|
|
Post by ᏞᎪᎠᎽ Ꮎf fᎪᏁᎠᎾms ミ☆ on Sept 29, 2021 20:11:23 GMT -5
Would be really Cool if they gave leadership to either Blossomfall or Bumblestripe . So we’d Finally have One of Graystripes Kin in power . Since he was soooo wrongfully stripped of position 16 years ago , time for some Justice to be served , and for Erins to correct there mistake . His legacy must continue (and bumblestripe needs to be developed past just being a punching bag , and apparently a fusspot according Kate Cary lol). disagree on the graystripe part. he didn't deserve to be deputy at all. not even in the first place. but i agree with the blossom and bumble part. i'd prefer bumblestripe to be given a chance at deputyship later in the series. i think he could have potential to be a good support deputy to someone else
|
|
Cloudstorm
Don’t let it kill you. Even when it hurts like hell.
|
Post by Cloudstorm on Sept 29, 2021 20:35:48 GMT -5
Would be really Cool if they gave leadership to either Blossomfall or Bumblestripe . So we’d Finally have One of Graystripes Kin in power . Since he was soooo wrongfully stripped of position 16 years ago , time for some Justice to be served , and for Erins to correct there mistake . His legacy must continue (and bumblestripe needs to be developed past just being a punching bag , and apparently a fusspot according Kate Cary lol). disagree on the graystripe part. he didn't deserve to be deputy at all. not even in the first place. but i agree with the blossom and bumble part. i'd prefer bumblestripe to be given a chance at deputyship later in the series. i think he could have potential to be a good support deputy to someone else yeah the graystripe aspect of my comment was more sarcasm then seriousness , since he arguably didn’t deserve the deputy position originally . If the Erins do end up snuffing out Bramblestar/squirrelflight or retiring either of them or both , leaving the leadership position open , I think it would be a very Erinesque move(haha) for them to think ‘ you know Graystripe was totally robbed of attaining Hierarchy of thunderclan back in 2005, we need to restore his bloodline to its former glory , so let’s make one of his Kits leader , since he’s so beloved (in the Erins heads anyway haha) , let’s rectify that by making one of his Kits leader , which will also Mean no more Tigerkin/Firekin in power , like the Fanbase has been asking for as an added bonus . So basically they’d be killing 2 birds with one stone in there Minds .
|
|
|
Post by ᏞᎪᎠᎽ Ꮎf fᎪᏁᎠᎾms ミ☆ on Sept 29, 2021 20:37:27 GMT -5
disagree on the graystripe part. he didn't deserve to be deputy at all. not even in the first place. but i agree with the blossom and bumble part. i'd prefer bumblestripe to be given a chance at deputyship later in the series. i think he could have potential to be a good support deputy to someone else yeah the graystripe aspect of my comment was more sarcasm then seriousness , since he arguably didn’t deserve the deputy position originally . If the Erins do end up snuffing out Bramblestar/squirrelflight or retiring either of them or both , leaving the leadership position open , I think it would be a very Erinesque move(haha) for them to think ‘ you know Graystripe was totally robbed of attaining Hierarchy of thunderclan back in 2005, we need to restore his bloodline to its former glory , so let’s make one of his Kits leader , since he’s so beloved (in the Erins heads anyway haha) , let’s rectify that by making one of his Kits leader , which will also Mean no more Tigerkin/Firekin in power , like the Fanbase has been asking for as an added bonus . So basically they’d be killing 2 birds with one stone in there Minds . sorry for misreading the sarcasm! i do want graykin in positions of power soon. especially blossom x thorn kits ( thornclaw would be hapy of the dethroning of some firekin and tigerkin for sure lol and so would i!)
|
|
|
Post by cable on Sept 29, 2021 21:05:07 GMT -5
blossom is a bully and bumble literally sold out squirrel to what was clearly by this point a tyrant just to look good and weasel his way to a deputy position (regardless of him later standing up to imposterstar, that was still super scummy). neither of them have major accomplishments either, unless you count be characters people argue about a lot. neither really deserve to be leader, nor would they be particularly interesting leaders (at least berrynose is kind of a jerk in a funny way, even if hes more scummy). i can enjoy a leader who doesnt deserve it if theyre interesting, but bumble and blossom has been done and dusted for ages now, and dont have the attachment or personality development that former protags do
besides which, making either of them leader would probably result in complaints from the people who think cats like ivypool and lionblaze are too old. bumble and blossom are both only three books younger than lion and jay, and ivy is younger than they are
best choice is an old protag, then push their leadership role to the background like what was done with firestar. given them a younger deputy who can then be developed. hence why im not totally against ivystar. if you want graykin leadership, give that deputy position to a blossomthorn kit. plumstone would probably be the most interesting choice given her more rigid, old-fashioned persona.
|
|
|
Post by *Faith* on Sept 29, 2021 21:09:54 GMT -5
blossom is a bully and bumble literally sold out squirrel to what was clearly by this point a tyrant just to look good and weasel his way to a deptuy position (regardless of him later standing up to imposterstar, that was still super scummy). neither of them have major accomplishments either, unless you count be characters people argue about a lot. neither really deserve to be leader, nor would they be particularly interesting leaders (at least berrynose is kind of a jerk in a funny way, even if hes more scummy). i can enjoy a leader who doesnt deserve it if theyre interesting, but bumble and blossom has been done and dusted for ages now, and dont have the attachment or personality development that former protags do besides which, making either of them leader would probably result in complaints from the people who think cats like ivypool and lionblaze are too old. bumble and blossom are both only three books older than lion and jay, and ivy is younger than they are best choice is an old protag, then push their leadership role to the background like what was done with firestar. given them a younger deputy who can then be developed. hence why im not totally against ivystar. if you want graykin leadership, give that deputy position to a blossomthorn kit Bumble and Blossom are actually younger than Lion and Jay. Those two were born Eclipse, while Lion and Jay were already around in The Sight.
|
|
|
Post by cable on Sept 29, 2021 21:10:42 GMT -5
blossom is a bully and bumble literally sold out squirrel to what was clearly by this point a tyrant just to look good and weasel his way to a deptuy position (regardless of him later standing up to imposterstar, that was still super scummy). neither of them have major accomplishments either, unless you count be characters people argue about a lot. neither really deserve to be leader, nor would they be particularly interesting leaders (at least berrynose is kind of a jerk in a funny way, even if hes more scummy). i can enjoy a leader who doesnt deserve it if theyre interesting, but bumble and blossom has been done and dusted for ages now, and dont have the attachment or personality development that former protags do besides which, making either of them leader would probably result in complaints from the people who think cats like ivypool and lionblaze are too old. bumble and blossom are both only three books older than lion and jay, and ivy is younger than they are best choice is an old protag, then push their leadership role to the background like what was done with firestar. given them a younger deputy who can then be developed. hence why im not totally against ivystar. if you want graykin leadership, give that deputy position to a blossomthorn kit Bumble and Blossom are actually younger than Lion and Jay. Those two were born Eclipse, while Lion and Jay were already around in The Sight. jedijwjsid yeah i meant to say that but ended up leaving a typo in😔
|
|
#04F9B3
StarClan leader
Name Colour
Featherstar
She could now see that destiny alone could not save RiverClan. - Frostpaw, Wind
|
Post by Featherstar on Sept 30, 2021 17:34:16 GMT -5
I'm fine with Ivypool being leader. If Ivypool (I wrote her name as Ivypoll at first! ) wins I don't really care. I want Riverstar to win. We need another DOTC-era SE. And the last DOTC-era content we got was back in 2019, two years ago.
|
|