1.A Light in the Mist (That's probably an unpopular opinion, but I really liked the book.
Bristlefrost dying was something I never would have expected and seeing how much of an impact her death had on the other characters was heart wrenching, even though I never cared about her. I just wish a couple more cats died.
2.Blackfootʼs Reckoning (Blackstar is one of my favourite characters and I adored how unique this book was, since it was almost exclusively written in flashbacks. I loved how Blackstar realized that he was a horrible cat and promised to redeem himself. I think they should confront cats with their past actions like this more often.
3.Winds of Change (I still hate Mudclaw, I think he's a horrible cat. I understand that he was the deputy, but that doesn't excuse trying to kill your clanmates. But I genuinely liked to see why he acted the way he did and that he actually thought Firestar was evil and would destroy WindClan. It was also a good Hawkfrost book.)
4.Daisy's Kin (I love Daisy, she's so pure. In the end, this book sadly didn't have much impact and I don't think the events will ever be brought up again, but I liked it. And I also Mousewhisker and this is the first book in probably a decade where he actually does something)
5.Spotfurʼs Rebellion (The first few chapters are what makes this book alright. I enjoyed seeing Spotpaw as an apprentice, her relationship with Stempaw and some of the minor characters getting something to do. The rest of the book sadly was only a retelling of the first half of The Broken Code, which we'd just read and wasn't interesting at all in my opinion.)
6.Leopardstarʼs Honor (Yeah, I honestly hate this book. It was a chore to get through and was just dragging on and on. Leopardstar was a horrible cat, I hate her even more than before. And in the end Mudfur just says it's the other catsʼ fault she did those things, because they spoilt her so much and should have noticed she wasn't ready to be leader? What? It's not your fault your daughterʼs horrible! This book just made me really mad in general, and I haven't even brought up the inconsistencies…)
7.The Place of No Stars (At the start, I really thought this book would be good. I really did. But then, it was just a mess of going in and out of the Dark Forest and urghh it was so boring. At least we got Snowtuft and some Dark Forest lore, but in the end, this book accomplished almost nothing.)