No one deserves the Dark Forest, not even Ravenwing, who was only doing his job. Not saying it was right, not saying he handled it right, not saying he's perfect either -- but he doesn't deserve the Dark Forest.
And why is Reedshine put for the option as going to the Dark Forest? All she said to Mapleshade was to go away. She doesn't deserve it, in fact she's as much of a victim to Mapleshade when Appledusk cheated on her. She wailed in pain in the Novella.
Perchpaw doesn't deserve it for simply
defending his mentor.Appledusk... no. He's a punk, but he loves his Clan. And this is coming from someone who doesn't even like the guy.
Oakstar... unsure. He wanted to raise Mapleshade's kits to kill Appledusk, full of hatred and vengeance... while he was grieving, it doesn't sound like he was a very nice tom. Maybe he's the only one who truly does deserve the Dark Forest. A Clan leader wanting revenge isn't a good leader. Clan leaders should make peace, not raise kits by poisoning hatred in their minds for a single RiverClan warrior.
Frecklewish... no... just... no. Whatever anyone says, she was having some sort of problem. She lost her brother, and Mapleshade used him, giving her false hope. Her reaction was
natural. She didn't even want the kits to die, and regretted it. I... can't believe some people still say she deserves the Dark Forest.
But, the only one who truly deserves the Dark Forest, is Mapleshade. She has killed 3 cats, nearly attacked a pregnant defenseless queen out of jealousy and possessiveness (cause she couldn't let Appledusk go), and only thought of herself. Yeah. I'm sorry, but I don't feel bad for her after trying to attack a pregnant queen. She's lost my sympathy for her the moment she attacked the innocent Reedshine.
I don't wanna debate with anyone on here so I'll end it at that. Not in the mood, just wanted to put in my two cents.