I have never wanted to slap a character (and CHARACTERS) in these books more so than when I was just reading Thunder and Shadow (an opinionated rant, sort ofish). So my review.
*Like Onestar? You're being a D-Bag, pull your crap together and stop acting like whiny a-hole, like you're going insane wth even happened to you man.
*Violetpaw? Suck it up and quit contradicting your bipolar self. Tawnypelt got a choice to join ShadowClan and never once (as far as I can remember) faltered in her belief that there's a separation from clan and kin. Twigpaw started moving on because you treated her like the plague when you bounced back and forth with Needletail. You fought to prove you're loyal to your clan but then turned on your leader and deputy when the rogues invaded. Don't you dare say you're family and clan didn't welcome you.
*Like Mothwing? Come on, it's been, what? A few years since you saw your dead brother kill people before your very eyes? How do you not still think StarClan is real? Haven't you ever watched your leader come back to life again?
*Needletail just makes me want to stab Rain's other eye tbh.
*ThunderClan has too many medicine cats. Leafpool said it herself. NO MORE.
*I love Mistystar but she's unrealistically old I mean she's older than Greystripe and he's a frickin elder--I don't care if she has nine lives YOU NEED TO KILL OFF MORE CATS
*DITTO. THE WARRIORS LIST FOR THUNDERCLAN IS MASSIVE AND YOU HAVE APPRENTICES TOO I MEAN LIKE BRACKENFUR WAS MENTORED BY GREYSTRIPE AND FIRESTAR AND CLOUDTAIL IS ONLY A FEW YEARS YOUNGER THAN FIRESTAR WAS PRINCESS MIGHT BE DEAD BY NOW
*I don't even remember Thornclaw actually physically doing something in the plot I thought he was dead BUT NOPE HE'S IN THE WARRIOR LIST SO WHERE IS HE???
*I'm really kind of P.O.'d like if they drag Tiger x Dove back up again I'm going to stab someone with a rusty pitchfork.
The only characters I really liked in the book this time round were Alderheart and few supporting characters but Twigpaw got on my nerves a bit sometimes. I'm glad ShadowClan had some sickness and some characters died like keep it going you need to thin the herd a bit more. I'm happy Tigerheart is still alive and deputy now because he's still probably my favorite warriors character, but the entire time I'm mentally scolding him like IS THIS HOW YOU'VE TRAINED YOUR APPRENTICE BOI????
NOTE: Excessively spamming the shoutbox may result in a 24 hour ban. Other forum rules still apply. Please do not advertise by linking other websites. Use spoilers when necessary. Members are encouraged to report offending content to the moderators by PM.