Post by Katanaheart on Nov 5, 2021 16:26:54 GMT -5
So considering scrolling about led me to posts about forbidden relationships. I wanted to make a list of all forbidden relationships and the tragedies of each that occur/do not occur.
(Discussion of TPONS, GV, and especially ALITM will not be mentioned or used. As I have not read those books yet.)
I’ll try and do this chronologically but we’ll see how well that goes.
(I’ll also include Medicine cat forbidden relationships as well.)
MicahXMoth’s Flight- Micah dies, kits are all later separated.
RyewhiskerXCloudberry-Ryewhisker dies in battle leading to the creation of the First Code. The fate of his kits are not mentioned.
AppleduskXMapleshade- All kits die. (Also Appledusk, Ravenwing, and Mapleshade herself eventually all die as well due to the relationship having existed. The latter of which could count towards the tragedy sans the kits. But noting it for noting sake.)
EaglestormXSquirrelwhisker- N/A. It is unknown as to what occurs to Eaglestorm, so the tragedy could lay in WindClan.
(Apparently him moving to ThunderClan is now non-canon and he has no appearances in books he should have appeared in. GC and PC respectively.)
Squirrelwhisker lives to be an elder and lives through the lack of prey in ThunderClan and goes to StarClan.
HalXFeatherstorm-Ostracization for the kits but this forbidden relationship does lead to a second that creates Brokenstar. Hal does also die later due to this relationship though. (Along with concern over Russetfur.)
ReedfeatherXFallowtail- Reedfeather nearly dies. (Willowshine also later dies, including most of her kits alongside Graypool losing her kits and having to foster more forbidden kits. Latter is more inconsequential but Reedfeather nearly dying would be a more tragedy as a result of the relationship. Also first ClanXClan not ending in some death.)
OakheartXBluestar- Mosskit dies.
GraystripeXSilverstream-Silverstream dies.
OnestarXSmoke-Most of Smoke’s kits die. Darktail is abandoned by his father.
TigerstarXSasha-Hawkfrost is Hawkfrost. Tadpole also dies. (Sasha also never sees her kits again after TNP, thus having no knowledge of Hawkfrost’s double death and later failed plans)
FeathertailXCrowfeather-Feathertail dies.
(Ironically this isn’t even listed in the wiki’s Half-Clan mates. I’m just adding it since I remember it exists. Lol)
CrowfeatherXLeafpool-Ends up as a misery slow-burn on the tragic end. Hollyleaf does nearly get herself killed due to the relationship itself. Also attempted murder with Leafpool and deathberries. (Breezepelt also threatens murder on Crowfeather specifically yet never considers killing Leafpool, now that I think about it…)
NettleXYarrowleaf- Nettle dies. Yarrowleaf is distrusted for a bit. Others die because kits are kit-napped.
Tigerstar IIXDogewing-Unfortunately, not much, minus various near kit deaths.
(I also have noticed the typo but I’m keeping it in for my own amusement.)
Hopefully I did that well enough. But that’s it, which is kinda weird. You’d think there would be more forbidden relationships, considering how much of a hot topic it can be. (Also Gorsetail and Beechfur are listed yet I’m leaving them as Unmentioned since I can’t find any content or link. Unless it’s on the family tree and that thing is very difficult to access for me.)
(Discussion of TPONS, GV, and especially ALITM will not be mentioned or used. As I have not read those books yet.)
I’ll try and do this chronologically but we’ll see how well that goes.
(I’ll also include Medicine cat forbidden relationships as well.)
MicahXMoth’s Flight- Micah dies, kits are all later separated.
RyewhiskerXCloudberry-Ryewhisker dies in battle leading to the creation of the First Code. The fate of his kits are not mentioned.
AppleduskXMapleshade- All kits die. (Also Appledusk, Ravenwing, and Mapleshade herself eventually all die as well due to the relationship having existed. The latter of which could count towards the tragedy sans the kits. But noting it for noting sake.)
EaglestormXSquirrelwhisker- N/A. It is unknown as to what occurs to Eaglestorm, so the tragedy could lay in WindClan.
(Apparently him moving to ThunderClan is now non-canon and he has no appearances in books he should have appeared in. GC and PC respectively.)
Squirrelwhisker lives to be an elder and lives through the lack of prey in ThunderClan and goes to StarClan.
HalXFeatherstorm-Ostracization for the kits but this forbidden relationship does lead to a second that creates Brokenstar. Hal does also die later due to this relationship though. (Along with concern over Russetfur.)
ReedfeatherXFallowtail- Reedfeather nearly dies. (Willowshine also later dies, including most of her kits alongside Graypool losing her kits and having to foster more forbidden kits. Latter is more inconsequential but Reedfeather nearly dying would be a more tragedy as a result of the relationship. Also first ClanXClan not ending in some death.)
OakheartXBluestar- Mosskit dies.
GraystripeXSilverstream-Silverstream dies.
OnestarXSmoke-Most of Smoke’s kits die. Darktail is abandoned by his father.
TigerstarXSasha-Hawkfrost is Hawkfrost. Tadpole also dies. (Sasha also never sees her kits again after TNP, thus having no knowledge of Hawkfrost’s double death and later failed plans)
FeathertailXCrowfeather-Feathertail dies.
(Ironically this isn’t even listed in the wiki’s Half-Clan mates. I’m just adding it since I remember it exists. Lol)
CrowfeatherXLeafpool-Ends up as a misery slow-burn on the tragic end. Hollyleaf does nearly get herself killed due to the relationship itself. Also attempted murder with Leafpool and deathberries. (Breezepelt also threatens murder on Crowfeather specifically yet never considers killing Leafpool, now that I think about it…)
NettleXYarrowleaf- Nettle dies. Yarrowleaf is distrusted for a bit. Others die because kits are kit-napped.
Tigerstar IIXDogewing-Unfortunately, not much, minus various near kit deaths.
(I also have noticed the typo but I’m keeping it in for my own amusement.)
Hopefully I did that well enough. But that’s it, which is kinda weird. You’d think there would be more forbidden relationships, considering how much of a hot topic it can be. (Also Gorsetail and Beechfur are listed yet I’m leaving them as Unmentioned since I can’t find any content or link. Unless it’s on the family tree and that thing is very difficult to access for me.)