|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 11, 2016 5:52:27 GMT -5
Now that Thunder and Shadow has made its official debut and more people have read it, I've decided to make this thread. Basically, this is just posting your predictions for the future of this series. If can be of Shattered Sky which is up next in the release date for April 11. 2017, or the very last book of the series.
Or if you prefer, your general review of the series so far as how it compares to its predecessors.
|
|
|
|
Post by Emberleaf on Sept 11, 2016 6:24:36 GMT -5
I'll probably post something here once I finish reading TaS!
|
|
|
|
Post by nem on Sept 11, 2016 7:35:21 GMT -5
*AVOS
I bet you that SkyClan will not join in with the rest of the Clans, they'll go back to the gorge. There isn't a reason for them not to.
|
|
|
|
Post by mEmE on Sept 11, 2016 7:52:20 GMT -5
*AVOS I bet you that SkyClan will not join in with the rest of the Clans, they'll go back to the gorge. There isn't a reason for them not to. If that happens I'll be really pissed off, because then it means that the clans spent another arc doing jackshit. I would've thought this series would end in SkyClan joining the rest. Then again, there is no space and no trees for them anyways |
|
|
|
Post by nem on Sept 11, 2016 7:59:28 GMT -5
*AVOS I bet you that SkyClan will not join in with the rest of the Clans, they'll go back to the gorge. There isn't a reason for them not to. If that happens I'll be really pissed off, because then it means that the clans spent another arc doing jackshit. I would've thought this series would end in SkyClan joining the rest. Then again, there is no space and no trees for them anyways What I think will happen is that they'll change the warrior code, actually. I have a feeling that it's going to become problematic. |
|
|
|
Post by mEmE on Sept 11, 2016 8:17:23 GMT -5
If that happens I'll be really pissed off, because then it means that the clans spent another arc doing jackshit. I would've thought this series would end in SkyClan joining the rest. Then again, there is no space and no trees for them anyways What I think will happen is that they'll change the warrior code, actually. I have a feeling that it's going to become problematic. My friend and I made a joke about where all the clans will move to the mountains and start the entire thing all over again |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 11, 2016 9:13:31 GMT -5
I like how quickly the clans have plunged in danger, and it gives me vibes from The Prophecy Begins and The New Prophecy, which are my personal favorites. While POT and OOTS were 5 books of long, sometimes boring suspense with a bit of drama thrown in just to make the wait not so painful, and then finally on the 6th book crazy things happening- this new series has had quite a few crazy things happen- and it's only been 2 books. It not only makes me anxious for what will happen in the future, but it keeps me hooked on what is happening now. If this was OOTS, TAS would just be the same-old clans, doing the same-old things and maybe Twigpaw and Violetpaw struggling with teenage drama and playing the "no one loves me" card. But instead, along with their struggling relationship we have a very real problem- a clan losing their entire identity especially as two sisters are now no longer divided by borders, but also by values, laws, and ways of life. I'm slightly disappointed that ShadowClan is one again the clan to be taken over by a evil leader, but honestly I'll take it- since this is, imo, one of the best plots Warriors has ever had. So by now I don't care which clan the corruption is in.
But yeah, regarding what will happen to the clans... I honestly don't know ^^" but I'm ok with that, cause it's exciting not knowing. I'm baffled by how bringing SkyClan back will make this situation any better. They're in pieces, remember? Even if someone can bring a good 6-10 cats to the lake... that's not nearly enough to try to win against Darktail, especially if he manages to take over another clan. I mean, I could be wrong, but it still seems odd.
And I honestly don't know what will happen to ShadowClan. Bramblestar seriously just formed a code protecting all the clans from being driven out- and I'm sure he would help ShadowClan escape their rogue leadership- but they don't want to escape it, at least not yet.
My theory of what I think though is that WindClan and RiverClan are going to want to drive out the rogues- and shadowclan with them- for the greater good so that all four clans don't get destroyed. But Bramblestar won't of course, cause he wants to wait for ShadowClan to get over themselves, and angry that ThunderClan weren't helping them, Onestar and Mistystar go against Bramblestar's pleas and form a united attack on the rogues. They fail miserably, and because the rogues have no problem killing, several warriors from RiverClan and WindClan are killed.
All during this, Alderheart and a few other cats are probably looking for SkyClan, find them, and when they find enough stragglers to form a clan- and convince them to come in the first place. When they make it back to the clans, they are in chaos. Darktail, taking advantage of RiverClan and WindClan's weakness, takes over RiverClan. By then even RiverClan and WindClan were starting to doubt the clan life and wonder if Darktail was right, and by the time he takes over half of RiverClan stay and join him, while the other half leave with Mistystar and shelter in WindClan or ThunderClan. A few cats from WindClan and ThunderClan desert to Darktail as well.
But yeah, that's all I can theorize for now. Really anything can happen.
|
|
|
|
Post by Wicked Witch on Sept 11, 2016 9:59:14 GMT -5
@galantis
"If this was OOTS, TAS would just be the same-old clans, doing the same-old things and maybe Twigpaw and Violetpaw struggling with teenage drama and playing the "no one loves me" card"
i personally thought this was what exactly happened. but i guess it how you look at it i guess?? idk i thought:
thunderclan still are helping other clans.
windclan and shadowclan are still problematic. the latter being even more so. we even get the same "hostage for herbs" subplot from OoTS.
riverclan is just there and mistystar is peaceful with hardly anything interesting going on in her clan which is just there.
violetpaw in one of her POVs said "I knew I shouldn't let myself believe anyone loved me." when Twigpaw leaves with the rescue patrol.
and Twigpaw herself kinda had those moments where she thought she would never find someone who would love her like Pinenose did Lionkit, Birchkit and Puddleshine.
|
|
|
|
Post by Wicked Witch on Sept 11, 2016 10:22:25 GMT -5
"Or if you prefer, your general review of the series so far as how it compares to its predecessors."
it was dawn of the clans were i stopped considering that all the series were equal in quality to me. it had a horrible first book and last book with the fifthe book being a set-up for this horrid book, it had too much focus on personal lives i didn't care about, the romances were absolutely terrible and a pain to read and the good villain dies in the same book they appear.
with AVoS, it just feels as bad as it is with DotC. the first book was boring, (a journey book) and alderpaw was kinda annoying, sparkpaw was one of the most boring protagonists this series has had and needlepaw was the only good thing in this book for me.
onto T&S needlepaw felt slightly ooc for me. i wish she ws still laid-back and passive about the issue and wasn't all over rain, unlike in taq where i remembered her just being chill with him and treating him like any other cat (i think?) i'm fine with her choosing rogues over her clan it's just how at times she felt... stereotypical? idk im kinda disappointed in her personality. and her name kinda. alderpaw gets less annoying for me but his a lot of his pov's occurred when he was at gatherings or a moonpool meetin which i thought was amusing. twigpaw's thing with wanting to being special got annoying real fast because of how overdone that word got in literally just one chapter. i feel violetpaw might develop some interesting ideals from how she was raised so i'd like to see how that plays out. she's still meh and sparkpelt is still boring.
thsi book was overestimated from the begninng for me because of how people said it was getting "dark." from the first 3 chapters. turned out 3 cats die: 2 of them are offscrreen, Littlecloud being one of them even though 2 pov's could have seen this and the other offscreen one being a guy who came back to life anyways so. but we get to see furzepelt death, a character i hardly know nor care about.
i'm not satisfied with this series so far and i feel i'll hate it just as much as i did DotC. i liked the first four series much better and equally.
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 13, 2016 14:09:23 GMT -5
*AVOS I bet you that SkyClan will not join in with the rest of the Clans, they'll go back to the gorge. There isn't a reason for them not to. It's not a big deal that she left off the a. No One complains when 'the' is left off the new prophecy. |
|
|
|
Post by nem on Sept 13, 2016 15:47:00 GMT -5
*AVOS I bet you that SkyClan will not join in with the rest of the Clans, they'll go back to the gorge. There isn't a reason for them not to. It's not a big deal that she left off the a. No One complains when 'the' is left off the new prophecy. It looks weird to me without the A. Plus, I would like it if someone corrected me if I got something wrong, or maybe minorly wrong. |
|
|
|
Post by Wicked Witch on Sept 13, 2016 16:41:15 GMT -5
right okay i predict:
redcough will occur because sparkpaw is red and plus when she blows up she'll be coughing up blood!1!
rowanastar will hesitate to take back his clan since he doesn't want to attack his clanmates... and fighing is teh only solution in warriors right?/??
redtail will be the new furzepelt. actually vice versa. i needed this idea to start with an 'r' like the rest,,,,,,,,
|
|
