|
Post by Fireleap on Feb 19, 2020 21:02:36 GMT -5
Here are some of mine, though I don't know if these are actually as unpopular as I think they are
SkyClan's Destiny is the best SkyClan super edition The art in Tigerstar and Sasha is actually charming in it's own way The Fourth Apprentice is the worst first book Yellowfang's Secret is one of the better super editions Path of a Warrior is the worst novella collection The last half of DotC was better than the first half
|
|
#add8e6
Name Colour
*Ravenpaw*
Warrior Fanatic
*reads books in a corner*
|
Post by *Ravenpaw* on Feb 19, 2020 21:08:20 GMT -5
I think DOTC gets too much love. It's like AVOS - first three books were great, the other three fell short.
Despite Bramblestar making some mistakes, he's still my favorite character, followed by Squirrelflight. He gets too much hate.
Bramblestar's Storm and Squirrelflight's Hope were pretty good super editions.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 19, 2020 21:16:23 GMT -5
I really like Yellowfang's Secret, it's my favorite SE so far.
I kind of disliked Squirrelflight's Hope, not because of how cats were acting OOC, or how ridiculous everyone was being, but because Squirrelflight's POV was very boring and repetitive in the first half, it felt like I was reading Hollyleaf's POV again.
|
|
Genderqueer
mrnnki
I do not think, therefore I am not.
|
Post by mrnnki on Feb 19, 2020 21:32:14 GMT -5
I liked Bramblestar's Storm.
Hawkwing's Journey was an awful read.
The art style in The Rise of Scourge was about as "weird" as the current/recent style.
The colors and textures in the new covers are amazing and much better than the old ones, even if the content of the covers is a bit samey. I didn't like the "box in middle" layout of the old ones, and I'd rather have a single illustration of an important scene (which we still haven't gotten in the English books aside from guides). I also don't like the floating head designs in TBC.
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 19, 2020 21:38:19 GMT -5
I genuinely enjoyed Mapleshade’s Vengeance.
|
|
|
Post by Brindlefern on Feb 19, 2020 21:57:13 GMT -5
Skyclan's Destiny is still one of my higher favorite Super Editions in regards to Skyclan books, right behind Firestar's Quest. In contrast, I don't get the hype for Hawkwing's Journey at all outside it being tragic but that's about it for me really.
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 19, 2020 22:02:42 GMT -5
““Path of a Warrior” is the worst novella collection.”
I don’t think this counts as an unpopular opinion, yo.
|
|
|
Post by Fireleap on Feb 19, 2020 22:11:20 GMT -5
““Path of a Warrior” is the worst novella collection.” I don’t think this counts as an unpopular opinion, yo. I said I wasn't sure if my opinions were as unpopular as I thought they were. I guess this is one of them.
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 19, 2020 22:12:00 GMT -5
““Path of a Warrior” is the worst novella collection.” I don’t think this counts as an unpopular opinion, yo. I said I wasn't sure if my opinions were as unpopular as I thought they were. I guess this is one of them. Ah, I missed that. My mistake!
|
|
|
Post by Fireleap on Feb 19, 2020 22:13:36 GMT -5
I said I wasn't sure if my opinions were as unpopular as I thought they were. I guess this is one of them. Ah, I missed that. My mistake! That's okay
|
|
|
Post by scint on Feb 19, 2020 22:32:44 GMT -5
Here's some of mine, I'm not entirely sure if they are unpopular or not but: - Hawkwing's Journey was a pretty boring read and the main POV only infuriated me. Probably one of my less favourite SEs.
- SkyClan's Destiny was a better SkyClan SE than Hawkwing's Journey.
- Dawn of the Clans is kind of overrated. Yes, it is better than most of the other series - but I never really thought it was the best arc ever written. The first two books were incredibly slow to read through.
- Tigerheart's Shadow isn't a terrible SE. It's honestly one of the ones I like more.
- I actually liked Thunderstar's Echo. Not sure how unpopular this one is, but it sure was better than Moth Flight's Vision and Shadowstar's Life.
- I honestly found Crookedstar's Promise to be kind of boring, ngl. Same with Tallstar's Revenge, unless I got to parts that just infuriated me to the point where I just didn't want to keep reading.
- The Prophecies Begin is decent. It isn't the best arc out of all of them, and it isn't the worst. I find it more mediocre if anything.
- Not sure with this one, but I honestly disliked the the second half of TNP. It would've been just fine if they had stopped at Dawn. (Or if they wanted 6 books like TPB, then maybe not screwing up the characters and plot for the second half.)
- Again, not sure with this one but I really don't like Crowfeather's Trial. It just feels out of place with Breezepelt's characterization in Dovewing's Silence and in Omen of the Stars, and it felt like it was blaming the POV for everything from the Crow-Night-Breeze situation, which was honestly grating considering that it was everyone's fault. Maybe if it weren't for these things, I'd like it more, but...eh.
|
|
|
Post by platinum blond death on Feb 19, 2020 23:37:01 GMT -5
- POT is honestly a letdown arc, aside from Eclipse and Long Shadows. - Goosefeather instilling fear into Pinestar was a **** move. Poor dude got paranoid! - Thistleclaw (pre SH Thistleclaw anyways) wasn't that bad, and Bluestar was being unnecessarily mean. - BluexOak had no chemistry, maybe some. It was a one night stand. - I like Mothpool. - I will never see SH as canon. - Making Scourge the villain of TDH was dumb. - Most of NP, POT, and OOTS could be rewritten to be better. - Yellowfang after TPB gets worse. - Firestar after TPB gets maddeningly perfect slowly but surely. He has his moments but lord I remember being infuriated. - Forbidden romance is stupid and overdone. - Dovewing giving Tigerheartstar that ultimatum was wrong and put unnecessary stress on him. idk if these are unpopular but oh well
|
|
|
Post by koripallopeitto on Feb 20, 2020 8:09:01 GMT -5
- TNP was better than TPB. - Forbidden romance is boring. - The new book covers are better. - StarClan's morals are very questionable.
|
|