|
Post by Lightflame on Sept 18, 2016 23:51:21 GMT -5
It should have been Thrushpelt.
|
|
Asexual
Sootfeather
Now a BNHA addict. Mina Ashido is the best girl and I will fight you all on that.
|
Post by Sootfeather on Sept 19, 2016 14:55:19 GMT -5
Jesus Christ, genes barely matter when looking for parents. One of my kids can be blonde because my great great great great grandmother was blonde I think Sootfeather was referring to Ashfur's behavior toward Squirrelflight and her family back in PoT and not be able to see how a cat like Whitestorm could father someone who behaved so awfully...Unless that was what you meant in which case I agree. This. I honestly don't mind genetic differences. The only ones that bother me are Rainflower and Shellheart = Crookedstar and Oakheart as well as Clear Sky and Storm = Thunder
|
|
|
Post by Amber on Sept 19, 2016 15:11:20 GMT -5
I think Sootfeather was referring to Ashfur's behavior toward Squirrelflight and her family back in PoT and not be able to see how a cat like Whitestorm could father someone who behaved so awfully...Unless that was what you meant in which case I agree. This. I honestly don't mind genetic differences. The only ones that bother me are Rainflower and Shellheart = Crookedstar and Oakheart as well as Clear Sky and Storm = Thunder Actually when looking at it genetically, Oakheart and Crookedstar are genetically possible. Gray is a dilution of black and black cats produce brown kittens. It also works for the better because Rainflower is gray and toms only get their pelt colors from their mothers.
|
|
Asexual
Sootfeather
Now a BNHA addict. Mina Ashido is the best girl and I will fight you all on that.
|
Post by Sootfeather on Sept 19, 2016 15:12:06 GMT -5
This. I honestly don't mind genetic differences. The only ones that bother me are Rainflower and Shellheart = Crookedstar and Oakheart as well as Clear Sky and Storm = Thunder Actually when looking at it genetically, Oakheart and Crookedstar are genetically possible. Gray is a dilution of black and black cats produce brown kittens. It also works for the better because Rainflower is gray and toms only get their pelt colors from their mothers. Ah, I'm not huge genetics guy so I didn't really know any of this.
|
|
|
Post by Amber on Sept 19, 2016 15:20:43 GMT -5
Actually when looking at it genetically, Oakheart and Crookedstar are genetically possible. Gray is a dilution of black and black cats produce brown kittens. It also works for the better because Rainflower is gray and toms only get their pelt colors from their mothers. Ah, I'm not huge genetics guy so I didn't really know any of this. I didn't either when first looking into genetics. Though in Warriors, genetics don't matter much because the Erins didn't do their research.
|
|
|
Post by klondikeclaw on May 7, 2023 2:17:57 GMT -5
Granted, it's stated by Su instead of Vicky, but she actually helps Vicky with the series and here's the reasoning why it's him instead of someone else like, say, Runningwind. "Vicky already stated once that Whitestorm is their father, and he is. I had the same thoughts as you on this case. Also Whitestorm is guarding the nursery when Brindleface gave birth to the kits and he is talking and praising Ashpaw and Fernpaw when they are apprentices. The one time she said its Runningwind, well I would call this Vicky-cat-confusion. He wouldn't make sense at all. He never talked to Brindle, Fern or Ash or had something to do with them. = Father of Ashfur, Ferncloud and the two unnamed kits, mate of Brindleface, is Whitestorm." Vicky already said that her heart doesn't think it's Whitestorm and while I can see him being their father, I still have trouble believing it, especially since I can't really see Whitestorm as having two mates at once or leaving one for the other especially while one is still in the nursey. While cats are known for taking multiple mates at once even in the series, I still can't see Whitestorm being one of those cats, but that's just me. And Vicky never actually confirmed that Whitestorm was the father before this either, she just said "I think". What are your thoughts on this? The thing is, to say Whitestorm is Ashfur and Ferncloud's father because hes guarding the nursery is like saying Rosetail was the father because she also guarded the kits, its a warriors duty to keep the Queens and kits and Elders safe and sound, so the reasoning for that is very stupid, and would also mean a lot of cats would be a potential "father". Second reason is Whitestorm also praises Brightpaw, but that does not make her his daughter. Warrior praise has been given out to apprentices, parents or not, which means THAT reason is even MORE stupid, not to mention that not only did that mean the bloodline of thunderclan is more f-cked up than it originally was thought to be, it ALSO means that Whitestorm shagged another girl while his kits were still in the nursery, which cough cough makes him a BAD. PERSON. Aka, ruins his character. Another thing is IF he was their father, which he is NOT, that means Ashfur and Ferncloud were sent out by their FATHER to get chased by dogs that literally ripped two cats apart, and they were far older than Fernpaw and Ashpaw! So to say he is their father would not just ruin his character, but would also mean he intentionally put them in harms way, RIGHT AFTER THEIR MOTHER DIED!
|
|
Bisexual
#FF00EC
Name Colour
BҽɾɾყႦʅσσɱ
Villain Enjoyer
Finally reading Wind!
|
Post by BҽɾɾყႦʅσσɱ on May 7, 2023 2:36:54 GMT -5
Granted, it's stated by Su instead of Vicky, but she actually helps Vicky with the series and here's the reasoning why it's him instead of someone else like, say, Runningwind. "Vicky already stated once that Whitestorm is their father, and he is. I had the same thoughts as you on this case. Also Whitestorm is guarding the nursery when Brindleface gave birth to the kits and he is talking and praising Ashpaw and Fernpaw when they are apprentices. The one time she said its Runningwind, well I would call this Vicky-cat-confusion. He wouldn't make sense at all. He never talked to Brindle, Fern or Ash or had something to do with them. = Father of Ashfur, Ferncloud and the two unnamed kits, mate of Brindleface, is Whitestorm." Vicky already said that her heart doesn't think it's Whitestorm and while I can see him being their father, I still have trouble believing it, especially since I can't really see Whitestorm as having two mates at once or leaving one for the other especially while one is still in the nursey. While cats are known for taking multiple mates at once even in the series, I still can't see Whitestorm being one of those cats, but that's just me. And Vicky never actually confirmed that Whitestorm was the father before this either, she just said "I think". What are your thoughts on this? The thing is, to say Whitestorm is Ashfur and Ferncloud's father because hes guarding the nursery is like saying Rosetail was the father because she also guarded the kits, its a warriors duty to keep the Queens and kits and Elders safe and sound, so the reasoning for that is very stupid, and would also mean a lot of cats would be a potential "father". Second reason is Whitestorm also praises Brightpaw, but that does not make her his daughter. Warrior praise has been given out to apprentices, parents or not, which means THAT reason is even MORE stupid, not to mention that not only did that mean the bloodline of thunderclan is more f-cked up than it originally was thought to be, it ALSO means that Whitestorm shagged another girl while his kits were still in the nursery, which cough cough makes him a BAD. PERSON. Aka, ruins his character. Another thing is IF he was their father, which he is NOT, that means Ashfur and Ferncloud were sent out by their FATHER to get chased by dogs that literally ripped two cats apart, and they were far older than Fernpaw and Ashpaw! So to say he is their father would not just ruin his character, but would also mean he intentionally put them in harms way, RIGHT AFTER THEIR MOTHER DIED! Hello, welcome to the forums! Please try to avoid posting on threads which are over a month or in this case even multiple years old, as that is considered necroposting on here and against forum rules/guidelines, thank you. Sand, please lock this thread.
|
|