|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 7:06:11 GMT -5
And it is obviously not true.
Basically, Thistleclaw killed Tigerpaw at his warrior assessment. Tigerpaw firmly got a grip on how [probably StarClan] works and went back down.
He acted as if nothing happened as he rose through the ranks of ThunderClan. Ya know, the normal The Prophecies Begin arc plotline.
He wasn't killed by Scourge, he was fighting a warrior and he ran into the forest on the verge of his second death. He went back to StarClan, where he was soon chased out.
How do you think the series would've been affected if this theory was true?
|
|
|
|
Post by neb on Jul 31, 2016 8:24:52 GMT -5
And it is obviously not true. Basically, Thistleclaw killed Tigerpaw at his warrior assessment. Tigerpaw firmly got a grip on how [probably StarClan] works and went back down. He acted as if nothing happened as he rose through the ranks of ThunderClan. Ya know, the normal The Prophecies Begin arc plotline. He wasn't killed by Scourge, he was fighting a warrior and he ran into the forest on the verge of his second death. He went back to StarClan, where he was soon chased out. How do you think the series would've been affected if this theory was true? Well the plot would have been 10x better |
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 8:42:03 GMT -5
And it is obviously not true. Basically, Thistleclaw killed Tigerpaw at his warrior assessment. Tigerpaw firmly got a grip on how [probably StarClan] works and went back down. He acted as if nothing happened as he rose through the ranks of ThunderClan. Ya know, the normal The Prophecies Begin arc plotline. He wasn't killed by Scourge, he was fighting a warrior and he ran into the forest on the verge of his second death. He went back to StarClan, where he was soon chased out. How do you think the series would've been affected if this theory was true? Well the plot would have been 10x better Tigerclaw's Fury would be amazingly strange. |
|
|
|
Post by neb on Jul 31, 2016 8:43:19 GMT -5
Well the plot would have been 10x better Tigerclaw's Fury would be amazingly strange. I want your dream as a novella. |
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 9:10:47 GMT -5
Tigerclaw's Fury would be amazingly strange. I want your dream as a novella. I could imagine this being the plot: 1: Tigerkit learns that his father has left the Clan. He starts bawling as Leopardfoot slaps some sense into him. 2: Tigerpaw is at an assessment. Thistleclaw kills him. 3: Tigerpaw is in StarClan. He shouts, "I'm not dying yet!" then leaves. 4: Tigerpaw comes back to Thistleclaw's dismay. He buries his old body. 5: Rusty joins ThunderClan, sadness fills up Tigerclaw's belly. 6: Tigerclaw is banished from ThunderClan after assaulting and nearly killing Bluestar. 7: Tigerclaw meets up with Brokenstar's followers and learns about poor ShadowClan. 8: The band of rogues are assaulted by a ShadowClan patrol. They win and say that they are rejoining ShadowClan. 9: ShadowClan says kk and then they learn that both their leader and deputy have died. RIP The rogues say that Tigerclaw is the only cat who can make ShadowClan great again. 10: Tigerclaw goes to the moonstone, then hits a key realization. How can he possibly be a leader with nine lives? A cat suggests that he sucks the souls of nine cats and see what happens. 11: K, Tigerclaw says. He finds nine cats and somehow steals all of their souls because why not. He announces himself Tigerstar, the leader of ShadowClan. |
|
|
|
Post by neb on Jul 31, 2016 9:16:13 GMT -5
I want your dream as a novella. I could imagine this being the plot: 1: Tigerkit learns that his father has left the Clan. He starts bawling as Leopardfoot slaps some sense into him. 2: Tigerpaw is at an assessment. Thistleclaw kills him. 3: Tigerpaw is in StarClan. He shouts, "I'm not dying yet!" then leaves. 4: Tigerpaw comes back to Thistleclaw's dismay. He buries his old body. 5: Rusty joins ThunderClan, sadness fills up Tigerclaw's belly. 6: Tigerclaw is banished from ThunderClan after assaulting and nearly killing Bluestar. 7: Tigerclaw meets up with Brokenstar's followers and learns about poor ShadowClan. 8: The band of rogues are assaulted by a ShadowClan patrol. They win and say that they are rejoining ShadowClan. 9: ShadowClan says kk and then they learn that both their leader and deputy have died. RIP The rogues say that Tigerclaw is the only cat who can make ShadowClan great again. 10: Tigerclaw goes to the moonstone, then hits a key realization. How can he possibly be a leader with nine lives? A cat suggests that he sucks the souls of nine cats and see what happens. 11: K, Tigerclaw says. He finds nine cats and somehow steals all of their souls because why not. He announces himself Tigerstar, the leader of ShadowClan. The fan fiction is writing itself |
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 9:24:35 GMT -5
I could imagine this being the plot: 1: Tigerkit learns that his father has left the Clan. He starts bawling as Leopardfoot slaps some sense into him. 2: Tigerpaw is at an assessment. Thistleclaw kills him. 3: Tigerpaw is in StarClan. He shouts, "I'm not dying yet!" then leaves. 4: Tigerpaw comes back to Thistleclaw's dismay. He buries his old body. 5: Rusty joins ThunderClan, sadness fills up Tigerclaw's belly. 6: Tigerclaw is banished from ThunderClan after assaulting and nearly killing Bluestar. 7: Tigerclaw meets up with Brokenstar's followers and learns about poor ShadowClan. 8: The band of rogues are assaulted by a ShadowClan patrol. They win and say that they are rejoining ShadowClan. 9: ShadowClan says kk and then they learn that both their leader and deputy have died. RIP The rogues say that Tigerclaw is the only cat who can make ShadowClan great again. 10: Tigerclaw goes to the moonstone, then hits a key realization. How can he possibly be a leader with nine lives? A cat suggests that he sucks the souls of nine cats and see what happens. 11: K, Tigerclaw says. He finds nine cats and somehow steals all of their souls because why not. He announces himself Tigerstar, the leader of ShadowClan. The fan fiction is writing itself What if it was part of a roleplay in which a bunch of theories, serious, silly or just plain dumb, comes true. |
|
|
|
Post by neb on Jul 31, 2016 9:45:04 GMT -5
The fan fiction is writing itself What if it was part of a roleplay in which a bunch of theories, serious, silly or just plain dumb, comes true. Can we start that. It would be great. Joke clans are allowed as well: |
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 9:49:33 GMT -5
What if it was part of a roleplay in which a bunch of theories, serious, silly or just plain dumb, comes true. Can we start that. It would be great. Joke clans are allowed as well: Ashfur is Dovewing's and Ivypool's father. This theory. Myler is a judgement spirit. Three theories that should come true. |
|
|
|
Post by neb on Jul 31, 2016 9:55:26 GMT -5
Can we start that. It would be great. Joke clans are allowed as well: Ashfur is Dovewing's and Ivypool's father. This theory. Myler is a judgement spirit. Three theories that should come true. Yes this is great. Quality content |
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 10:11:43 GMT -5
Ashfur is Dovewing's and Ivypool's father. This theory. Myler is a judgement spirit. Three theories that should come true. Yes this is great. Quality content I'll collect as many theories as possible. |
|
|
|
Post by neb on Jul 31, 2016 10:14:46 GMT -5
Yes this is great. Quality content I'll collect as many theories as possible. We should make a rp out of this oml |
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 10:18:04 GMT -5
Two kind of dumb theories:
Cinderheart loved Hollyleaf and she only mated with Lionblaze to get kits related to her
Darkstripe was Brindleface's mate but loved Tigerstar at the same time. And he was the father of Ashfur and Ferncloud.
|
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 10:25:22 GMT -5
More dumb theories off of a WCF thread;
Ya know... I've actually seen a lot of weird ones but they are interesting....
Brichfall had a forbidden relationship with Applefur, and their kits were Pinenose and Ferretclaw. Smokefoot was Applefur's cover-up mate.
Pinenose's kit in The Last Hope was named Birchkit, since Applefur had told Ferretclaw and Pinenose their real father was Birchfall.
Mousefur loved Redtail, which is why she never took a mate.
Hazeltail loved Jayfeather.
Leopardstar loved Whiteclaw before she loved Tigerstar, which is why she never took a mate.
Poppyfrost loved Jayfeather and only took Berrynose as a mate because he seemed like he liked her and she just went with it.
Jayfeather had a crush on Poppyfrost at some point.
A lot of shipping theories!
Once whenever I was in middle school, my friends tried to convince me that Tallstar was the father of Jayfeather, Lionblaze and Hollyleaf. :\ I don't even remember why they thought that but they did and they were like "THERE'S SO MUCH PROOF!!!!!!!!!!!! WHY DON'T YOU BELIEVE US???"
I was convinced for the longest time that Hollyleaf was actually Shadow's reincarnation XD But then again I was also 120% sure that Ivypool was actually Hawkfrost's daughter with Whitewing so I guess that's a bit normal...
1)The main reason why Mothwing didn't believe in StarClan was because she was in love with Leafpool.
2) Squirrelflight shippers gone mad: Crowfeather as Crowpaw liked her at first, Shrewpaw liked her at one point. Add these to the fact that Stormfur loved her once, Ashfur loved her, and Brambleclaw loved her, and you've got a Squirrelflight with 5 lovers. Far-fetched, anyone?
3) Back with Shrewpaw; Whitewing loved him? Pft.
4) I won't say it exactly, as it is forum-inappropriate: Darkstripe tried to mate Ferncloud during training. He never had any interest in Ferncloud, or in any shecat, I think.
5) Jake, Firestar's father is half ShadowClan. Really.
6) Sandpaw liked Firestar to begin with, she just didn't know how to 'express her feelings'. Again, REALLY.
7) Squirrelflight is the reincarnation of Scourge, that's why she has a white paw. *facepalm anyone?*
|
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 10:29:43 GMT -5
|
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 10:33:58 GMT -5
Tigerstar truly loved Sasha.
Molewhisker will fall in love with Ivypool.
Blackclaw is the father of Mistystar's kits. After Blackclaw found out about Mistystar being half-Clan he broke up with her. After the battle with BloodClan, he realized he had been wrong and said he still loved her, but Mistystar was over him and told him that what he had said wasn't true and that she would never get back together with him.
Whiteclaw and Leopardstar loved each other, but Leopardstar got over him and fell in love with Tigerstar.
Tigerstar and Leopardstar had kits, but she never let her Clan know and gave them to a mother rogue who had lost her kits.
Willowpelt only had a small crush on Tawnyspots, she didn't really love him. However, Tawnyspots truly did love her. Willowpelt got over him after about a moon though.
Fuzzypelt and Robinwing had a fight and broke up. Robinwing soon developed a crush on Patchpelt and had Longtail with him, but she would never love him the way she loved Fuzzypelt, so they broke up and Robinwing got with Fuzzypelt again.
Patchpelt pressured Willowpelt into a relationship with him to make Robinwing jealous because he thought she loved him. He even went so far to try to have kits with her, and soon it was announced Robinwing was having Fuzzypelt's kits. Patchpelt broke up with Willowpelt. Willowpelt soon told the Clan what Patchpelt had did with her.
Goldenflower hadn't been there when Willowpelt had announced what Patchpelt had done, and she loved him, and he soon fell in love with her. She was expecting Patchpelt's kits when she was told about what he had done, and she broke up with him.
Patchpelt and Goldenflower are mates in StarClan. Goldenflower still loves both Patchpelt and Tigerstar, though.
Frostpaw had a crush on Whitestorm as an apprentice, but he trusted her with his biggest secret- he loved her sister Brindlepaw. Frostpaw told Brindlepaw and she was heartbroken. Frostfur soon found comfort in a friend- Lionheart- and he fathered her kits.
Brindleface broke up with Redtail to be with Whitestorm, and he fathered her kits(Ashfur and Ferncloud). She was only crushing on him though- deep down she still loved Redtail. She realized this after Whitestorm and Willowpelt confessed they loved each other and Brindleface witnessed it, and she broke up with him. She was going to reconcile her relationship with Redtail, but he died the same day. They are mates again in StarClan.
Brindleface's unknown tom kits were named Redkit and Ravenkit. Redkit after Redtail, and Ravenkit after Ravenpaw(who the Clan thought was dead at the time).
Redtail mentored Mousefur.
Willowpelt was going to mentor Runningwind, but she got pregnant the day he was apprenticed, so Sunstar gave him to Bluestar to mentor.
Smudge became mates with Princess not long after Rusty left. She became pregnant with kits really soon, but their Twolegs found out, and Smudge's Twolegs took him to the vet so that they wouldn't have any more kits.
Mousefur loved Redtail, but knew he would never love her, and tried to hide her feelings. Many moons later, she developed a crush on Longtail.
Dappletail truly loved Stormtail, but got over him. She later fell in love with Thrushpelt, who had recently got over Bluefur. They had 2 litters of kits. Only one in the first litter survived(one died a few hours after birth, another was the one who was taken by a fox, and the whole second litter caught greencough), and he died shortly after becoming a warrior.
Lionheart mentored Dappletail's only surviving kit.
Thornclaw and Blossomfall will have kits.
Rosepetal loves Bumblestripe. She always has.
Bumblestripe and Rosepetal will have kits.
Dovewing will join Tigerheart in ShadowClan and have his kits.
Crowfrost will eventually die and Tigerheart will be ShadowClan's new deputy.
When Onestar dies, Harespring will choose Heathertail to be his deputy.
Breezepelt and Heathertail love each other.
Onestar will exile Breezepelt.
|
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 10:37:08 GMT -5
Stormpaw (Frankie) only stayed in thunderclan because he and cherryfall were in love
Mousewhisker falls in love with ivypool and they become mates
Rosepetal falls in love with bumblestripe and he realizes she is hopeless so he starts a family with her
Molewhisker becomes mates with Amberpaw
Dewpaw loves lilyheart and they have kits
Snowbirds kits are actually thornclaws kits not scorchfurs
Whitewing doesn't love birchfall but he loves her
Tigerheart doesn't love dovewing he loves blossomfall
Blossomfall is in love with mousewhisker but he loves ivypool
Thornclaw is in love with briarlight as well as snowbird
Greystripe has a crush on sandstorm
|
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 10:37:27 GMT -5
Firestar is pudgy fat
Some of the characters are based off celebrities
Ashfur was mental
RavenxBarley is true
Brightheart had a crush on Firestar at one point
|
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 10:37:56 GMT -5
Willowpelt mated with Tawnyspots for status, Patchpelt for lack of kits, but she truly loved Whitestorm.
Hollyleaf visited the Dark Forest unknowingly in her dream from Sunrise.
Mothwing was very close to Leafpool.
Blossomfall doesn't like any tom in her Clan.
Ivypool really, really admired Hollyleaf. It was heartbreaking to watch her die.
Swiftpaw loved Brightpaw.
I still firmly think Dovewing is on the autistic spectrum due to how she behaves and reacts.
Tallstar treated Firestar like a surrogate son. That's two cats - Yellowfang and Tallstar who see him this way.
|
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 10:38:42 GMT -5
Tawnyspots and Willowpelt only had a one night stand and Darkstripe was unwanted.
Patchpelt only mated with Willowpelt for the kits.
Whitestorm's true love is Willowpelt and he only had a crush on Brindleface.
Redtail was completely focused on being a warrior and only mated Brindleface for the kits and Brindleface truly loved him and only used Whitestorm to make him jealous and never planned to have kits with him.
Thrushpelt and Speckletail are from Robinwing's first litter.
Fuzzypelt and Robinwing had a fight and Robinwing only used Patchpelt to make him jealous.
Patchpelt and Smoky are both cowboy Casanovas. (I love Carrie Underwood!)
Dustpelt lost most of his family and Longtail lost his sight due to a curse for following Tigerstar.
Crookedstar's curse is still following his family.
Breezepelt will force Heathertail to have kits with him and those kits will cause problems for Hollypaw, Sorrelpaw, and Fernpaw.
Mousewhisker is in love with Minnowtail.
Jessy will return with kits (not Bramblestar's) and Bramblestar will be so busy playing father to these kits that he neglects his own.
Rowanstar still doesn't trust Tawnypelt and that is why he didn't appoint her deputy.
Tigerheart will use a ShadowClan she-cat to make Dovewing jealous when she is already pregnant with his kits.
Bumblestripe will get together with Rosepetal and have kits. Dovewing gets pregnant with Tigerheart's kits and moves to the nursery before Rosepetal and everyone thinks the father is Bumblestripe until Rosepetal moves into the nursery.
Thornclaw and Blossomfall will have kits after Thornclaw retires and Blossomfall will die during kitting.
Graystripe's love for Millie is an echo for Silverstream and that's why she looks so much like her. (Both are silver tabbies. Really, Erin?!)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 11:05:07 GMT -5
The "Darkstripe mating with Ferncloud" makes me imagine SSS Darkstripe is Darkstripe's canon voice (and Whirlpool's from Wings of Fire) Good job. I'll go post a planning page. |
|
|
|
Post by Uмвяᴀ on Jul 31, 2016 12:43:28 GMT -5
I once heard that Ivypool was in love with Tigerheart.
And that Squirrelflight had stillborn kits that were Ashfur's and took that as a sign that she should be with Brambleclaw.
A lot of those actually make good headcanons, though.
|
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 12:45:40 GMT -5
I once heard that Ivypool was in love with Tigerheart. And that Squirrelflight had stillborn kits that were Ashfur's and took that as a sign that she should be with Brambleclaw. A lot of those actually make good headcanons, though. I don't like it that some people treat headcanons as if they were fact.  |
|
|
|
Post by Uмвяᴀ on Jul 31, 2016 13:13:18 GMT -5
I once heard that Ivypool was in love with Tigerheart. And that Squirrelflight had stillborn kits that were Ashfur's and took that as a sign that she should be with Brambleclaw. A lot of those actually make good headcanons, though. I don't like it that some people treat headcanons as if they were fact. Me neither, but it is sometimes funny to watch a YouTube video made by some kid and laugh at all the "facts" they probably made up or heard form a friend. |
|
|
|
Post by Kenshin on Jul 31, 2016 13:15:02 GMT -5
|
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 13:20:34 GMT -5
I don't like it that some people treat headcanons as if they were fact. Me neither, but it is sometimes funny to watch a YouTube video made by some kid and laugh at all the "facts" they probably made up or heard from a friend. Same. |
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 13:21:23 GMT -5
Me when I woke up from that dream. |
|
Asexual
Sootfeather
Now a BNHA addict. Mina Ashido is the best girl and I will fight you all on that.
|
Post by Sootfeather on Jul 31, 2016 14:11:02 GMT -5
I once heard that Ivypool was in love with Tigerheart. And that Squirrelflight had stillborn kits that were Ashfur's and took that as a sign that she should be with Brambleclaw. A lot of those actually make good headcanons, though. "Squirrelflight pregnant with Ashfur's kits" no no god please no no nO NO (just thought this was noteworthy but I typed Ashfur instead of Squirrelflight at first so it was "Ashfur pregnant with") |
|
|
|
Post by nem on Jul 31, 2016 15:37:32 GMT -5
I once heard that Ivypool was in love with Tigerheart. And that Squirrelflight had stillborn kits that were Ashfur's and took that as a sign that she should be with Brambleclaw. A lot of those actually make good headcanons, though. "Squirrelflight pregnant with Ashfur's kits" no no god please no no nO NO (just thought this was noteworthy but I typed Ashfur instead of Squirrelflight at first so it was "Ashfur pregnant with") Good job. Someone once put that as a fact in front of my face. ;-; |
|
