|
Post by Deleted on Sept 24, 2019 14:53:54 GMT -5
Yes, I am alive. So um, what are your unpopular Warrior Cats opinions? I shouldn't really say unpopular, but whateeevvverr. Just voice your opinions and thoughts on things in the series.
Here are mine, I won't go into detail but I can elaborate if asked to:
- I love Ivypool and I think Dovewing is okay
- I love Jayfeather, not a fan of Hollyleaf and Lionblaze
- The Three should've been BrambleSquirrel kits
- I like Blackstar
- RiverClan is the best Clan
- River Ripple is best original leader, closely followed by Tall Shadow
- Clear Sky/Star Flower and Tigerheartstar/Dovewing didn't bother me as much as I thought they would
- I wanted a full LionClan vs TigerClan battle in TPB, not the weird out-of-nowhere BloodClan thing
- The Cinder reincarnation drama was so stupid
- I like Crowfeather, am neutral on Nightcloud, and dislike Breezepelt
- Firestar deserved a better death
- ThunderClan needs to stop getting POV's, honestly, or at least give a main series POV to someone in ThunderClan who isn't related to Firestar in someway (I know Twigbranch exists but still)
- In TNP, I believed Ashfur was the better choice for Squirrelflight, and I kept shipping them and liking Ashfur until the fire scene
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 24, 2019 15:21:36 GMT -5
1. I can't stand Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, or Crowfeather
2. I love Sandynose
3. I thought all of Tigerclawstar's kits were kinda lame and boring
4. I agree about the Cinderpelt/heart reincarnation thing
5. I don't mind ThunderClan POVs
6. I don't really like Swiftpaw
7. Tornear is best WindClan boy, after Stagleap.
8. I really liked Alderheart, but he annoyed me
9. I don't think Brackenfur is boring at all
10. I agree that the three should have been Bramblestar's and Squirrelflight's kits, like, from the beginning, everything has centered around Firestar and Tigerclawstar, and instead of the prophecy cats being kits from both their family lines, instead, they're kits of Firestar's family line, and some rando from WindClan. And then there's Dovewing, who's not even in the same litter. They should have all been in the same litter, or all in different ones. It sucks that one cat from each of their litters got left out.
|
|
|
Post by scint on Sept 24, 2019 15:48:33 GMT -5
- I hate Ivypool. Outside of this forum and within it, there are several people who love her to the death, and hardly anyone who hates her. She is not underrated, I don't get why people keep saying that...?
- I could care less for Needletail.
- Crowfeather's Trial was a decent book but it trashed on Crowfeather more than needed or what he was responsible for, and ignored other character's faults and actions.
- Twig x Fin was never cute to me. Twig x Soft always stood out more.
- Instead of the Three being Firestar kin, they should've been spread out over the Clans instead. Why does ThunderClan have to have all the cats who save the others? It's why I made that Ivytail, Pebblefoot, and Kestrelflight AU with them as the three out of spite.
- Tiger/Dove would've been better had they not have dragged it along for so long.
- I like Tree, as well as the mediator position.
- I don't like Leafstar. She may have been through a lot, but that does not excuse her behavior in AVoS. Would elaborate but I'd rather not start a debate on her because she's too frustrating for me to want to talk about her.
- Skystar isn't a bad character. He's an interesting antihero, far more complex than I had seen of Gray Wing and Thunder. Gray Wing bored me greatly, and while I like Thunder he suffered from being introduced too late and given a bland personality.
- One of my favourite ships is actually an AU ship of mine, Hazelwing x Snowtuft. I might share that AU one day, but not today.
- I'd rather not have any of the villains like Sparrowfeather, Snowtuft, Rushtooth, and etc get a novella or SE or anything like that because I prefer them being shrouded in mystery and people coming up with where they came from.
...Well, except for the Snowkit is Snowtuft theory. That one can go die.
|
|
|
Post by Honeyfall on Sept 25, 2019 10:46:27 GMT -5
- Onestar is great, so is Crowfeather. sorrynotsorry
- I couldn't care less about Hollyleaf or Ivypool.
- Graystripe X Silverstream is just overrated.
- I'm not a fan of the reincarnation arcs (Cinderpelt > Cinderheart, Jay's Wing > Jayfeather, etc.)
|
|
#add8e6
Name Colour
*Ravenpaw*
Warrior Fanatic
*reads books in a corner*
|
Post by *Ravenpaw* on Sept 25, 2019 15:28:39 GMT -5
- I don't mind ThunderClan POVs. - The original Three and OOTS Three are the worst. - I don't care that much about SkyClan anymore, especially Leafstar. - The Cinderheart/Cinderpelt thing was pointless. - I don't like Needletail, and her redemption was terrible. - Tigerstar II and Dovewing were annoying.
|
|
|
Post by hazelstar on Sept 25, 2019 15:37:06 GMT -5
1.) Ashfur is my third fav character
2.) Every single background character that everyone likes for some reason is all overrated.
3.) Skystar is my second fav character
4.) Not sure if this is a popular opinion or not, but I'll say it anyway: Bristle X Root is great
5.) I love One Eye(DOTC) as a villian.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 25, 2019 16:16:16 GMT -5
1. I loathe Ivypool. She treats her sister like trash, she's selfish about Dove x Tiger, and to me, she's not a well written character.
2. Dovewing is fine, and taking care of yourself is not selfish.
3. I'm starting to understand Ashfur and I think he's a well written character.
4. Hollyleaf has a fine redemption.
5. Needletail isn't that bad of a cat
6. Breezepelt's redemption sucked and he paid 0 consequences for his crimes
7. Nightcloud is just as bad as Crowfeather. Being treated like shit does not give you an excuse to treat others like shit
|
|
|
Post by quailberry on Sept 25, 2019 16:25:54 GMT -5
-Tallstar's Revenge is the worst SE
-Lionblaze was always a good cat
-Hollyleaf abused Leafpool and that needed to be acknowledged
-Its okay to say that you simply do not know enough about neglect/abuse to say if Millie and Crowfeather were abusive parents
-As for the Millie debacle, I don't agree with when people drag Greystripe into it for being a bad dad, because to me it just seems like the Erins forgot he was there and just forgot to add him into the plotline rather than any personality flaw of his own
-I didn't really like the Sister's? Everyone seems to forget they literally held two innocent cats hostage...like, the Clans went too far with the battles but I don't blame them for being mad
-Although she ended up being right, I agreed with Bramblestar that Squirrelflight was being insensitive by suggesting SkyClan move again
-Hollyleaf would be an awful leader and should never in a million years be offered the position: I can accept she's changed but I also think she will always be a control freak who would use leadership as a way of terrorising others into following her rules
-The warrior code isn't always right and should be heavily criticized and scrutinized for faults
-Dustpelt and Ferncloud started off as an unhealthy relationship and it makes me uncomfortable to see it romanticized (although I genuinely do get the appeal). I used to love this ship too, but as an adult I cannot sit comfortably with the fact Dustpelt was intentionally seeking out an apprentice (probably the equivalent of a 16/17 year old)
-Heathertail was always wonderful
-Cats who have done bad things, like Breezepelt and Blackstar, should be let into StarClan if they have genuinely tried to make amends for their behaviour
-I don't like DOTC
-Spottedleaf's thing for Firepaw/Fireheart was strange and again, I hate how romanticized it is
|
|
|
Post by hazelstar on Sept 25, 2019 16:29:03 GMT -5
-Tallstar's Revenge is the worst SE -Lionblaze was always a good cat -Hollyleaf abused Leafpool and that needed to be acknowledged -Its okay to say that you simply do not know enough about neglect/abuse to say if Millie and Crowfeather were abusive parents -As for the Millie debacle, I don't agree with when people drag Greystripe into it for being a bad dad, because to me it just seems like the Erins forgot he was there and just forgot to add him into the plotline rather than any personality flaw of his own -I didn't really like the Sister's? Everyone seems to forget they literally held two innocent cats hostage...like, the Clans went too far with the battles but I don't blame them for being mad -Although she ended up being right, I agreed with Bramblestar that Squirrelflight was being insensitive by suggesting SkyClan move again -Hollyleaf would be an awful leader and should never in a million years be offered the position: I can accept she's changed but I also think she will always be a control freak who would use leadership as a way of terrorising others into following her rules -The warrior code isn't always right and should be heavily criticized and scrutinized for faults -Dustpelt and Ferncloud started off as an unhealthy relationship and it makes me uncomfortable to see it romanticized (although I genuinely do get the appeal). I used to love this ship too, but as an adult I cannot sit comfortably with the fact Dustpelt was intentionally seeking out an apprentice (probably the equivalent of a 16/17 year old) -Heathertail was always wonderful -Cats who have done bad things, like Breezepelt and Blackstar, should be let into StarClan if they have genuinely tried to make amends for their behaviour -I don't like DOTC -Spottedleaf's thing for Firepaw/Fireheart was strange and again, I hate how romanticized it is Just curious, why do you think Tallstar's Revenge is the worst SE? It's personally my fav
|
|
|
Post by quailberry on Sept 25, 2019 16:31:42 GMT -5
-Tallstar's Revenge is the worst SE -Lionblaze was always a good cat -Hollyleaf abused Leafpool and that needed to be acknowledged -Its okay to say that you simply do not know enough about neglect/abuse to say if Millie and Crowfeather were abusive parents -As for the Millie debacle, I don't agree with when people drag Greystripe into it for being a bad dad, because to me it just seems like the Erins forgot he was there and just forgot to add him into the plotline rather than any personality flaw of his own -I didn't really like the Sister's? Everyone seems to forget they literally held two innocent cats hostage...like, the Clans went too far with the battles but I don't blame them for being mad -Although she ended up being right, I agreed with Bramblestar that Squirrelflight was being insensitive by suggesting SkyClan move again -Hollyleaf would be an awful leader and should never in a million years be offered the position: I can accept she's changed but I also think she will always be a control freak who would use leadership as a way of terrorising others into following her rules -The warrior code isn't always right and should be heavily criticized and scrutinized for faults -Dustpelt and Ferncloud started off as an unhealthy relationship and it makes me uncomfortable to see it romanticized (although I genuinely do get the appeal). I used to love this ship too, but as an adult I cannot sit comfortably with the fact Dustpelt was intentionally seeking out an apprentice (probably the equivalent of a 16/17 year old) -Heathertail was always wonderful -Cats who have done bad things, like Breezepelt and Blackstar, should be let into StarClan if they have genuinely tried to make amends for their behaviour -I don't like DOTC -Spottedleaf's thing for Firepaw/Fireheart was strange and again, I hate how romanticized it is Just curious, why do you think Tallstar's Revenge is the worst SE? It's personally my fav I first read it when I was like 13 and I just found it incredibly boring. I didn't like Tallstar as a character and honestly thought Jake deserved better lol
|
|
|
Post by hazelstar on Sept 25, 2019 16:58:04 GMT -5
Just curious, why do you think Tallstar's Revenge is the worst SE? It's personally my fav I first read it when I was like 13 and I just found it incredibly boring. I didn't like Tallstar as a character and honestly thought Jake deserved better lol Lol okay, I was just curious
|
|
|
Asexual
#ca55a0
Name Colour
Rανєη'ѕ ƑƖιgнт
Rebel Queen
Art by Nicoletta Baldari
|
Post by Rανєη'ѕ ƑƖιgнт on Sept 26, 2019 1:44:30 GMT -5
I’m not sure how many of these are actually unpopular, but here goes:
- I prefer Leafpool over Squirrelflight (but I do like Squirrelflight more after reading SqH and LS). - Lionblaze x Cinderheart isn’t that bad of a ship, the drama it created was just dragged out too long (same with Dovewing x Tigerstar II). - RiverClan is the most boring Clan, even when they were still relevant. - AVoS is my least favorite arc. - I like journey books. - Po3 is my favorite arc. - The rebellious apprentices in Thunder and Shadow were right about the situation in ShadowClan. That being said, leaving ShadowClan and joining Darktail was really stupid. - More deaths for the sake of purging the Clans doesn’t work in my book. Every death should have impact on the plot, and the more important ones should also have emotional impact. (Please do Graystripe’s death scene right. *crosses fingers*) - Ivystar! - Lionblaze needs another apprentice, he’s way overdue for another. - I’ve never cared much for Rowanstar, though Tawnypelt’s Clan redeemed him in my eyes a little bit. - Having relatives of Firestar as protagonists is fine. Unfortunately, keeping a ThunderClan PoV doesn’t leave much choice anymore.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 26, 2019 10:20:52 GMT -5
-Dovewing and Ivypool were both annoying
-Graystripe is a terrible character
-Longtail should've been deputy
-TNP is a good arc
-Lionblaze, Hollyleaf, and Jayfeather should've been Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw's kits
-Briarlight is boring
-BloodClan was pointless
|
|
|
Post by padpaw on Sept 26, 2019 11:35:02 GMT -5
Okay, here are mine. I don't know if they're actually unpopular, but I'll write them down anyway.
- I liked Thistleclaw since I first read Bluestar's Prophecy and still cling on to him. What he did in Spottedleaf's Heart wasn't right however. - I like Vision of Shadows and Tigerheart's Shadow. - Moth Flight's Vision is my second favourite Super Edition. - I think Jay, Holly and Lion should have been Bramble and Squirrel's kits. Making them Leafpool and Crowfeather's kits doesn't change anything. - I love the edgy WindClan family (Crowfeather, Nightcloud and Breezepelt) - Crowfeather is my alltime favourite character. - Alderheart is boring and I never liked him. - Bluestar is terrible and I hate her. I'm currently rereading Bluestar's Prophecy and it's a pain. - The fandom turns to many characters LGBT just for the sake of having LGBT characters. (Don't kill me, I'm a pan transboy and support LGBT with all of my heart, but sometimes it's a bit too much.)
|
|
|
Post by cappuccinokitty on Sept 26, 2019 16:11:42 GMT -5
Ivypool is a queen and I love her I don’t have a problem with her, but hollyleaf is kinda boring. FernxIvy is the best thing I hate Lionblaze Hate bluestar. Longtail would’ve been a great deputy. Have never cared for Greystripe. Tawnypelt is bae AVoS never needed to happen and it was boring ( I don’t really care for Skyclan) Dovewing is annoying af in OOtS, AVoS, but I love her in TBC Brackenfur is overrated I love Tallstar and Crookedstar Scourge is cringy to read about I liked Cinderpelt. But she should’ve stayed dead instead of the cinderheart possesion drama Squirrel and Bramble shouldn’t have gotten back together. Then we wouldn’t have Alderheart
|
|
|
Post by Ivyfalcon on Sept 26, 2019 19:37:09 GMT -5
I hate Graystripe.
That’s honestly the only opinion I can think of that seems pretty unpopular. I have some other controversial opinions, but they aren’t really “unpopular” since the fandom is split on them, pretty close to 50/50 it seems (such as Dovewing and Ivypool, Breezepelt/Nightcloud/Crowfeather, Hollyleaf, etc.).
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 26, 2019 20:27:49 GMT -5
I thought of more
1. I don't mind that ThunderClan has a lot of cats, or any of the clans for that matter, I love meeting new characters, and I hate the thought of losing the older ones
2. I want Reedwhisker to be the next leader of RiverClan
3. I like Pinestar, and I think he made the right choice
4. It gets kind of annoying always having characters like, Spottedleaf, Feathertail, and Silverstream shoved in our faces. I know, they're beautiful, kind, sweet, but they were only in like a few books, and none of them, other than Spottedleaf, was even connected to anyone that important, and she's the most annoying out of the three of them
5. I don't mind when characters have kits, like Ivypool
6. I pretty much like Dovewing and Ivypool equally
7. There are characters that I find just too pathetic to hate, like Darkstripe and Breezepelt
8. Gray Wing was a bit annoying in the first part of the first book in Dawn of the Clans. He and Turtle Tail had a nice thing going, and then Storm comes along, and he's like, "Ope, sorry Turtle Tail, but there's this prettier she-cat, that I just met, and don't even know, and we're totally going to be mates now!" That's probably not how it happened lol, but that's what it seemed like. Up until Clear Sky kicked out Jagged Peak, I actually liked him more than Gray Wing
|
|
|
Post by whiteflight on Sept 26, 2019 21:53:37 GMT -5
I love/like Crowfeather. I like SilverxGray more than GrayxMillie (idk if this is unpopular) I like Ashfur Cinderpelt as an apprentice was annoying and I believe she shouldn't have been "reincarnated" cause imo she doesn't deserve it. I love CrowxLeaf I like Leaf better than Squirrel just by a bit. Breezepelt should had never had a redemption cause he doesn't deserve it. Nightcloud is just as bad as Crowfeather even if she was a bit better she still isn't "innocent" Skyclan should had never been made.
|
|
|
Post by ᴄᴏɴɪ﹣ғᴇʀᴏᴜs on Oct 8, 2019 4:59:23 GMT -5
I dislike GraySilver for the ‘love at first sight’ trope it is I like Sol’s backstory and I kind of wish we had some spotlight on his littermates, but I hate how he was put in the books: he was there for some very unnecessary drama and disappeared completely. I like the Tribe. I think that at least Lionblaze should have been a BrambleSquirrel kit. I don’t like Blossomfall. I flat-out hate Spottedleaf. I think RiverClan deserved better. Stand-alone clans like SkyClan are, frankly, interesting.
|
|
|
Post by Rio on Oct 8, 2019 7:25:07 GMT -5
- I think that Needletail has the most interesting character arc in the main series. - I think that Violetshine should have become leader of Shadowclan. - I think that Skyclan should have stayed at the gorge. - I think Rowanclaw was more responsible for Shadowclan's downfall than people give him credit for. He was also kind of awful throughout TNP and PoT. - I think that Micah wasn't actually that interesting. - Longtail should have been deputy instead of Greystripe.
|
|
Bisexual
#64C7FF
Name Colour
finland
Porgs are love
|
Post by finland on Oct 8, 2019 7:26:01 GMT -5
I hate Tree x Violet
Greystripe should die
The New Prophecy is my least favourite series.
|
|