Which cats do you think are the most attractive physically ?

Characters such as Firestar, Spottedleaf, Silverstream, Feathertail, Leopardstar and Lionblaze would be considered attractive to other cats, I imagine. With the first three, it was even confirmed in the text itself at some point (Firestar gets described as handsome in the allegiances of TPB, Spottedleaf was called pretty by Graystripe and at least once stated to be so by the narrative seperately as well in ItW, Silverstream is called beautiful in the first arc as well).

Some more cats who could possibly also be perceived as attractive are Bluestar, Mistystar, Goldenflower, Squirrelflight, Brambleberry, Tawnypelt, Mothwing, Hawkfrost, Bramblestar, Blossomfall and Sparkpelt.

Brightheart is a gorgeous cat as well (scarred face and all) imo but since other cats are usually shown to be spooked/scared by her appearance after the dog attack (except for Cloudtail because he is awesome), she is probably not considered attractive because of her injuries in-universe by most. Although perhaps some cats might consider her scars to be a sign of bravery and see that as a different kind of beautiful (seeing as they live in a battle cat society where having scars should be a sign of courage).

Tigerstar (the first) was called handsome and charming by Sasha (even though the artstyle it happened in was anything but flattering for him in this situation imo and he was obviously playing up his charm for his own personal gain regarding her). But then again, he also usually got unflattering descriptions by his nemesis Firestar opposing that view (him having "stinking breath" was thought of by Firestar at least three times in the first arc, if I remember correctly). Personally, since his kits with both Goldenflower and Sasha are on the list I have up above (even his two Tigerstar clones), I'm of the opinion that Tigerstar I was certainly at least impressive to look at for other cats and had good genes to give his kits. Wether or not that had to do with him actually being considered attractive overall or just his (over)confident attitude playing a big part in how other cats admired him is up for debate.

Completely forgot about Star Flower even though she is probably the most gorgeous cat described in the series to this day considering her green eyes with star-shaped pupils combined with golden tabby fur, a white chest and fancy white paws to top it all of. Not sure about Clear Sky though, as to me, his charm in regards to getting three mates who were all smitten with him had probably more to do with his charisma earlier on and then later his confidence and position of power regarding Star Flower in particular. He's not "ugly" by any means but not incredibly outstanding appearance-wise either imo.

Squirrelflight,Brightheart,Bellaleaf,Lilyheart and Rosepetal

Feathertail