|
Post by π―ππππ¦π±π£π―π¬π°π± on Jan 18, 2022 17:35:27 GMT -5
I think in some ways, yes he definitely regrets his decision. But I still think ultimately things wouldβve been a lot worse had he left Mudclaw in charge. Onestar was awful, but Mudclaw likely wouldβve been so much worse. So ultimately I donβt think he regrets it, but itβs definitely not his finest moment either. Mudclaw would not have tried to drive ThunderClan out for no reason and would never have deprived an entire Clan of herbs. He would have been a better leader than Onestar Even if we ignore all the crappy things Mudclaw actually did (ahem, leading a coup against his own leader and Clan), I think he totally would have been willing to do that. He had a grudge against ThunderClan from the time Fireheart and Graystripe brought WindClan back from exile. Mudclaw hated that his Clan relied on ThunderClan. I feel like part of Onestar's problem was his own Clan bullying him into believing ThunderClan was trying to manipulate him (totally not an excuse for his actions, but still). But Mudclaw always believed that about ThunderClan. Mudclaw was always WindClan first, screw the other Clans - which is the whole reason Tallstar chose to make Onewhisker deputy instead. Mudclaw wouldn't have done any favors for the other Clans without getting something in return, and he definitely would've led an attack against ThunderClan for just a few mousetails.
|
|
|
Post by Saint Ambrosef on Jan 18, 2022 21:52:22 GMT -5
I think in some ways, yes he definitely regrets his decision. But I still think ultimately things wouldβve been a lot worse had he left Mudclaw in charge. Onestar was awful, but Mudclaw likely wouldβve been so much worse. So ultimately I donβt think he regrets it, but itβs definitely not his finest moment either. Mudclaw would not have tried to drive ThunderClan out for no reason and would never have deprived an entire Clan of herbs. He would have been a better leader than Onestar based on what? genuine question. i would like to know what textual evidence we have that supports that view.
|
|
|
Post by cygna on Jan 18, 2022 23:12:24 GMT -5
I think he regrets choosing Onewisker but I don't think he regrets not choosing Mudclaw.
|
|