Post by 𝓣𝓲𝓷𝓾𝓿𝓲𝓮𝓵 on Jul 6, 2017 23:50:52 GMT -5
Guys! Guys! I just noticed something! So, you know Mothwing, right? RiverClan medicine cat who still doesn't believe in StarClan for some reason even though she witnessed the Great Battle for herself? Yeah, that Mothwing. Well, I noticed something very peculiar about her... Her fur.
What's wrong with it? Well, it's gold. No one in Tigerstar's family has gold fur, and Sasha is tawny-colored. But you know who does have gold fur? That's right, readers! It's Leopardstar!
Just look at their descriptions from the wiki.
But wait, didn't Mistystar's Omen reveal that Leopardstar never had any kits?
Keep in mind that Leopardstar was dying when she said this. It's possible she was delirious, but still wanted to have a sweet moment with Mistyfoot.
Okay, so then if Leopardstar is Motheing's mother, then who's the father? That's easy! It's Tigerstar. But that can't be, right? Leopardstar wasn't fond of half-Clan cats. And yet, she fell in love with Tigerstar anyway. That's part of the reason she helped form RiverClan with him. Not only did Vicky confirm this, but it's also in TUG.
Okay, so then what about Sasha? Well, Leopardstar probably gave her kits away to continue her duties as leader as well as out of guilt. Besides, let me ask you this: do we ever actually see Sasha give birth? Nope! In fact, why not throw Hawkfrost as one of Leopardstar's kits as well, but at least he actually looks like one of his parents (although it would explain the obvious favoritism), while Tadpole likely takes after Leopardfoot.
Wait a minute. Leopardfoot. Leopardstar. New theory! Leopardstar is either Leopardfoot reincarnated or Tigerstar mated with her because she reminded him of his mother! Or both, because why not!
Like and comment on this thread dear readers! And remember, it's just a theory—a book theory! Thanks for reading!
What's wrong with it? Well, it's gold. No one in Tigerstar's family has gold fur, and Sasha is tawny-colored. But you know who does have gold fur? That's right, readers! It's Leopardstar!
Just look at their descriptions from the wiki.
Leopardstar is a dappled golden tabby she-cat with unusual, dark golden spots, and a long, winding tail. She has sleek fur and amber eyes.
Mothwing is a small, triangular-faced, thick, sleek, and long-furred, dappled, dark golden she-cat with rippling tabby stripes, huge, brilliant amber eyes, a broad head, and a fluffy tail.
But wait, didn't Mistystar's Omen reveal that Leopardstar never had any kits?
“I am sorry not to have known the joy of having kits. There was a time when I thought it might happen, but it was not to be.”
Keep in mind that Leopardstar was dying when she said this. It's possible she was delirious, but still wanted to have a sweet moment with Mistyfoot.
Okay, so then if Leopardstar is Motheing's mother, then who's the father? That's easy! It's Tigerstar. But that can't be, right? Leopardstar wasn't fond of half-Clan cats. And yet, she fell in love with Tigerstar anyway. That's part of the reason she helped form RiverClan with him. Not only did Vicky confirm this, but it's also in TUG.
Question: Was it really just pride that stopped Leopardstar from breaking her agreement with Tigerstar (when he was about to kill the half-Clans), or was there another factor--something she would never admit out loud--like fear?
Answer: VickyHolmes: Good question! Most definitely, Leopardstar was afraid of Tigerstar - but also in love with him, poor thing.—Erin Hunter Chat 6
Answer: VickyHolmes: Good question! Most definitely, Leopardstar was afraid of Tigerstar - but also in love with him, poor thing.—Erin Hunter Chat 6
Perhaps she also hoped that Tigerstar would invite her to be his mate and share the rule of the forest.—The Ultimate Guide, Leopardstar's page
Okay, so then what about Sasha? Well, Leopardstar probably gave her kits away to continue her duties as leader as well as out of guilt. Besides, let me ask you this: do we ever actually see Sasha give birth? Nope! In fact, why not throw Hawkfrost as one of Leopardstar's kits as well, but at least he actually looks like one of his parents (although it would explain the obvious favoritism), while Tadpole likely takes after Leopardfoot.
Wait a minute. Leopardfoot. Leopardstar. New theory! Leopardstar is either Leopardfoot reincarnated or Tigerstar mated with her because she reminded him of his mother! Or both, because why not!
Like and comment on this thread dear readers! And remember, it's just a theory—a book theory! Thanks for reading!
I am so not sorry for that! At all! I was I laughing the entire time and I still am! This is what happens when I'm bored and not sleepy at 12:50. But really, what if Mothwing really was Leopardstar's daughter instead of Sasha's?