Violet or Twig?

I have the unpopular opinion of preferring Twigbranch to Violetshine.

Why? I find her to be more relatable.

Twigbranch was a much better character in RoF, but on the whole I still prefer Violetshine. They're both excellent POVs in different books, though neither is on my favorites list.

Twigbranch by far. She's relateable in the idea of searching for where one truly belongs and her flaws are all realistic. She's not a wise cat, but she does have development and above all she is consistent. She doesn't magically become wise and perfect.

She's better than Violetshine in my opinion because she doesn't bash on her sister for asking honest questions, she clearly cared more about her family from the start, and she doesn't follow and defend someone after they clearly used and abused her. She doesn't join rouges that nearly destroy a clan, and she's just far more forgiving.

Both she-cats suffered due to their seperation and environment, but at least Twigbranch doesn't think negatively about her sister like her sister does about her every action.