|
Post by Deleted on Jul 16, 2018 9:42:00 GMT -5
So this new thread idea, where I give you two characters and you put which one is worse. Not as in which ones you're less favourite character-wise but mortality-wise. Which one is more 'evil'. So I'll put a list of characters and you decide you put your choice down below. Feel free to add reasons.
Also, this thread will carry on to update as I come up with more ideas, also feel free to suggest any. Also, only strictly option. You can ask for someone to clarify their reasoning but no more than that. No debating or it could get rather chaotic. You can also reply to someone for the sake of a light-hearted joke as well.
Round 1:
Hollyleaf or Ashfur.
Brokenstar or Tigerstar.
Hawkfrost or Darkstripe.
Leafpool or Squirrelflight.
Rainflower or Lizardstripe.
Spiderleg or Stormtail.
Greystripe or Dovewing. (As in Forbidden couples.)
Millie or Sandgorse.
Mapleshade or Appledusk.
Edit: '2009's Thistleclaw or Bluestar', was removed due to it being unclear what it's meant to mean.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 16, 2018 9:55:13 GMT -5
Ashfur. - All his victims were innocent, also having 2 more victims then Hollyleaf. She also gave her guilty victims quite quick deaths in private, while Ashfur's murders were extremely painful and forced an injured mother to watch one. Finally, Ashfur had far more pathetic reasons for his crimes, having years to get over it. While Hollyleaf was a victim, forced into it against her will, all happening in just a few days, only doing her crimes because others' crimes.
Brokenstar. - Tigerstar never killed a kit.
Darkstripe. - Tried killing a kit, killed Stonefur and tried to kill Firestar. While Hawkfrost only tried to kill one cat, who was from an enemy clan.
Leafpool. - Squirrelflight was only protecting her sister, for a mistakes that weren't even her own.
Thistleclaw. -Though Bluestar was close with the whole forbidden couple, having the same ambition to be leader and accidentally killing Mosskit.
Lizardstripe. - At least Rainflower loved Oakheart and loved Crookedstar at one point. Lizardstripe flat-out hated her all kits, including her own for no real reason, calling them 'brats'.
Stormtail. - At least Spiderleg didn't go after other she-cats behind his family's back. Stormtail didn't even step up after his kits lost their mother.
Greystripe. - Betrayed two of his separate Clans, neglected his apprentice's training, left kits as young apprentices and still rewarded by becoming deputy. At least, Dovewing joined Shadowclan properly for the sake of her kits. (Hopefully)
Sandgorse - Millie was a good mother to all her kits for their whole kithood and apprenticeship. It was only when Briarlight desperately needed more attention due to being paralyzed, so she was forced not to give her other kits as much attention but still loved them regardless. By that time, they were already fully grown warriors/adults. And Millie wasn't completely wrong when she said Blossomfall needed to grow up. Anyway, Sandgorse was controlling of Tallstar since he was a kit and disowned him when he didn't want to be exactly like him, even if it made him unhappy.
Mapleshade. - At least Appledusk isn't a mass murderer.
|
|
|
Post by streamflower on Jul 16, 2018 14:29:35 GMT -5
Ashfur: You don't try to murder your ex-girlfriends supposed children because she broke up with you. Just no.
Brokenstar: Tigerstar was pretty horrible, but Brokenstar kidnapped children and forced them to fight to the death.
Darkstripe: He's just....slimier. There's no other way to put.
Leafpool: I like both sisters but Leafpool did kind of screw both of them over.
Thistleclaw: He orders his apprentice to attack a literal child. Not cool.
Rainflower: I really hate Lizardstripe, but Rainflower literally ignored Crookedstar because he had a permanent injury, and changed his name because of her own disgust with him. That, to me, is arguably worse than what Lizardstripe did.
Stormtail: Spiderleg at least tried.
Dovewing: Graystripe was an idiot, but Dovewing was more of an idiot in my opinion, and extremely hypocritical too. She put herself, her kits, and Tigerheart in danger and put Tigerheart in a terrible position in which he felt he needed to abandon Shadowclan which ended up making it even worse in the end.
Sandgorse: Millie sucks, but she obviously cares about her children. Sandgorse cares about becoming his children. That, to me, is worse.
Appledusk: Yes, Mapleshade murdered three cats but Appledusk could have at least tried to do something to help her join Riverclan. Instead he messed around and cheated on her, and then basically told her to screw off. Mapleshade's actions seem to be more a product of madness than anything else (her hallucinations); Appledusk's actions seem to be a product of being a jerk, ergo, I dislike and think Appledusk is worse.
|
|
|
Post by Fernstep on Jul 16, 2018 15:11:58 GMT -5
Oh, boy.
Ashfur. Tigerstar. Hawkfrost. Leafpool. Thistleclaw...? Rainflower Spiderleg Dovewing Millie Mapleshade, but only slightly.
|
|
|
Post by kinkajou on Jul 16, 2018 15:32:24 GMT -5
Hollyleaf or Ashfur.
Brokenstar or Tigerstar.
Hawkfrost or Darkstripe.
Leafpool or Squirrelflight.
Bluestar or Thistleclaw.
Rainflower or Lizardstripe.
Spiderleg or Stormtail.
Greystripe or Dovewing.
Millie or Sandgorse.
Mapleshade or Appledusk.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 16, 2018 15:41:40 GMT -5
Oh, boy. Ashfur. Tigerstar. Hawkfrost. Leafpool. Thistleclaw...? Rainflower Spiderleg Dovewing Millie Mapleshade, but only slightly. Yeah, I admit that one confusing. Considering alot of people on this forum were probably too young to be reading warriors in 2009, I certainly was. I'll get rid of that one.
|
|
|
Post by 𝕊𝕙𝕒𝕕𝕠𝕨 on Jul 16, 2018 16:24:02 GMT -5
Hollyleaf or Ashfur: Ashfur, simply because he would kill cats just because he was jealous and selfish. Can’t really argue he wasn’t. Brokenstar or Tigerstar: Brokenstar, again, killed kits specifically and out them in danger. Plus Badgerfang Hawkfrost or Darkstripe: Honestly, tough one. I’d say Hawkfrost because he was extremely manipulative, and morally, selfish. Leafpool or Squirrelflight: Leafpool, While I don’t have anything against it myself, she did leave her clan and break the warrior code. Rainflower or Lizardstripe: Rainflower, not listing reasons, just...just Rainflower. Spiderleg or Stormtail: Stormtail. Greystripe or Dovewing: Dovewing, mostly because hers was worse in my opinion, especially the timing. Millie or Sandgorse: Millie, she’s a freaking douche to her kits. Mapleshade or Appledusk: Appledusk, granted Mapleshade did a lot, but it could have been prevented if Appledusk was less of a douche.
|
|
|
Post by gonxkillua on Jul 16, 2018 16:32:34 GMT -5
1.Ashfur 2.Bronkenstar 3.Hawnkfrost 4.Leafpool 5.Rainflower 6.Stormtail 7.Dovewing 8.Mille 9.Mapleshade
|
|
|
Post by Fernstep on Jul 16, 2018 17:45:32 GMT -5
Oh, boy. Ashfur. Tigerstar. Hawkfrost. Leafpool. Thistleclaw...? Rainflower Spiderleg Dovewing Millie Mapleshade, but only slightly. Yeah, I admit that one confusing. Considering alot of people on this forum were probably too young to be reading warriors in 2009, I certainly was. I'll get rid of that one. I'm not sure what age has to do with it. I'm just not sure how anyone would actually consider Bluestar worse.
|
|
|
Post by gonxkillua on Jul 16, 2018 18:14:33 GMT -5
Bluestar just hasnt done anything that could even be comparable to Thistleclaw.
|
|
|
Post by kinkajou on Jul 16, 2018 18:14:48 GMT -5
Yeah, I admit that one confusing. Considering alot of people on this forum were probably too young to be reading warriors in 2009, I certainly was. I'll get rid of that one. I'm not sure what age has to do with it. I'm just not sure how anyone would actually consider Bluestar worse. well imo she did kinda become worse then thistle near the end of her life...not that i blame her its really not her fault. but i chose thistle as worse cause blue was pretty great throughout the rest of her life
|
|
|
Post by hissingwillows on Jul 16, 2018 18:16:25 GMT -5
Hollyleaf or Ashfur: I feel like it's pretty easy to say it's Ashfur. Hollyleaf killed him, yes, but he was pretty irredeemably horrible by that point. He obsessed over Squirrelflight for years after they almost dated, tried to help Hawkfrost murder her father/HIS LEADER because she didn't date him, was a terrible mentor to Lionpaw because he was obsessed with his mother, and then later tried to murder three cats, all because his heart was broken.
Brokenstar or Tigerstar: They're both pretty awful, but... Brokenstar. Tigerstar did a lot more damage, but Brokenstar was the one that murdered kits and forced them to fight to the death.
Hawkfrost or Darkstripe: Hawkfrost never really did much. He tried to kill Firestar, and had his sister fake some signs, but that was about it. Darkstripe constantly betrayed his own Clan by reporting to Tigerstar, tried multiple times to sneak out Tawnykit and Bramblekit, poisoned Sorrelkit, tried to kill Stonefur, and in the end betrayed ALL the Clans by fighting with BloodClan.
Leafpool or Squirrelflight: I don't think either is worse than the other morality-wise. They were protecting each other and Leafpool's kits. Neither are really "evil".
Rainflower or Lizardstripe: Rainflower. Lizardstripe sucked, but Rainflower turned her back on her son when he needed her most and gave him a cruel name to further make it worse.
Spiderleg or Stormtail: Pretty close, but I'd say Spiderleg. He doesn't seem to care and has an irritating personality to boot.
Graystripe or Dovewing: Graystripe. I can sympathize with Dovewing's reasons for pursuing a relationship with Tigerheart - he was the only cat that treated her like she was normal and she felt like she could be herself around him - but Graystripe neglected his duties to his apprentice and betrayed both ThunderClan and RiverClan by switching Clans a few times and revealing RiverClan plans to ThunderClan. I get you love your old Clan, but dude, if you're going to commit to a new one, then actually be loyal to them.
Millie or Sandgorse: I don't like Millie, but at least she only became inattentive to her other kits after Briarlight's injury. Sandgorse was overly controlling and ignored Tallkit's wishes, which just made him miserable.
Mapleshade or Appledusk: Mapleshade. She killed cats.
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 16, 2018 18:36:52 GMT -5
Hollyleaf. She killed Ashfur and then ruined Squirrelflight and Leafpool’s lives by outing herself, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather as kits of a WindClan warrior and a ThunderClan medicine cat at a Gathering.
Brokenstar. The only thing Tigerstar did was dislike Firestar.
Darkstripe.
Leafpool. If she hadn’t run away from her Clan to be with Crowfeather, Cinderpelt would still be alive.
Lizardstripe. She’s the reason Brokenstar became evil, because she never truly gave him a mother’s love.
Stormtail. He basically left his mate Moonflower to die in the middle of a battle and cheat on her with Dappletail.
Dovewing.
I’ll answer it anyway. Bluestar, because she abandoned her kits to go live in RiverClan so she could become ThunderClan leader.
|
|
|
Post by 𝕊𝕙𝕒𝕕𝕠𝕨 on Jul 16, 2018 19:38:46 GMT -5
Hollyleaf. She killed Ashfur and then ruined Squirrelflight and Leafpool’s lives by outing herself, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather as kits of a WindClan warrior and a ThunderClan medicine cat at a Gathering. Brokenstar. The only thing Tigerstar did was dislike Firestar. Darkstripe. Leafpool. If she hadn’t run away from her Clan to be with Crowfeather, Cinderpelt would still be alive. Lizardstripe. She’s the reason Brokenstar became evil, because she never truly gave him a mother’s love. Stormtail. He basically left his mate Moonflower to die in the middle of a battle and cheat on her with Dappletail. Dovewing. I’ll answer it anyway. Bluestar, because she abandoned her kits to go live in RiverClan so she could become ThunderClan leader. Agreed with Bluestar, I mean, yes, she did it for a ‘good’ reason, but looking specifically at what she did morally Vs. what Thistleclaw did morally and not include reasons(we are basing this off of what they did, not why they did it), is say Bluestar too.
|
|
|
Post by olivepatch on Jul 16, 2018 21:19:50 GMT -5
i was originally gonna explain my choices but i dont want to anymore Hollyleaf is better. because ashfur is dumb and he sucks and yes i am a 3rd grader Brokenstar i guess because like, he killed kits Hawkfrost Leafpool (i still love her i just love squirrelflight way more) Rainflower Dovewing. Sandgorse... no wait millie... both? Mapleshade (As much as i absolutely hate appledusk, he wasnt responsible for anyones death... well, directly anyways. thistleclaw because hes dumb and he sucks edit: i forgot about spiderleg and stormtail. at least spiderleg acknowledged that he was neglecting his kits and at least triiied(?) to talk to them, while stormtail payed absolutely no attention to his kits aside from “wow good job bluepaw” like once. oh yeah and im pretty sure he cheated on moonflower too.
|
|
Asexual
#ca55a0
Name Colour
Rανєη'ѕ ƑƖιgнт
Rebel Queen
Art by Nicoletta Baldari
|
Post by Rανєη'ѕ ƑƖιgнт on Jul 16, 2018 22:16:13 GMT -5
Ashfur (Burning three cats alive, one your own former apprentice, for their foster mother not choosing you is pretty petty.) Brokenstar (Tigerstar never killed Pinestar or essentially killed a bunch of kits.) Darkstripe (For being evil, Hawkfrost never did a lot of evil things while he was alive. He didn't get enough time while he was alive because Bramblestar foiled his plans. But Darkstripe tried to poison Sorreltail as a kit and was a traitorous cat in general.) Leafpool (Sorry, I still like you. But she really should have let Bramblestar know about the kits. I think he would have kept the secret, because he kept his Dark Forest visits secret.) Rainflower (I can't stand how she treats Crookedstar badly, as compared to Oakheart. Creating a double standard for your kits is not a good idea. Lizardstripe treated everyone poorly, at least she was consistent.) Stormtail (He was cheating on Moonflower with Dappletail. What he and Spiderleg have in common, is that they're both distant dads, but Spiderleg never cheated on Daisy.) Dovewing (Dragging Bumblestripe around for so long wasn't a good idea if she didn't really love him.) Millie (She's worse for basically the same reason as Rainflower. She coddled Briarlight, while ignoring Blossomfall and Bumblestripe, driving Blossomfall to the Dark Forest because of her jealousy. Sandgorse was not understanding of Tallstar, but he was still a decent cat.) Mapleshade (Appledusk may have been a cheater, but Mapleshade is far worse. She killed for the sake of the hallucinations of her kits.)
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 16, 2018 23:12:17 GMT -5
Bluestar just hasnt done anything that could even be comparable to Thistleclaw. We were talking about 2009 Thistleclaw, when he and Bluestar were on more equal footing as rivals. Apart from letting Tigerpaw attack Tiny, he'd done nothing by then. Also, it's important to bring up Bluestar accidentally killing Mosskit and disowning her other two kits, for the sake of becoming leader herself, when she could of simply warned Sunstar instead. (Also, this is only an explanation. As this is a no debating thread, please don't reply to this.)
|
|
#a3c5e6
Name Colour
𝓣𝓲𝓷𝓾𝓿𝓲𝓮𝓵
Warrior Fanatic
All hail me, the flower-flushing queen of Prague
|
Post by 𝓣𝓲𝓷𝓾𝓿𝓲𝓮𝓵 on Jul 16, 2018 23:34:35 GMT -5
Ashfur (tried to have four cats killed just because he was rejected)
Brokenstar (at least Tigerstar never trained kits)
Hawkfrost (this one was more difficult since both were horrible, but Hawkfrost just seems more threatening)
Leafpool (I like her, but her actions caused so many problems)
Lizardstripe (I don't like either Rainflower or Lizardstripe, bit at least Rainflower wasn't physically abusive)
Stormtail (I don't have much of an opinion on Stormtail, but at least Spiderleg was in his kits' lives while they were still kits, whereas Stormtail came around later in their lives)
Graystripe (both have issues with loyalty, but Graystripe always seemed to annoy me more due to him neglecting Brackenpaw's training)
Sandgorse (Millie wasn't a great mother, but she was there for her kits before Briarlight was paralyzed; Sandgorse cared more about tunneling than his own son)
Mapleshade (Appledusk was a jerk, but at least he never intentionally killed anyone)
I'll answer the Bluestar/Thistleclaw one anyway, and my answer to that is Thistleclaw because he was a battle-hungry jerk and goaded his apprentice into attacking an innocent kit if we're only looking at his portrayal in BP.
|
|
|
Post by suicunetobigaara on Jul 17, 2018 0:37:40 GMT -5
Ashfur - Ashfur crimes were purely for revenge, whereas with Hollyleaf you can say it is self defense.
Brokenstar - At least Tigerstar repaired Shakedown, whereas Brokenstar only made his clan weaker and threatened all the other clans.
Hawkfrost - Hawkfrost was more of a threat to more clans (Windclan and Thunderclan). Darkstripe was almost worse for trying to kill a kit.
Leafpool - I dunno, her decisions caused a lot of grief for others.
Rainflower - lizardstripe never changed Brokenstar's name to highlight a problem.
Spiderleg - Stormtail made a bit of an effort. I dunno we don't see too much of these guys so maybe Spiderlegs relationship with his kits were better than we saw. But based on evidence at least Bluestar respected Stormtail.
Dovewing - only because she gave Tigerheartstar an ultimatuminvolving picking between her or his dying clan. Graystripe was more annoying during his forbidden romance and treated his friends poorly and neglected his apprentice and clan.
Sandgorse- he pushed his ideals on Tallstar and made him feel awful. What Millie did wasn't the best but you could see she had good intentions, just a bit misguided. I am sad we never got to see the resolution to her and Blossomfall's drama.
Mapleshade - she did murder a bunch of cats, both directly and indirectly and her toxicness only grew worse in the DF. Appledusk sucks though.
|
|
|
Post by Brindlefern on Jul 17, 2018 1:13:34 GMT -5
Ashfur - Trying to burn three innocent cats alive, one of them a Med. Cat, and helped plotted to kill Squirrelflight's father who is also HIS LEADER, and partially succeeding in doing so too, all because he felt he was entitled to Squirrelflight's love when really he's literally just an obsessive, psychotic yandere incel.
Brokenstar - Tigerstar may be kitty Hitler, but Brokenstar literally made what was the equivalent of CHILD SOLDIERS, and trained with them so hard to the point they DIED, and felt NOTHING when they, innocent kits that are so young they were barely weaned of milk, were slain, not to mention driving Windclan out of their dang territory.
Darkstripe - This was a tough one tbh. But idk, he's slimier than Hawkfrost I think. He helped kill Stonefur, would've killed a kit if he hadn't been caught, and tried to kill Firestar.
Leafpool - While I've grown more tolerant of her the more I read AVoS, before that arc?... Nu-uh. Her selfish actions were the cause of the vast majority of Bramble and Squirrel's problems. And at least Squirrelflight didn't break the dang code for some forbidden love, DOUBLY forbidden at that!
Rainflower - She literally disowns her own blood-related kit for breaking his dang jaw in an accident, renamed him as a cruel infinite reminder of it, ignores him for who knows how long, and Starclan knows what else. Her pride and vain should've bit her in the butt.
Stormtail - While Spiderleg wasn't exactly the kind of cat to be a dad, he at least TRIED, heck more than once even, despite knowingly not being dad material, so that adds points to him. In comparison, where the frick was Stormtail?
Dovewing - I like her, but man her forbidden romance was stupid, talk about horrid timing with that.
Sandgorse - He tried to push his son into HIS image of one, one that grovels in his pawsteps instead of, ya know, not supporting his dreams to step away from that. He didn't care for the real Talltail, only the fake Talltail in HIS mind.
Mapleshade - Appledusk was a cheating scumbag, there's no denying that, but Mapleshade literally resorted to killing cats in a rampage, all for her hallucinations. Because there's no way in actual kitty hell three innocent kits would tell anyone to murder someone to avenge them, that's just nonsense.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 17, 2018 4:59:03 GMT -5
Round 2.
Lionblaze or Heathetail.
Lionblaze or Ivypool. (As in their attempts and murders.)
Yellowfang or Brambleclaw. (More similar then you think: Forced to kill evil family member while having secrets of their own).
Onestar or Mudclaw.
Clear Sky or Crowfeather. (Family wise.)
Bumblestripe or Tigerheart.
|
|
|
Post by streamflower on Jul 17, 2018 5:35:33 GMT -5
Heathertail: Probably surprising, but Heathertail seems worse to me. Lionblaze broke it off with her and she held resentment. She continued to hold things against him (for instance, how he didn't believe that she didn't tell about the tunnels), but failed to recognize why he wouldn't believe her in the first place. And she STILL seems to hold a grudge through 2 more series. She needs to chill.
Lionblaze: This one is tough, but probably Lionblaze. Ivypool only killed when she absolutely needed to--Lionblaze literally killed "by accident" and nearly killed Crowfeather because he was mad at Heathertail. Granted, I like both Lionblaze and Ivypool, but Lionblaze (IMO) is worse.
Brambleclaw: I get that Yellowfang had a relationship as a medicine cat and then killed her son, but she did that to protect others. Brambleclaw killed Hawkfrost almost by accident it seemed; furthermore he's a boring leader and he sucks at naming.
Onestar: Had an out-of-clan relationship and then was a terrible leader to Windclan.
Clear Sky: I hate them both, but probably Clear Sky. Crowfeather had no idea that the three were his and he rejected them as adults after reestablishing his place in Windclan. Clear Sky on the other hand KNEW that Thunder was his son, rejected him despite this, and was overall just terrible. Crowfeather is terrible too. They're both terrible I don't know. Clear Sky just seems worse.
Tigerheart: Both have grown on me but I find Tigerheart far more annoying than Bumblestripe.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 17, 2018 5:54:04 GMT -5
Lionblaze: Turned to violence and murder when none was used against him.
Lionblaze: Lionblaze's victims: Almost killed Crowfeather, tempted to kill Heatherpaw, accidentally killed Russetfur while she took one of Firestar's live and killed Shredtail. Than Ivypool: Killed Antpelt, Was about to kill Flampelt and threatened to kill Thistleclaw. Lionblaze not has more victims, but half of them were for selfish personal reasons, that didn't benefit his Clan in any way. Also, Ivypool was forced to do hers or she'd would of been killed, while Lionblaze doesn't need to worry about that with his power.
Brambleclaw: Spent his whole life knowing about his father's actions, and didn't want to be like him. Yet, still trained with him in the Dark forest, for his own selfish reasons, including using Berrynose as a pawn to become deputy. Even if briefly, was tempted to kill Firestar and forced to kill his brother in defence, who technically hadn't even killed anyone at that point. While Yellowfang didn't even want to a Medicine cat and was already mates with Raggedpelt, so her getting impregnated was understandable. Still tried to stand up to her son on multiple occasions. Only killed Brokenstar after he'd killed many kits, exiled Elders/Entire Clans, etc. Even if Blind, he was still a threat when planned a rebellion with Tigerstar. There was no redemption for him and there was no point in keeping him around.
I'll Decide the others later.
|
|
|
Post by hissingwillows on Jul 17, 2018 20:23:43 GMT -5
Round 2. Lionblaze or Heathetail. Lionblaze or Ivypool. (As in their attempts and murders.) Yellowfang or Brambleclaw. (More similar then you think: Forced to kill evil family member while having secrets of their own). Onestar or Mudclaw. Clear Sky or Crowfeather. (Family wise.) Bumblestripe or Tigerheart. Lionblaze or Heathertail: Lionblaze thought frequently about killing her. That makes him worse. Lionblaze or Ivypool: Lionblaze, again - mostly because Ivypool was coerced into continuing to spy in the Dark Forest by the three and had to do whatever it took to avoid being caught in order to keep being privy to what was being plotted there. She didn't really have a choice when it came to killing Antpelt. If she decided not to, she would have either been kicked out or killed herself. Yellowfang or Brambleclaw: Mm... as much as I pretend Yellowfang's butchered personality post TBP doesn't exist, I'd say based off of her actions in StarClan, she's worse. She lied to Squirrelflight about her being infertile to convince her to adopt Leafpool's kits and pressured Jayfeather to stay away from the other medicine cats and Clans. Onestar or Mudclaw: They're both bad for their own reasons, so it's kind of hard to pick. I'd say they're equally bad. Mudclaw was willing to start a civil war in WindClan, even recruiting outside cats to attack his own Clanmates in order to overthrow Onewhisker, and Onestar turned out to be a pretty awful leader who antagonized ThunderClan constantly. Clear Sky or Crowfeather: This is also close, but I'd say Clear Sky. He rejected his younger brother for his disability, turned his back on Gray Wing, and rejected Thunder a few times. Also, all of his relationships were with cats that either his brother or son were in love with, which is just weird. Bumblestripe and Tigerheart: Bumblestripe. He whined about Dovewing not liking him and acted like she was horrible to him for not returning his feelings when he should have just moved on and stop acting like a brat.
|
|
|
Post by kinkajou on Jul 17, 2018 23:12:49 GMT -5
Lionblaze or Heathetail.
Lionblaze or Ivypool.
Yellowfang or Brambleclaw.
Onestar or Mudclaw.
Clear Sky or Crowfeather.
Bumblestripe or Tigerheart.
|
|
|
Post by Fernstep on Jul 18, 2018 12:56:35 GMT -5
Lionblaze Lionblaze, I guess. I guess Brambleclaw? But like, neither of them is really bad? Onestar, but I feel this is a bit of an unfair comparison because we got to see every one of Onestar's faults across nine lives laid bare, whereas Mudclaw did one bad thing and immediately died for it. Family-wise, hmm? Clear Sky. Crowfeather was just, like, kinda grumpy. Clear Sky disowned his son and drove his wife away. Bumblestripe or Tigerheart as characters? Uh, Bumblestripe, I guess.
|
|
|
Post by gonxkillua on Jul 18, 2018 14:27:35 GMT -5
Lionblaze Lionblaze Yellowfang Onestar Clear Sky Bumblestirpe
|
|