|
Post by Chicken on Sept 2, 2021 14:00:54 GMT -5
After reading a standalone book for a character, did you find yourself liking them more, less, or did your opinion of them stay the same? Mine are: Firestar's Quest - Same Bluestar's Prophecy - Less SkyClan's Destiny - More for both, though this one is kind of hard to gauge since they didn't appear much before. Crookedstar's Promise - Same Yellowfang's Secret - More Tallstar's Revenge - Less Bramblestar's Storm - Same Moth Flight's Vision - I guess same, it's kind of like with SkyClan's Destiny, in the fact that she didn't appear much before. Hawkwing's Journey - More Tigerheart's Shadow - More Crowfeather's Trial - More Squirrelflight's Hope - Less Hollyleaf's Story - More Mistystar's Omen - Less Cloudstar's Journey - More (but kind of the same as Moth/Leaf/Stick) Leafpool's Wish - I dislike her so much already, I don't really know if her novella really changes things Tigerclaw's Fury - Same Dovewing's Silence - I honestly don't remember a thing she did in that novella, so same Mapleshade's Vengeance - Same Goosefeather's Curse - Same Ravenpaw's Farewell - More Spottedleaf's Heart - Less Pinestar's Choice - Did he even have any focus before his novella? Thunderstar's Echo - Same Redtail's Debt - It seemed like we learned more about Tigerclaw than about Redtail, and there's really nothing to go on beforehand, so I guess same. Tawnypelt's Clan - Less Shadowstar's Life - Same Pebbleshine's Kits - Same Tree's Roots - Same Mothwing's Secret - Same Daisy's Kin - Less Blackfoot's Reckoning - More Spotfur's Rebellion - More Winds of Change - More As for the other graphic novels, I haven't read a lot of them, and as for the ones I have read, I don't really have much of an opinion.
|
|
Aroace
#ffa100
Name Colour
𝕱𝖑𝖚𝖙𝖙𝖊𝖗𝖋𝖆𝖑𝖑
Villain Enjoyer
Taking a break from the forums because my cat died. Will probably be back mid to late October.
|
Post by 𝕱𝖑𝖚𝖙𝖙𝖊𝖗𝖋𝖆𝖑𝖑 on Sept 2, 2021 14:19:37 GMT -5
Firestar's Quest - More Bluestar's Prophecy - Same SkyClan's Destiny - More Crookedstar's Promise - More Yellowfang's Secret - More Tallstar's Revenge - More Bramblestar's Storm - Same Moth Flight's Vision - More (but she sucked in SqH) Hawkwing's Journey - More Tigerheart's Shadow - Less (even less than beore) Crowfeather's Trial - Same Squirrelflight's Hope - Same Graystripe's Vow - Same Hollyleaf's Story - Same Mistystar's Omen - Less Cloudstar's Journey - More Leafpool's Wish - Same Tigerclaw's Fury - More (he's such a drama queen/king) Dovewing's Silence - Same Mapleshade's Vengeance - More Goosefeather's Curse - Same Ravenpaw's Farewell - Same Spottedleaf's Heart - Same Pinestar's Choice - More Thunderstar's Echo - Same Redtail's Debt - Same Tawnypelt's Clan - Same Shadowstar's Life - More Pebbleshine's Kits - Same Tree's Roots - (Even) More Mothwing's Secret - Same Daisy's Kin - More Blackfoot's Reckoning - Same Spotfur's Rebellion - Same A Shadow in RiverClan - More Winds of Change - Less (way less)
I only added Graystripe's Vow and A Shadow in RiverClan as the newest Super Edition isn't out yet and the other Graphic Novels are about characters who are already on the list so Graystripe, Ravenpaw and Leafstar, except for Sasha and Scourge whom I both actually liked more for a while due to their added on content, if only temporarily.
|
|
|
Post by ᏞᎪᎠᎽ Ꮎf fᎪᏁᎠᎾms ミ☆ on Sept 2, 2021 16:10:05 GMT -5
Firestar's Quest - Same Bluestar's Prophecy - Less SkyClan's Destiny - More Crookedstar's Promise - More Yellowfang's Secret - Less Tallstar's Revenge - More Bramblestar's Storm - Same Moth Flight's Vision - Less Hawkwing's Journey - More Tigerheart's Shadow - Less Crowfeather's Trial - Same Squirrelflight's Hope - Less Graystripe's Vow - Less Hollyleaf's Story - More Mistystar's Omen - Less Cloudstar's Journey - Same Leafpool's Wish - Same Tigerclaw's Fury - Same Dovewing's Silence - Less Mapleshade's Vengeance - Less Goosefeather's Curse - More Ravenpaw's Farewell - More Spottedleaf's Heart - Same Pinestar's Choice - Less Thunderstar's Echo - Same Redtail's Debt - Same Tawnypelt's Clan - Less Shadowstar's Life - Same Pebbleshine's Kits - Less Tree's Roots - More Mothwing's Secret - Less Daisy's Kin - Less Blackfoot's Reckoning -Less Spotfur's Rebellion - Less A Shadow in RiverClan - More Winds of Change - More
|
|
|
Post by Rainsplash on Sept 2, 2021 18:35:01 GMT -5
Firestar's Quest - Same Bluestar's Prophecy - More SkyClan's Destiny - More Crookedstar's Promise - More Yellowfang's Secret - Same/Less Tallstar's Revenge - Same/More Bramblestar's Storm - Same/Less Moth Flight's Vision - More and less at the same time, it gave her more character and there were likable moments about her but I hated it when she was like "NO, you don't know, Acorn Fur, you should listen to ME." Hawkwing's Journey - More Tigerheart's Shadow - Less Crowfeather's Trial - Same Squirrelflight's Hope - Less Graystripe's Vow - Same
Hollyleaf's Story - Same Mistystar's Omen - Less Cloudstar's Journey - Same Leafpool's Wish - Same Tigerclaw's Fury - Same Dovewing's Silence - Same Mapleshade's Vengeance - Less Goosefeather's Curse - Same Ravenpaw's Farewell - More Spottedleaf's Heart - Same Pinestar's Choice - More Thunderstar's Echo - Same Redtail's Debt - More Tawnypelt's Clan - More Shadowstar's Life - Same Pebbleshine's Kits - Less Tree's Roots - More Mothwing's Secret - Less Daisy's Kin - Same/More Blackfoot's Reckoning - Same/More Spotfur's Rebellion - More A Shadow in RiverClan - More Winds of Change - More
|
|
|
|
Post by rookheart on Sept 2, 2021 21:19:18 GMT -5
I feel for all of them, they made me like them more, except for Yellowfang's Secret and Squirrelflight's Hope. The working partners really just love pushing their female characters around and making them suffer for no particular reason. They didn't make me dislike them, it just frustrated me to see strong female characters once again being trauma punching bags so we feel bad for them.
Leafpool's Wish is an odd one, because on one hand, it detracts from Squirrelflight's entire sacrifice when you learn she was forced into it, on the other hand, Leafpool knowing of the three is kind of cool. Also I loved baby Hollykit.
I didn't really like modern Crowfeather, as I prefered him in TNP, but Crowfeather's Trial brought back everything I loved about him. So I really love it.
Crookedstar's Promise is a big one for me, I love him.
I actually always saw Feathertail the way she is in A Shadow in RiverClan, right down to her wishing Leopardstar dead casually, so I would say same, but it really just confirmed every single one of my headcanons for her, and let me comfortably say she's my second favourite character without being like "oh the version in my head sorry".
|
|
|
Post by whiteflight on Sept 2, 2021 21:38:43 GMT -5
I'll only do the ones that I read.
Firestar's Quest - Same Bluestar's Prophecy - More Crookedstar's Promise - More Yellowfang's Secret - Less Tallstar's Revenge - Same Bramblestar's Storm - Same Hollyleaf's Story - More Mistystar's Omen - Less Leafpool's Wish - Same Tigerclaw's Fury - Same Dovewing's Silence - More Spottedleaf's Heart - Less
|
|
|
Post by Mothdapple on Sept 2, 2021 22:37:30 GMT -5
Firestar's Quest - Same Bluestar's Prophecy - More SkyClan's Destiny - More Crookedstar's Promise - More Yellowfang's Secret - More Tallstar's Revenge - Less Bramblestar's Storm - Same Moth Flight's Vision - Same Hawkwing's Journey - More Tigerheart's Shadow - More Crowfeather's Trial - More Squirrelflight's Hope - More Hollyleaf's Story - More Mistystar's Omen - Less Cloudstar's Journey - More Leafpool's Wish - More Tigerclaw's Fury - Same Dovewing's Silence - Same Mapleshade's Vengeance - Less Goosefeather's Curse - More Ravenpaw's Farewell - More Spottedleaf's Heart - Same Pinestar's Choice - More Thunderstar's Echo - Same Redtail's Debt - More Tawnypelt's Clan - More Shadowstar's Life - Same Pebbleshine's Kits - Same Tree's Roots - More Mothwing's Secret - Same Daisy's Kin - More Blackfoot's Reckoning - More Spotfur's Rebellion - More Winds of Change - Less A Shadow In RiverClan - More Rise of Scourge - More
|
|