -5
Best in making me cry is bluestar’s prophecy Just reread whitekits reaction to snowfurs death for the millionth time. The way he lays down next to his mother and says he’ll stay out with her. It absolutely breaks me!
|
|
|
Post by silverstarpenguin on Nov 26, 2023 16:23:12 GMT -5
Best in plot:Yellowfang's Secret (Seeing her go from this normal kit to one of the most important series 1 characters after all she'd been through had been a long journey that seemed to go on for more than 40 chapters.) Best in character development:Crookedstar's Promise (He had been a personal role model to me on how to let go of the things I can't change. I'm glad his SE had turned him into a brave character rather than the weak leader we saw in The Prophecies Begin.) Best in villans:Hawkwing's journey (I was horrified at the way Darktail murdered Sharpclaw and the rest of his Clanmates, glad to see Dodge finally getting what he deserves.) Best in pacing:Squirrelflight's Hope (I like the way it handled the Clans-Sisters conflict, even though some cats shouldn't have gotten away that easily in the end after what they've done.) Most important:Bluestar's Prophecy (It would be harder for me to understand Blustar's character and what led to TPB if not for this SE.) Honestly, I haven't thought of any book for the "funniest" category. That's not the reason why I read Warriors. Best friendship: Leopardstar's Honor (I have very much enjoyed the friendships between Lepardstar, Whiteclaw and Leopardstar, Frogleap. I thought they all deserved more than this and I'm sorry for the way they ended.) Best travelling: Hawkwing's Journey (This isn't just a solo/pair quest, but of a full Clan, trying to survive at the same time. Sometimes I think there's no one braver than SkyClan.) Best overall: Moth Flight's Vision (I love the portrayal of a cat with mental health disabilities placed in a high position. Even tgough I don't agree with her final decision, this is still my favorite SE.)
|
|
|
Post by Purdyisbestboi on Dec 22, 2023 14:48:27 GMT -5
Bump
|
|
|
Post by Ivyfalcon on Dec 23, 2023 18:10:40 GMT -5
Best in plot: Hawkwing’s Journey
Best in character development: Hawkwing’s Journey
Best in villains: Crookedstar’s Promise
Best in pacing: Crookedstar’s Promise was pretty good I think, it again Hawkwing’s Journey
Most Important: Firestar’s Quest maybe?
Funniest: The only funny thing I can think of in one was for Crowfeather’s Trial so I guess that?
Best Friendship: Leopardstar’s Honor
Best Traveling SE: Hawkwing’s Journey
Overall best: Hawkwing’s Journey
|
|