The Timeline

Yeah I noticed it too. There should be a timeline that is redone, with added information. Such as kits, deaths, or even family relations.

I have a list of cats who were born in Warriors and I had no clue where to put Blossomkit and Swampkit on it. They died when ShC was driving out WC but their mother was still an apprentice despite the fact that she was practically an elder in ITW. In TF, Dawncloud appeared as a young warrior while during Tigerstar's nine lives ceremony in TUG she was a dead elder. Speaking of which...so was Tallpoppy. And she didn't even die until the battle in TLH.

It's canon....as Kestrelflight's catnip induced hallucination.

Maybe he had just read The Better Choice, and Yellowfang's Secret looked like The Darkest Hour compared to that.