Post by Ligerfrost on Aug 1, 2016 22:37:30 GMT -5
That's right I'm bringing it back because...well because I'm bored and because I can.
If you seen the original thread you probably know what this thread is about if not well I'll explain where my idea came from:
So I was thinking about all the cats who have undergone some weird genderswap/switch in the books such as: Rowanclaw (I think he's the king of this happening), Mosskit, Mintfur and Sagepaw
And it got me thinking what if other characters had been the opposite gender than how they are portrayed in the books? Would the books change so drastically or roughly remain the same with a few differences?
So I decided to come up with some scenarios. Revolving around one character being the opposite gender than they were in the books, while everyone else remain the same.
So everyone can give their opinion on them. Oh and I'll be changing the cat daily.
I guess I can add all the cats that have been done so far.
As long as the topic has been put up you can talk about it. If you want to state your opinion of any of the scenarios on the page feel free.
Scenarios:
So What if: Firestar/heart/paw had been a she-cat instead of a tom? Who would be her mate? Who would her friends be? Would she remain as devoted to the warrior code and ThunderClan as her male counterpart? Would she still become leader? Would she even remain in ThunderClan? Would her warrior name be different or stay the same?
So What if Squirrelflight had been a tom? Who would have pursued him as a mate? Who would have covered for Leafpool? Would he and Brambleclaw be friends? Would his mate even be from ThunderClan? Would his warrior name be different or remain the same?
So what about Tigerstar? if he had been a she-cat how might things have been different? Would she have even had any kits? Would she be more dangerous than her male counterpart? Would she even have a mate in ThunderClan? Do you think her name will change?'
So how about Sandstorm? What if she had been a tom? Who would his mate be if he had one at all? Would he still be friends with Firestar or Dustpelt? Do you think its possible he would become deputy instead of Graystripe?
So what about Graystripe? Same name or not? Who would her mate be? Would she still become deputy? Would Millie still appear later on in the books?
What if Hollyleaf had been born a tom? Same name or not? Who would his mate be (if he had one), Would he have interest in other Clans? Would things still happen the same?
So what if Brambleclaw was a female? do you think she would still become deputy? Who might be her mate? Her friends? Do you think her relationship with her father would be different? What about her name do you think that would be different?
So what if Brightheart had been a tom? who would his mate be? Do you think him and Cloudtail would be friends? What about his name?
So what if Ashfur had been a she-cat? Do you think she'd get a mate? Who would her friends be? What about her name? Do you think her and Squirrelflight would be friends?
So what if Whitewing had been a tom? Who would be his mate? would he have a different name? Would he still have a mothering(fathering) personality?
Now Ravenpaw, what do you think would happen if she was female? Do you think Dustpelt would have been more protective of her or acknowledge her more as his sister? Do you think she would come back? Do you think she would have pursued becoming a medicine cat instead of being Tigerstar's apprentice? If she lived at the barn? If she stayed in ThunderClan what do you think her warrior name would be?
What about Sorreltail? how different would things be is she were a tom? Who would his mate be? would he have the same friends? Would his personality be different?
Okay what about Crowfeather? What if he had been a she-cat? Who would her mate be? Friends? Name different or the same? How different do you think the journey to find midnight would be?
Okay so what if Bluestar had been a tom? How different do you think things would have been? Do you think he would have had a mate? If so who do you think she would be? Do you think him and Crookedstar would have been friends? What about Oakheart?
So what if Tallstar was a she-cat? How different would her life have been? Do you think she would have a mate? What about her name? Do you think it would stay the same or change? Do you think her and Shrewclaw would still be rivals? What about her and Jake? What about relationship with her father and mother?
Okay what about Ivypool? If Ivypool was a tom what would he be like? Would he still be jealous of Dovewing? Would he have a mate? Would he still trust Hawkfrost so easily? Would he still be a spy for the three? How about his name would it change?
Okay so what about Crookedstar? Do you think she would still have the same injury? Do you think her mother would still treat her the same both before and after her injury? Would Mapleshade still target her or Oakheart? Do you think she would still have a mate?
Okay how different do you think things would have been if Daisy was a tom? What would his name be? How would his relationship with Smoky and Floss be differed? Do you think he's still join ThunderClan? Do you think he would have an unrequited crush in ThunderClan (Like with Cloudtail) Do you think he'd take a warrior name? Who do you think his mate would be?
So what if Longtail was a she-cat? How different do you think things would be? Would she have a mate? Would she still be as devoted to Tigerclaw/star in the beginning? Would her relationship with FIrestar be better or worse?
So what if Dovewing was a tom? Would he have a mate or a new crush? Would he still have a good relationship with Ivypool, Would his name still be Dovewing? Do you think he would still be part of the Three? Do you think his powers would still be the same or have slight differences?
♦New♦
So what if Gray Wing had been a she-cat instead of a tom? Do you think her approach to dealing with her brothers would be different? Would she have a mate? Who would that be? Would her death be the same or more tragic?
If you seen the original thread you probably know what this thread is about if not well I'll explain where my idea came from:
So I was thinking about all the cats who have undergone some weird genderswap/switch in the books such as: Rowanclaw (I think he's the king of this happening), Mosskit, Mintfur and Sagepaw
And it got me thinking what if other characters had been the opposite gender than how they are portrayed in the books? Would the books change so drastically or roughly remain the same with a few differences?
So I decided to come up with some scenarios. Revolving around one character being the opposite gender than they were in the books, while everyone else remain the same.
So everyone can give their opinion on them. Oh and I'll be changing the cat daily.
I guess I can add all the cats that have been done so far.
As long as the topic has been put up you can talk about it. If you want to state your opinion of any of the scenarios on the page feel free.
Scenarios:
So What if: Firestar/heart/paw had been a she-cat instead of a tom? Who would be her mate? Who would her friends be? Would she remain as devoted to the warrior code and ThunderClan as her male counterpart? Would she still become leader? Would she even remain in ThunderClan? Would her warrior name be different or stay the same?
So What if Squirrelflight had been a tom? Who would have pursued him as a mate? Who would have covered for Leafpool? Would he and Brambleclaw be friends? Would his mate even be from ThunderClan? Would his warrior name be different or remain the same?
So what about Tigerstar? if he had been a she-cat how might things have been different? Would she have even had any kits? Would she be more dangerous than her male counterpart? Would she even have a mate in ThunderClan? Do you think her name will change?'
So how about Sandstorm? What if she had been a tom? Who would his mate be if he had one at all? Would he still be friends with Firestar or Dustpelt? Do you think its possible he would become deputy instead of Graystripe?
So what about Graystripe? Same name or not? Who would her mate be? Would she still become deputy? Would Millie still appear later on in the books?
What if Hollyleaf had been born a tom? Same name or not? Who would his mate be (if he had one), Would he have interest in other Clans? Would things still happen the same?
So what if Brambleclaw was a female? do you think she would still become deputy? Who might be her mate? Her friends? Do you think her relationship with her father would be different? What about her name do you think that would be different?
So what if Brightheart had been a tom? who would his mate be? Do you think him and Cloudtail would be friends? What about his name?
So what if Ashfur had been a she-cat? Do you think she'd get a mate? Who would her friends be? What about her name? Do you think her and Squirrelflight would be friends?
So what if Whitewing had been a tom? Who would be his mate? would he have a different name? Would he still have a mothering(fathering) personality?
Now Ravenpaw, what do you think would happen if she was female? Do you think Dustpelt would have been more protective of her or acknowledge her more as his sister? Do you think she would come back? Do you think she would have pursued becoming a medicine cat instead of being Tigerstar's apprentice? If she lived at the barn? If she stayed in ThunderClan what do you think her warrior name would be?
What about Sorreltail? how different would things be is she were a tom? Who would his mate be? would he have the same friends? Would his personality be different?
Okay what about Crowfeather? What if he had been a she-cat? Who would her mate be? Friends? Name different or the same? How different do you think the journey to find midnight would be?
Okay so what if Bluestar had been a tom? How different do you think things would have been? Do you think he would have had a mate? If so who do you think she would be? Do you think him and Crookedstar would have been friends? What about Oakheart?
So what if Tallstar was a she-cat? How different would her life have been? Do you think she would have a mate? What about her name? Do you think it would stay the same or change? Do you think her and Shrewclaw would still be rivals? What about her and Jake? What about relationship with her father and mother?
Okay what about Ivypool? If Ivypool was a tom what would he be like? Would he still be jealous of Dovewing? Would he have a mate? Would he still trust Hawkfrost so easily? Would he still be a spy for the three? How about his name would it change?
Okay so what about Crookedstar? Do you think she would still have the same injury? Do you think her mother would still treat her the same both before and after her injury? Would Mapleshade still target her or Oakheart? Do you think she would still have a mate?
Okay how different do you think things would have been if Daisy was a tom? What would his name be? How would his relationship with Smoky and Floss be differed? Do you think he's still join ThunderClan? Do you think he would have an unrequited crush in ThunderClan (Like with Cloudtail) Do you think he'd take a warrior name? Who do you think his mate would be?
So what if Longtail was a she-cat? How different do you think things would be? Would she have a mate? Would she still be as devoted to Tigerclaw/star in the beginning? Would her relationship with FIrestar be better or worse?
So what if Dovewing was a tom? Would he have a mate or a new crush? Would he still have a good relationship with Ivypool, Would his name still be Dovewing? Do you think he would still be part of the Three? Do you think his powers would still be the same or have slight differences?
♦New♦
So what if Gray Wing had been a she-cat instead of a tom? Do you think her approach to dealing with her brothers would be different? Would she have a mate? Who would that be? Would her death be the same or more tragic?