|
Post by Hollyfall on Feb 20, 2022 10:22:56 GMT -5
Basically the title. How would you rank the books of each arc? You can include SEs and novellas if you want. My list: The Prophecies Begin1. Forest of Secrets 2. The Darkest Hour 3. Into the Wild 4. A Dangerous Path 5. Fire and Ice 6. Rising Storm The New Prophecy1. Sunset 2. Twilight 3. Starlight 4. Moonrise 5. Dawn 6. Midnight Power of Three1. Eclipse 2. Sunrise 3. Long Shadows 4. The Sight 5. Dark River 6. Outcast Omen of the Stars1. Night Whispers 2. The Last Hope 3. Fading Echoes 4. The Forgotten Warrior 5. The Fourth Apprentice 6. Sign of the Moon Dawn of the Clans1. The First Battle 2. Path of Stars 3. The Sun Trail 4. A Forest Divided 5. The Blazing Star 6. Thunder Rising A Vision of Shadows
1. Shattered Sky 2. Thunder and Shadow 3. The Raging Storm 4. River of Fire 5. Darkest Night 6. The Apprentice's Quest The Broken Code1. The Silent Thaw 2. The Place of No Stars 3. A Light in the Mist 4. Darkness Within 5. Lost Stars 6. Veil of Shadows Novellas1. Shadowstar's Life 2. Blackfoot's Reckoning 3. Daisy's Kin 4. Tawnypelt's Clan 5. Spotfur's Rebellion 6. Ravenpaw's Farewell 7. Hollyleaf's Story 8. Mothwing's Secret 9. Tree's Roots 10. Cloudstar's Journey 11. Mistystar's Omen 12. Pebbleshine's Kits 13. Thunderstar's Echo 14. Goosefeather's Curse 15. Mapleshade's Vengeance 16. Dovewing's Silence 17. Leafpool's Wish 18. Pinestar's Choice 19. Tigerclaw's Fury 20. Redtail's Debt 21. Spottedleaf's Heart Super Editions
1. Graystripe's Vow 2. Bramblestar's Storm 3. Hawkwing's Journey 4. Crookedstar's Promise 5. Firestar's Quest 6. Leopardstar's Honor 7. Tigerheart's Shadow 8. Bluestar's Prophecy 9. Moth Flight's Vision 10. Crowfeather's Trial 11. Tallstar's Revenge 12. SkyClan's Destiny 13. Yellowfang's Secret 14. Squirrelflight's Hope
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 20, 2022 15:48:25 GMT -5
Warriors: (I refuse to call it TPB. There were prophecies before Firestar's time so it makes no sense.) Forest of Secrets The Darkest Hour Into the Wild (I know it's not the most popular but I'm really fond of it) Fire and Ice A Dangerous Path Rising Storm
The New Prophecy: Dawn (This was the only book in the arc that really gripped me. The rest of it falls flat) Moonrise Midnight Starlight Sunset Twilight
Power of Three: The Sight (One of my favorite books in the whole series) Eclipse (Very close runner-up) Long Shadows Sunrise Dark River Outcast
Omen of the Stars: The Forgotten Warrior (I love Hollyleaf and had awawited her return a long time. Even 10 year old me doubted she really "died") Night Whispers Sign of the Moon The Last Hope (Anticlimactic as hell. Very disappointed that twelve books and two arcs of buildup was to that) The Fourth Apprentice
Dawn of the Clans (Best Arc!) The First Battle (Obviously. It's even the best book of the series to me) The Sun Trail A Forest Divided Path of Stars The Blazing Star Thunder Rising
A Vision of Shadows: Shattered Sky Thunder and Shadow The Apprentice's Quest Darkest Night The Raging Storm River of Fire
The Broken Code The Silent Thaw Lost Stars Veil of Shadows A Light in the Mist The Place of No Stars Darkness Within (This is last simply because I hate the Sisters and everything about them. They had a lot of focus here. There are still some really cool scenes, though)
I'll add the novellas and Super Editions later. These lists were more difficult to come up with then I'd realized.
|
|
Aroace
#ffa100
Name Colour
𝕱𝖑𝖚𝖙𝖙𝖊𝖗𝖋𝖆𝖑𝖑
Villain Enjoyer
Taking a break from the forums because my cat died. Will probably be back mid to late October.
|
Post by 𝕱𝖑𝖚𝖙𝖙𝖊𝖗𝖋𝖆𝖑𝖑 on Feb 20, 2022 17:51:30 GMT -5
The Prophecies Begin
1. The Darkest Hour 2. Forest of Secrets 3. A Dangerous Path 4. Into the Wild 5. Rising Storm 6. Fire and Ice
The New Prophecy
1. Dawn 2. Midnight 3. Starlight 4. Sunset 5. Moonrise 6. Twilight
Power of Three
1. The Sight 2. Eclipse 3. Long Shadows 4. Dark River 5. Sunrise 6. Outcast Omen of the Stars1. The Last Hope 2. The Forgotten Warrior 3. Fading Echoes 4. Night Whispers 5. The Fourth Apprentice 6. Sign of the Moon
Dawn of the Clans1. The First Battle 2. The Sun Trail 3. Path of Stars 4. The Blazing Star 5. Thunder Rising 6. A Forest Divided
A Vision of Shadows1. Shattered Sky 2. Thunder and Shadow 3. The Apprentice's Quest 4. Darkest Night 5. River of Fire 6. The Raging Storm
The Broken Code
1. A Light in the Mist 2. The Place of No Stars 3. Lost Stars 4. The Silent Thaw 5. Veil of Shadows 6. Darkness Within
Novellas1. Tigerclaw's Fury 2. Dovewing's Silence 3. Leafpool's Wish 4. Hollyleaf's Story 5. Ravenpaw's Farewell 6. Mothwing's Secret 7. Pinestar's Choice 8. Goosefeather's Curse 9. Cloudstar's Journey 10. Tree's Roots 11. Daisy's Kin 12. Thunderstar's Echo 13. Shadowstar's Life 14. Mapleshade's Vengeance 15. Tawnypelt's Clan 16. Spotfur's Rebellion 17. Mistystar's Omen 18. Blackfoot's Reckoning 19. Pebbleshine's Kits 20. Redtail's Debt 21. Spottedleaf's Heart
Super Editions1. Firestar's Quest 2. Crookedstar's Promise 3. Tallstar's Revenge 4. Bluestar's Prophecy 5. SkyClan's Destiny 6. Bramblestar's Storm 7. Graystripe's Vow 8. Crowfeather's Trial 9. Hawkwing's Journey 10. Moth Flight's Vision 11. Yellowfang's Secret 12. Leopardstar's Honor 13. Tigerheart's Shadow 14. Squirrelflight's Hope
|
|
|
|
Post by dreamingof on Feb 20, 2022 23:14:52 GMT -5
The Original Series: 1. Rising Storm 2. Fire and Ice 3. The Darkest Hoour 4. Forest of Secrets 5. A Dangerous Path 6. Into the Wild
The New Prophecy 1. Midnight 2. Twilight 3. Starlight 4. Dawn 5. Sunset 6. Moonrise
Power of Three 1. The Sight 2. Dark River 3. Eclipse 4. Long Shadows 5. Sunrise 6. Outcast
Omen of the Stars 1. Fading Echoes 2. The Forgotten Warrior 3. The Fourth Apprentice 4. The Last Hope 5. Night Whispers 6. Sign of the Moon
Dawn of the Clans 1. The Sun Trail 2. Thunder Rising 3. The First Battle 4. The Blazing Star (I didn't read the last two)
A Vision of Shadows 1. Thunder and Shadow 2. The Apprentice's Quest 3. Shattered Sky (I didn't read the last three)
The Broken Code 1. A Light in the Mist 2. The Place of No Stars 3. The Silent Thaw 4. Veil of Shadows 5. Lost Stars 6. Darkness Within
Novellas 1. Hollyleaf's Story 2. Spotfur's Rebellion 3. Tree's Roots 4. Blackfoot's Reckoning 5. Daisy's Kin 6. Pinestar's Choice 7. Tawnypelt's Clan 8. Mothwing's Secret 9. Mistystar's Omen 10. Cloudstar's Journey 11. Dovewing's Silence - I have read this book twice and I still can't tell you a thing that happens besides that there was a burial for the fallen ThunderClan warriors and the part where Cherrypaw & Molepaw get the Dark Forest trainees attacked 12. Leafpool's Wish (All the rest I have not read)
Super Editions 1. Crowfeather's Trial 2. Tallstar's Revenge 3. Bluestar's Prophecy 4. Crookedstar's Promise 5. Yellowfang's Secret 6. Squirrelflight's Hope 7. Tigerheart's Shadow 8. Bramblestar's Storm 9. Firestar's Quest - Every time I attempt to read this, I get bored once the journey starts and I just read the epilogue and call the book finished. (The rest I have not read)
|
|
|
|
Post by Midnightcacoon loves Sunbeam on Feb 26, 2022 4:22:34 GMT -5
The Prophecies Begin:1. Forest of Secrets 2. A Dangerous Path 3. The Darkest Hour 4. Fire and Ice 5. Into the Wild 6. Rising Storm The New Prophecy:Not Ranking, Still Reading The Power of Three:1. Long Shadows 2. Outcast 3. Dark River 4. The Sight 5. Eclipse 6. Sunrise(Didn't actually finish this one lol) Omen of the Stars:1. Fading Echos 2. The Forgotten Warrior 3. The Last Hope 4. Night Whispers 5. Sign of the Moon 6. The Fourth Apprentice
Dawn of the Clans:1. The First Battle 2. Thunder Rising 3. Sun's Trail 4. The Blazing Star (Didn't finish) A Vision of Shadows:1.Thunder and Shadow 2. Shattered Sky 3. The Apprentices Quest 4. The Raging Storm 5. Darkest Night 6. River of Fire The Broken Code:1. A Light in the Mist 2. Silent Thaw 3. Lost Stars 4. Veil of Shadows 5. Darkness Within 6. The Place of no Stars
|
|
|
Post by 𝔯𝔞𝔟𝔟𝔦𝔱𝔣𝔯𝔬𝔰𝔱 on Feb 26, 2022 15:54:24 GMT -5
I honestly don't feel like I can rate the arc books. I have some that I definitely really like, but no matter how many times I read them, a lot of the arcs just become a blur to me - like, I know which events are from which arc, but I can't quite pinpoint which books they're in. For me, the arcs are complete sets - and while there are some particular books I'd rank as a lot higher or a lot lower than others, for the most part I can't really differentiate between books within a particular arc. I can, however, rank the Super Editions and Novellas. Super Editions: - Crookedstar's Promise
- Moth Flight's Vision
- Hawkwing's Journey
- Tallstar's Revenge
- Yellowfang's Secret
- Crowfeather's Trial
- Graystripe's Vow
- Bramblestar's Storm
- Firestar's Quest
- Leopardstar's Honor
- Bluestar's Prophecy
- SkyClan's Destiny
- Squirrelflight's Hope
- Tigerheart's Shadow
Novellas: - Blackfoot's Reckoning
- Tawnypelt's Clan
- Ravenpaw's Farewell
- Mothwing's Secret
- Hollyleaf's Story
- Thunderstar's Echo
- Mapleshade's Vengeance
- Daisy's Kin
- Pinestar's Choice
- Tigerclaw''s Fury
- Shadowstar's Life
- Redtail's Debt
- Tree's Roots
- Goosefeather's Curse
- Leafpool's Wish
- Cloudstar's Journey
- Spotfur's Rebellion
- Pebbleshine's Kits
- Mistystar's Omen
- Dovewing's Silence
- Spottedleaf's Heart
|
|
|
Post by Ivyfalcon on Mar 1, 2022 22:07:24 GMT -5
TPB: 1. Forest of Secrets 2. Into the Wild 3. The Darkest Hour 4. A Dangerous Path 5. Rising Storm 6. Fire and Ice
TNP: 1. Midnight 2. Starlight 3. Dawn 4. Moonrise 5. Sunset 6. Twilight
PoT: 1. The Sight 2. Eclipse 3. Dark River 4. Long Shadows 5. Sunrise 6. Outcast
OotS: 1. The Fourth Apprentice 2. Fading Echoes 3. The Forgotten Warrior 4. The Last Hope 5. Sign of the Moon 6. Night Whispers
DotC: 1. The First Battle 2. The Blazing Star 3. Thunder Rising 4. The Sun Trail 5. Path of Stars 6. A Forest Divided
AVoS: 1. Shattered Sky 2. Darkest Night 3. Thunder and Shadow 4. River of Fire 5. The Apprentice’s Quest 6. The Raging Storm
TBC: 1. Lost Stars 2. The Silent Thaw 3. Veil of Shadows 4. A Light in the Mist 5. Darkness Within 6. The Place of No Stars
SEs: 1. Hawkwing’s Journey 2. Moth Flight’s Vision 3. Crookedstar’s Promise 4. Leopardstar’s Honor 5. Firestar’s Quest 6. Bluestar’s Prophecy 7. SkyClan’s Destiny 8. Crowfeather’s Trial 9. Tallstar’s Revenge 10. Graystripe’s Vow 11. Tigerheart’s Shadow 12. Yellowfang’s Secret 13. Bramblestar’s Storm 14. Squirrelflight’s Hope
Novellas: 1. Hollyleaf’s Story 2. Mapleshade’s Vengeance 3. Blackfoot’s Reckoning 4. Spotfur’s Rebellion 5. Tree’s Roots 6. Dovewing’s Silence 7. Goosefeather’s Curse 8. Shadowstar’s Life 9. Mothwing’s Secret 10. Redtail’s Debt 11. Thunderstar’s Echo 12. Daisy’s Kin 13. Ravenpaw’s Farewell 14. Tawnypelt’s Clan 15. Leafpool’s Wish 16. Tigerclaw’s Fury 17. Cloudstar’s Journey 18. Mistystar’s Omen 19. Pinestar’s Choice 20. Pebbleshine’s Kits 21. Spottedleaf’s Heart
|
|
|
Post by tema on Mar 2, 2022 2:56:42 GMT -5
SE: Graystripe's Vow (listing SEs first since this one's my top pick for the series) Crookedstar's Promise Tallstar's Revenge Bluestar's Prophecy Yellowfang's Secret Tigerheart's Shadow Bramblestar's Storm Squirrelflight's Hope Firestar's Quest SkyClan's Destiny
Original Series: Into the Wild A Dangerous Path The Darkest Hour Fire and Ice Forest of Secrets Rising Storm
The New Prophecies: Sunset Midnight (I can barely remember the individual details of the rest)
The Power of Three: The Sight Eclipse Long Shadows Sunrise Outcast Dark River
Omen of the Stars: The Last Hope Sign of the Moon The Fourth Apprentice (The rest; I took a haitus from this series at the Forgotten Warrior and picked it back up only a few years ago).
A Vision of Shadows & The Broken Code: I'll wait until the book club gets to them before letting my thoughts simmer on the individual books.
Comics/Manga/Graphic Novels: Winds of Change (some of the panels are just hilarious. You can tell Barry had fun making them) Rise of Scourge Graystripe's Adventure A Shadow in RiverClan Tigerstar and Sasha Ravenpaw's Path SkyClan and the Stranger
Novellas: (Can't rank entire books due to conflicting judgments on individual stories, and don't wish to rank individual stories due to the number of them)
|
|