|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 10, 2016 11:24:23 GMT -5
How is Twigpaw the only prophecy cat? What if Leafpool went to SkyClan? In HJ, there is a vision of a she-cat that looks just like Hawkwing, his daughter. Everyone with half a brain cell can tell that it was Twigpaw, but there is no trace of Violetpaw. In my opinion. She isin't his daughter |
|
|
|
Post by pastelpills on Dec 10, 2016 11:34:33 GMT -5
In HJ, there is a vision of a she-cat that looks just like Hawkwing, his daughter. Everyone with half a brain cell can tell that it was Twigpaw, but there is no trace of Violetpaw. In my opinion. She isin't his daughter I think it is fairly obvious at this point, but yeah. We have to see. |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 11, 2016 9:56:08 GMT -5
I think that Violetpaw and Twigpaw should go to SkyClan. That way Violetpaw won't suffer with the rogues and ShadowClan, and Twigpaw won't be lonely. Plus, SkyClan has received a prophecy, and Twigpaw and Violetpaw probably have to do with it. Because one of the phrases in the prophecy is: Clear the sky. This definitely refers to SkyClan. Also, I'm convinced that Twigpaw and Violetpaw are Hawkwing's daughters. SPOILERS Only Twigpaw is the prophecy cat I dont feel like its Twigpaw. We need a cat that loka exactly like Hawkwing to the last peice of fur. That only means Pebbleshines kits which arent Voiletpaw and Twigpaw. I think if Pebbleshine lives she will get a POV and come back to the clans eith Skyclan. Twigpaw and Hawkwing dont look fully alike. In Echosongs vision. This cat was fully looking like Hawkwing. |
|
|
|
Post by pastelpills on Dec 11, 2016 12:13:56 GMT -5
SPOILERS Only Twigpaw is the prophecy cat I dont feel like its Twigpaw. We need a cat that loka exactly like Hawkwing to the last peice of fur. That only means Pebbleshines kits which arent Voiletpaw and Twigpaw. I think if Pebbleshine lives she will get a POV and come back to the clans eith Skyclan. Twigpaw and Hawkwing dont look fully alike. In Echosongs vision. This cat was fully looking like Hawkwing. Just a little note.
It would be extremely lame if they were not his kits. I'm for plot twists and all of that, but c'mon. Besides, Warriors tend to be very predictable. And they look a lot alike, actually. We only know Twigpaw is gray. We don't know if she's dark gray or not (which I think might be described in future books). As for the eye color, remember that Hollyleaf was said to look just like Crowfeather, while she is black and he is gray and they have different eye colors. It never said that she looked fully like Hawkwing. And there was a couple of times where cats were said to look exactly like one another, yet they had different details (like Crowfeather and Hollyleaf).
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 11, 2016 12:24:30 GMT -5
I dont feel like its Twigpaw. We need a cat that loka exactly like Hawkwing to the last peice of fur. That only means Pebbleshines kits which arent Voiletpaw and Twigpaw. I think if Pebbleshine lives she will get a POV and come back to the clans eith Skyclan. Twigpaw and Hawkwing dont look fully alike. In Echosongs vision. This cat was fully looking like Hawkwing. Just a little note.
It would be extremely lame if they were not his kits. I'm for plot twists and all of that, but c'mon. Besides, Warriors tend to be very predictable. And they look a lot alike, actually. We only know Twigpaw is gray. We don't know if she's dark gray or not (which I think might be described in future books). As for the eye color, remember that Hollyleaf was said to look just like Crowfeather, while she is black and he is gray and they have different eye colors. It never said that she looked fully like Hawkwing. And there was a couple of times where cats were said to look exactly like one another, yet they had different details (like Crowfeather and Hollyleaf).
The thing is Pebbleshine is a pretty important charecter. She wouldint just die like that. Twigpaw is important but she doesnt seem like his daughter. Twigpaw doesnt act like Pebbleshine : well knowing and able to make a decesion. Or like Hawkwing: Hard headed yet can make a desion for the best. |
|
|
|
Post by pastelpills on Dec 11, 2016 12:27:46 GMT -5
Just a little note.
It would be extremely lame if they were not his kits. I'm for plot twists and all of that, but c'mon. Besides, Warriors tend to be very predictable. And they look a lot alike, actually. We only know Twigpaw is gray. We don't know if she's dark gray or not (which I think might be described in future books). As for the eye color, remember that Hollyleaf was said to look just like Crowfeather, while she is black and he is gray and they have different eye colors. It never said that she looked fully like Hawkwing. And there was a couple of times where cats were said to look exactly like one another, yet they had different details (like Crowfeather and Hollyleaf).
The thing is Pebbleshine is a pretty important charecter. She wouldint just die like that. Twigpaw is important but she doesnt seem like his daughter. Twigpaw doesnt act like Pebbleshine : well knowing and able to make a decesion. Or like Hawkwing: Hard headed yet can make a desion for the best. Pebbleshine isn't that important really. Twigpaw is still young and naive. This doesn't prove anything. People, especially in books don't always have the same personality as their parents, so frankly, it's no proof. Same goes for Violetpaw. |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 11, 2016 12:51:06 GMT -5
The thing is Pebbleshine is a pretty important charecter. She wouldint just die like that. Twigpaw is important but she doesnt seem like his daughter. Twigpaw doesnt act like Pebbleshine : well knowing and able to make a decesion. Or like Hawkwing: Hard headed yet can make a desion for the best. Pebbleshine isn't that important really. Twigpaw is still young and naive. This doesn't prove anything. People, especially in books don't always have the same personality as their parents, so frankly, it's no proof. Same goes for Violetpaw. page 425 of Hawkwings Journey Echosong : "After I went back to sleep. She continued at last. " I had a vision of young she-cat that looked EXACTLY like you Hawkwing. At her paws was a maple leaf. Do you know what this means ?". This is me quoting the book. Proof cant get more real than this. |
|
|
|
Post by pastelpills on Dec 11, 2016 13:24:46 GMT -5
Pebbleshine isn't that important really. Twigpaw is still young and naive. This doesn't prove anything. People, especially in books don't always have the same personality as their parents, so frankly, it's no proof. Same goes for Violetpaw. page 425 of Hawkwings Journey Echosong : "After I went back to sleep. She continued at last. " I had a vision of young she-cat that looked EXACTLY like you Hawkwing. At her paws was a maple leaf. Do you know what this means ?". This is me quoting the book. Proof cant get more real than this. "proof can't get more real than this"
I literally have nothing to say, only that I'm convinced and nothing can convince me otherwise, and you will see yourself when it turns out it's her father. Like, c'mon. This is Erins we are talking about. Two kits were found. A queen expecting kits got lost. The two found kits are likely part of a prophecy, and a she-cat which is the daughter of the lost queen also seems to be a prophecy cat and both are gray. That is proof enough for me. Besides, like I said above, cats have been described to look just like their parents when they didn't. This is warriors and cats. Echosong probably meant just the fact that she's gray, because again, eye colors don't clearly matter in look-alikeness in warriors and Twigpaw can still be dark gray.
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 11, 2016 13:30:14 GMT -5
page 425 of Hawkwings Journey Echosong : "After I went back to sleep. She continued at last. " I had a vision of young she-cat that looked EXACTLY like you Hawkwing. At her paws was a maple leaf. Do you know what this means ?". This is me quoting the book. Proof cant get more real than this. "proof can't get more real than this"
I literally have nothing to say, only that I'm convinced and nothing can convince me otherwise, and you will see yourself when it turns out it's her father. Like, c'mon. This is Erins we are talking about. Two kits were found. A queen expecting kits got lost. The two found kits are likely part of a prophecy, and a she-cat which is the daughter of the lost queen also seems to be a prophecy cat and both are gray. That is proof enough for me. Besides, like I said above, cats have been described to look just like their parents when they didn't. This is warriors and cats. Echosong probably meant just the fact that she's gray, because again, eye colors don't clearly matter in look-alikeness in warriors and Twigpaw can still be dark gray.
But the thing that bothers me is why would Pebbleshine be so close to the lakes ?? The clan cats went the opposite way and theres no chicken factory near the lake what so ever |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 11, 2016 13:39:41 GMT -5
"proof can't get more real than this"
I literally have nothing to say, only that I'm convinced and nothing can convince me otherwise, and you will see yourself when it turns out it's her father. Like, c'mon. This is Erins we are talking about. Two kits were found. A queen expecting kits got lost. The two found kits are likely part of a prophecy, and a she-cat which is the daughter of the lost queen also seems to be a prophecy cat and both are gray. That is proof enough for me. Besides, like I said above, cats have been described to look just like their parents when they didn't. This is warriors and cats. Echosong probably meant just the fact that she's gray, because again, eye colors don't clearly matter in look-alikeness in warriors and Twigpaw can still be dark gray.
But the thing that bothers me is why would Pebbleshine be so close to the lakes ?? The clan cats went the opposite way and theres no chicken factory near the lake what so ever Wait do you think Pebbleshine is alive? |
|
|
|
Post by pastelpills on Dec 11, 2016 13:59:59 GMT -5
But the thing that bothers me is why would Pebbleshine be so close to the lakes ?? The clan cats went the opposite way and theres no chicken factory near the lake what so ever Wait do you think Pebbleshine is alive? 1. yes
2. they werent that close to the lake
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 11, 2016 14:17:42 GMT -5
Wait do you think Pebbleshine is alive? 1. yes
2. they werent that close to the lake
K so I was looking st the cover of Hawkwings journey and Twigpaw kinda looks like now that i see the resemblence. But I still want Pebbleshine to become a Ferncloud of Skyclan |
|
