Heterosexual
Spinestar
Got The Ashfur Tattoo!
|
Post by Spinestar on Jun 20, 2020 0:44:27 GMT -5
Rank as many as you can, if not all, from best to worst, NOT by favorite
P.S Ashfur = The Imposter. But if you for some reason still do not believe it, you can include them separately For me it's: 1) Ashfur
2) Darktail 3) Tigerstar 1 (would be #1 if only TPB is counted)
4) Scourge
5) Clear Sky (antagonist = villain for this thread)
6) Darkstripe 7) Mapleshade 8) Sleekwhisker 9) Sol 10) Hawkfrost 11) Brokenstar 12) One Eye
13) Thistleclaw
14) Slash
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 20, 2020 1:39:15 GMT -5
Haven't read AVOS or TBC. I'll just put them into categories since it's easier. Counting some antagonists as well.
Cool Clear Sky/Skystar - Well-written. Ashfur - Unique and unhinged. Points for the ridiculously edgy blood on the stones speech. Mapleshade - Great in CP and even in GC. Liked her backstory and her descent into insanity. Scourge - Good backstory and pure, unfiltered edginess. Blackstar - Well-written imo, liked how he went from a murderous grunt to leader of pretty much the Golden Age of ShadowClan.
Okay Tigerstar - Not exactly subtle, but gets points for getting shit done and his ridiculous manner of speech. Onestar - *slurps tea* Thistleclaw - Not counting SH. Thought he was decently written. One-Eye - Can't remember much about him but props for kicking Clear Sky to the curb in like two weeks lol.
Ew Darkstripe - Slimy utter wimp. Can barely damage a half-starved cat. Dodge- Uh, why do you exist again?? Sol - Overhyped and failed to provide anything interesting to the plot apart from the eclipse. Pathetic in OOTS and even more so in the manga. Don't bring him back please. Breezepelt - Too shallow and unsympathetic. Willow Tail - Petty and pathetic. Maybe she should've focused on her own Clan instead of trying to start shit with Red Claw who showed remorse for his mistake.
Awful Quiet Water - What the actual hell. Just…ughhh. Brokenstar - Gets wrecked by apprentices. We are told how bad he is rather than shown. Hawkfrost - Mustache-twirling shallow Tigerstar 2.0. Slash - Utterly, utterly lame and pointless. What a complete joke. One-Eye died for this tool?
|
|
Lesbian
satanael
are you girls ready? let’s go!
|
Post by satanael on Jun 20, 2020 15:17:08 GMT -5
1. ashfur
|
|