im neutral on Squirrelflight. she got much better as she matured, but i really didn't like her as an apprentice. she was a bit of a brat, reminding me of Sandstorm at that age, but she did get better as she grew up.
she was a great sister to Leafpool, and did well with raising Leafpool's kits. this made me warm to her a little more.
during the time when Brambleclaw was spending more time with Hawkfrost, she did annoy me a bit. i mean, yeah,
Hawkfrost did turn out to be bad (we all saw that one coming) but she could have been more tolerant. she seemed to try and tell Brambleclaw what to do half the time and that really irritated me.
however, i did warm to her again when when Brambleclaw became distant with her once the truth of Hollyleaf, Jayfeather and Lionblaze's parentage was leaked. she did seem to try to get her mate back the whole time, and became much more mature, loving her kits with all her heart even though they weren't her own.
i haven't actually read Tallstar's SE so im probably going to miss out a load of important points here. i haven't really looked into the super edition, either, so sorry about that.
from what ive read and remember about Tallstar, i liked him. in my opinion, he was an excellent & reasonable leader of WindClan.
like i said, i haven't read the books in AGES so i don't remember much
