Post by cygna on Jan 3, 2023 17:43:34 GMT -5
EDIT: My sincerest apologies for not including Alderheart & Nightheart in the poll. My stupid brain always associated them more with Firestar because Alder is ginger and Night's whole character is revolved around Firestar but they are equally related to Tigerstar despite Tiger being non existent in their stories BUT PLEASE INCLUDE THEM IN YOUR RANKINGS.
Also, I locked the poll because it isn't accurate without Alder & Night.
I was unsure of whether to add Flametail since he was hardly important but had like 5 POV chapters so I'll add him anyways.
Here's my ranking:
1. Mothwing - Perfection in cat form.
2. Shadowsight - I wasn't fond of him as Shadowkit because I'm a Juniperclaw stan but I'm soft for him now. He just went though way too much shit and I like poor suffering meow-meows.
3. Alderheart - His father-daughter relationship with Twigbranch is very adorable and so is his relationship with Jayfeather. On his own he's not particularly compelling after book 1 of AVOS but I love him anyways,
4. Nightheart - He's absolutely a bit much and I hate how much Firestar is brought up in relation to him but his relationship with Sunbeam is cute.
5. Bramblestar - I am in no way a Bramblestar supporter. He's been a jerk more than a few times and I hope he's die already but I was truthfully rooting for him in arc 1 and he was a really good dad in arc 3 so he gets some points in my book. Still hate him though, I just hate everyone under him more.
6. Flametail - I know he's going to be at the bottom of everybody else's lists but I really don't hate him as much as the rest of you do. I guess I selectively like jerks and I think he had a understandable reason for being insufferable to Jayfeather that one time even if it wasn't justified.
7. Tawnypelt - She's down here for committing the cardinal sin of giving birth to Tigerheartstar. Also for being a trash grandma to best girl Dawnpelt's kits. She was fine in arc 2 though, I liked her.
8. Tigerstar 2 - Honestly, I would not hate him as much as I do if he never became leader. After betraying ShadowClan & Dovewing numerous times, he's REWARDED WITH BOTH. This ugly slimy rat also has everyone's character dragged down to prop him up, it's frankly embarrassing how the narrative is so into him. He's also a huge @$$ to SkyClan, I'm sure several times great grandfather Cloudstar is real proud of him. Don't even get me started on what he does in Sky. My hatred of this character is so strong it makes me delude myself into thinking Bramblestar is a saint.
Also, I locked the poll because it isn't accurate without Alder & Night.
I was unsure of whether to add Flametail since he was hardly important but had like 5 POV chapters so I'll add him anyways.
Here's my ranking:
1. Mothwing - Perfection in cat form.
2. Shadowsight - I wasn't fond of him as Shadowkit because I'm a Juniperclaw stan but I'm soft for him now. He just went though way too much shit and I like poor suffering meow-meows.
3. Alderheart - His father-daughter relationship with Twigbranch is very adorable and so is his relationship with Jayfeather. On his own he's not particularly compelling after book 1 of AVOS but I love him anyways,
4. Nightheart - He's absolutely a bit much and I hate how much Firestar is brought up in relation to him but his relationship with Sunbeam is cute.
5. Bramblestar - I am in no way a Bramblestar supporter. He's been a jerk more than a few times and I hope he's die already but I was truthfully rooting for him in arc 1 and he was a really good dad in arc 3 so he gets some points in my book. Still hate him though, I just hate everyone under him more.
6. Flametail - I know he's going to be at the bottom of everybody else's lists but I really don't hate him as much as the rest of you do. I guess I selectively like jerks and I think he had a understandable reason for being insufferable to Jayfeather that one time even if it wasn't justified.
7. Tawnypelt - She's down here for committing the cardinal sin of giving birth to Tigerheartstar. Also for being a trash grandma to best girl Dawnpelt's kits. She was fine in arc 2 though, I liked her.
8. Tigerstar 2 - Honestly, I would not hate him as much as I do if he never became leader. After betraying ShadowClan & Dovewing numerous times, he's REWARDED WITH BOTH. This ugly slimy rat also has everyone's character dragged down to prop him up, it's frankly embarrassing how the narrative is so into him. He's also a huge @$$ to SkyClan, I'm sure several times great grandfather Cloudstar is real proud of him. Don't even get me started on what he does in Sky. My hatred of this character is so strong it makes me delude myself into thinking Bramblestar is a saint.