|
Post by downfalls on Jul 26, 2021 19:48:16 GMT -5
which cats are enjoyable/not enjoyable in your opinion?
i'll go first.
enjoyable: squirrelflight, ivypool, bluestar, shadowsight, mothwing, ferncloud, feathertail, barley, ravenpaw, spotfur, brightheart
neutral: daisy, coriander, silverstream, blossomfall, wing shadow over water, yellowfang, eaglewing
not enjoyable: bramblestar, shellfur, ashfur, greystripe, leopardstar, tigerstar, tigerheartstar, hawkfrost, stoneteller (before the new one), crowfeather, nightcloud, breezepelt
|
|
|
Post by Aqua on Jul 26, 2021 19:53:49 GMT -5
Enjoyable: Ivypaw, Crowfeather, Bluestar, Hollyleaf, Cinderpelt, Dovewing, Leafpool, Fallen Leaves, Daisy, Ferncloud, Lilyheart, Twigbranch, Violetshine, Leafstar
Neutral: Ivypool, Nightcloud, Brackenfur, Heathertail
Not enjoyable: Breezepelt, Squirrelflight, Mapleshade, Ashfur, Tigerheart
|
|
|
Post by kells on Jul 27, 2021 3:40:06 GMT -5
enjoyable
Needlepaw was a breath of fresh air, I really wish she didn't turn out the way she did.
Scourge is a classic, maybe its the nostalgia talking but idc I love my edgefest kitty
Rootspring has really climbed the ranks for me! In Lost Stars, I felt I was going to sit through a character that just dumps on his dad's ways in favor of superior, normal Clan traditions, but I love how his character is handled, the development is an absolute icing on cake too
Jayfeather has been getting some criticism recently, but he still holds number one in my list for the most expressive, personality-filled characters in this series. Reading his POVs was never a bore and I will always enjoy his character
neutral
Man, the impact on so many notable characters are very lukewarm for me, like 80% I really don't care about. Cats like Bristlefrost, Shadowsight, and the rest of the OotS/PoT cast kits are very forgettable
not enjoyable
Clear Sky hands-down. He will always take the cake for worst character in my opinion, the abuse, torture, and mental and emotional manipulation he was behind should never have been left with a slap on the wrist by the end of DotC, in my opinion. All it took was him not being an asshole for once and saving Gray Wing's kit for everyone to forgive him and for him to live his life honky-dory with Star Flower. ew
Thunder too, a very annoying protag who always seemed to trail after Clear Sky like some duckling, especially after so much proof on how much of an asshole his dad was. I mean, how can you look at someone who abandoned you so admiringly, especially right after degrading your uncle right in front of you? Made me rage, man
Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw go hand-in-hand like their relationship and toxicity. I never liked Squirrelflight, especially given how my first impression is an extremely annoying and intrusive apprentice and didn't get better as time went on. Bramblestar wasn't as insufferable, but he had several douchey moments, one against kittypets joining the Clan too, if I recall correctly. He made several little asshole steps on his path to becoming deputy
Sagewhisker also comes to mind. Every appearance she made in Yellowfang's novella was her just constantly harrasing Yellowfang and pressuring her to give up her warrior life to be a damn medicine cat. Regardless of whether it for some prophecy or not, she was sticking her intrusive paws in someone's else's life and set off that doomsday domino effect, all leading right down to Brokenstar's reign. screw this cat
|
|
|
Post by ππ₯πππ€π¬π¨π₯ on Jul 27, 2021 4:59:10 GMT -5
Enjoyable:
Jayfeather Squirrelflight Hawkfrost Ravenpaw Spotfur Shadowsight Bristlefrost Feathertail Mapleshade Gray Wing
Neutral:
Ivypool Hollyleaf Stormfur Crowfeather Clear Sky Needletail Yellowfang Rootspring
Not enjoyable:
Thunder Lionblaze Sagewhisker Bramblestar Graystripe Tigerheart Nightcloud Bluestar Leafpool
|
|
|
Post by π±ππππππππππ on Jul 27, 2021 12:08:05 GMT -5
Enjoyable:Firestar Tigerstar I Cinderpelt Longtail Brightheart Cloudtail Tallstar Ravenpaw Bramblestar Hawkfrost Squirrelflight Hollyleaf Lionblaze Jayfeather Ivypool Dovewing Gray Wing Thunder River Ripple Tall Shadow Pebble Heart Violetshine Tree Leafstar Hawkwing Darktail Twigbranch Spotfur Rootspring Shadowsight
Neutral:Darkstripe Brackenfur Thornclaw Spottedleaf Bluestar Sasha Blackstar Leopardstar Graystripe Silverstream Purdy Stormfur Berrynose Wind Runner Moth Flight Needletail Bristlefrost Not enojoyable at all:
Mudclaw Onestar Sol Ashfur Flametail Mistystar Clear Sky Star Flower Tigerstar II Sleekwhisker Finleap Moonlight
|
|