Post by plaggy on Oct 27, 2021 15:27:58 GMT -5
This the types of codes that should be changed.
1. The deputy will become Clan leader when the leader dies, retires, or is exiled.
The problem with this if there is no guarantee that the the deputy will be a good leader. During "The Broken Code" we see example of this. Lionblaze anger was clouding his judgement. Berrynose wasn't exactly organize. Even the fandom is questioning if Squirrleflight will be a good leader. But this mostly comes from cats like Tigerstar and Brokenstar. Cats who killed just to get this position. Starclan should't allow these types of cats to receive nine lives. If my memory is correct during "Yellowfang Secret" even Yellowfang yell at Starclan why they even made Brokenstar leader when he killed. And Starclan respond was "Because the code says so". Really. Or they gave Tigerstar nine lives because Shadowclan needed a strong cat to lead it. Really.
2. The word of the Clan leader is the warrior code.
The current arc as show why this needs to change. Just because someone is leader doesn't mean he or she is always right. We had seem many leaders abuse this rule in the past. If Fireheart hadn't defy Bluestar she would have send her clan to an unnecessary battle with Windclan. Or how Brokenstar, Tigerstar and Ashfur done many bad things because of this.
3. A warrior rejects the soft life of a kittypet.
This is tricky. There is nothing bad if a cat wants to have a life that doesn't involve a lot of pressure. But I think former clan cats should still allowed to Starclan if they decide to become a house cat. Besides kittypets life isn't really that soft.
4. Forbidden romances and medicine cats not having kits or mates.
For the love please change this. I had enough of forbidden romances. Yeah a cat should be loyal but in the end one can't help to fall love. Please let medicine cats have kits and mates. Just because Mothflight have problems doesn't mean the others will do. The best thing to solve this maybe med cats can have a family if they already made an apprentice a full medicine cat.
In addition I think clan should come up with new methods for the clan. Or respect others. Sometimes the old methods will no longer work and have to find others ways to do things. Sky wasn't disrespectful of their hunting methods but the clans could disrespect his. Or how Blossomfall was disrespectful when the Sisters were doing a funeral ceremony for Flickerkit. So they want others to respect them but they can't do the same in return.
1. The deputy will become Clan leader when the leader dies, retires, or is exiled.
The problem with this if there is no guarantee that the the deputy will be a good leader. During "The Broken Code" we see example of this. Lionblaze anger was clouding his judgement. Berrynose wasn't exactly organize. Even the fandom is questioning if Squirrleflight will be a good leader. But this mostly comes from cats like Tigerstar and Brokenstar. Cats who killed just to get this position. Starclan should't allow these types of cats to receive nine lives. If my memory is correct during "Yellowfang Secret" even Yellowfang yell at Starclan why they even made Brokenstar leader when he killed. And Starclan respond was "Because the code says so". Really. Or they gave Tigerstar nine lives because Shadowclan needed a strong cat to lead it. Really.
2. The word of the Clan leader is the warrior code.
The current arc as show why this needs to change. Just because someone is leader doesn't mean he or she is always right. We had seem many leaders abuse this rule in the past. If Fireheart hadn't defy Bluestar she would have send her clan to an unnecessary battle with Windclan. Or how Brokenstar, Tigerstar and Ashfur done many bad things because of this.
3. A warrior rejects the soft life of a kittypet.
This is tricky. There is nothing bad if a cat wants to have a life that doesn't involve a lot of pressure. But I think former clan cats should still allowed to Starclan if they decide to become a house cat. Besides kittypets life isn't really that soft.
4. Forbidden romances and medicine cats not having kits or mates.
For the love please change this. I had enough of forbidden romances. Yeah a cat should be loyal but in the end one can't help to fall love. Please let medicine cats have kits and mates. Just because Mothflight have problems doesn't mean the others will do. The best thing to solve this maybe med cats can have a family if they already made an apprentice a full medicine cat.
In addition I think clan should come up with new methods for the clan. Or respect others. Sometimes the old methods will no longer work and have to find others ways to do things. Sky wasn't disrespectful of their hunting methods but the clans could disrespect his. Or how Blossomfall was disrespectful when the Sisters were doing a funeral ceremony for Flickerkit. So they want others to respect them but they can't do the same in return.