|
Post by cygna on Apr 8, 2024 10:40:05 GMT -5
While I don't think Mothstar will happen, it's still a fun idea to me. If she somehow was able to interact with StarClan, here's who I think would give her lives: 1. Leafpool - Her once bestie & she trusts her. 2. Willowshine - Apprentice & one of the only cats she likes. 3. Mudfur - Mentor. 4. Leopardstar - The leader who admitted her into Riverclan. 5. Mistystar - Warrior mentor who seems to have a love/hate relationship with her. 6. Tadpole - I know he's probably not in StarClan but I wonder if he could visit to give her a life like Leafstar's Mother. 7. Sasha - If she's dead. 8. Pinestar - Maybe? 9. Harelight - He got exiled to ShadowClan with her at some point & he's dead so idk.
|
|
Bisexual
#FF00EC
Name Colour
BҽɾɾყႦʅσσɱ
Villain Enjoyer
Finally reading Wind!
|
Post by BҽɾɾყႦʅσσɱ on Apr 8, 2024 12:08:23 GMT -5
Mudfur Leopardstar Willowshine Leafpool Mistystar Tadpole Sasha Leopardfoot Riverstar
I pretty much agree with most of these (including the Wind spoiler option). Although I personally could also see other family members on her father's side want to give her a life, hence why I choose her paternal grandmother.
Goldenflower crossed my mind because I just think it would be sweet in a way to see Mothwing interact with her half-sibling's mother. Not sure why.
As for my choice of Riverstar, I just feel like he would want to give her a life to reassure her of deserving that position and prove to the rest of StarClan that he approves of her leading his Clan even if she (rightfully) doesn't trust them or their judgement blindly just because the Clans listen to them as their ancestors.
If Brambleclaw or Tawnypelt die or are dead in this scenario of her becoming leader, I definitely think either of them or both would give her a life as well even though their lack of proper interactions with her is still a dissapointment to me despite having accepted it in canon at this point.
|
|
|
Post by wygolvillage on Apr 8, 2024 12:34:30 GMT -5
Wow I agree with all of this list. I also really like the idea of Goldenflower giving her a life, it's very sweet. But I also think it would be cool (in a scenario where she does become leader) she can't receive any lives due to her being closed off from StarClan entirely, and seeing how she works with that during her leadership. It would be cool to see that kind of scenario work out for once rather than being a situation like Nightstar where he immediately dies and leaves his clan wholly unstable, (wind spoilers?) or Splashtail/star where it's proof of his dishonor/StarClan refusing him. Like, it would be neat to see a leader be competent despite having only one life.
|
|
|
Post by cygna on Apr 8, 2024 13:56:25 GMT -5
Mudfur Leopardstar Willowshine Leafpool Mistystar Tadpole Sasha Leopardfoot Riverstar I pretty much agree with most of these (including the Wind spoiler option). Although I personally could also see other family members on her father's side want to give her a life, hence why I choose her paternal grandmother. Goldenflower crossed my mind because I just think it would be sweet in a way to see Mothwing interact with her half-sibling's mother. Not sure why. As for my choice of Riverstar, I just feel like he would want to give her a life to reassure her of deserving that position and prove to the rest of StarClan that he approves of her leading his Clan even if she (rightfully) doesn't trust them or their judgement blindly just because the Clans listen to them as their ancestors. If Brambleclaw or Tawnypelt die or are dead in this scenario of her becoming leader, I definitely think either of them or both would give her a life as well even though their lack of proper interactions with her is still a dissapointment to me despite having accepted it in canon at this point. I would personally love if Leopardfoot gave her a life too, but I genuinely think the Erins forgot about her since Leopardfoot didn't even give her own son a life, though I hope that's due to her rejecting Tigerstar after seeing him become a murderer & not the Erins forgetting. I just think Pinestar would be more likely out of Mothwing's paternal family, as a Kittypet himself he'd be more likely to acknowledge her than possible xenophobes.
|
|
Bisexual
#FF00EC
Name Colour
BҽɾɾყႦʅσσɱ
Villain Enjoyer
Finally reading Wind!
|
Post by BҽɾɾყႦʅσσɱ on Apr 8, 2024 14:44:04 GMT -5
Mudfur Leopardstar Willowshine Leafpool Mistystar Tadpole Sasha Leopardfoot Riverstar I pretty much agree with most of these (including the Wind spoiler option). Although I personally could also see other family members on her father's side want to give her a life, hence why I choose her paternal grandmother. Goldenflower crossed my mind because I just think it would be sweet in a way to see Mothwing interact with her half-sibling's mother. Not sure why. As for my choice of Riverstar, I just feel like he would want to give her a life to reassure her of deserving that position and prove to the rest of StarClan that he approves of her leading his Clan even if she (rightfully) doesn't trust them or their judgement blindly just because the Clans listen to them as their ancestors. If Brambleclaw or Tawnypelt die or are dead in this scenario of her becoming leader, I definitely think either of them or both would give her a life as well even though their lack of proper interactions with her is still a dissapointment to me despite having accepted it in canon at this point. I would personally love if Leopardfoot gave her a life too, but I genuinely think the Erins forgot about her since Leopardfoot didn't even give her own son a life, though I hope that's due to her rejecting Tigerstar after seeing him become a murderer & not the Erins forgetting. I just think Pinestar would be more likely out of Mothwing's paternal family, as a Kittypet himself he'd be more likely to acknowledge her than possible xenophobes. I mean, I highly doubt Pinestar approved of his son's actions either when giving him a life. But him doing so does make sense in the context of StarClan warning him about what Tigerstar I would grow up to become. I nonetheless would like for Leopardfoot to do so instead since Pinestar already gave lives to two leaders (Bluestar and Tigerstar himself). Similarly to this, I would've loved for her to give Tawnypelt a life if she had become leader in AVoS instead of her son Tigerstar II (still mad we got robbed of Tawnystar).
|
|