I'm still loyal to
A Shadow in RiverClan because Feathertail is just that awesome there <3 I agree with
𝓣𝓲𝓷𝓾𝓿𝓲𝓮𝓵 that it would've been better if Feathertail and Stormfur hadn't forgiven Leopardstar in the end though.
Second favorite is definitely
A Thief in ThunderClan because CloudBright is the best canon ship and getting some more content on them was lovely to read through even though the main conflict of a prey stealer plot was!
Winds of Change is my third favorite despite hating Mudclaw (and Onestar too for that matter). But it was still interesting (albeit also infuriating at times) to see the rebellion from his PoV. Hawkfrost was the best character in that whole book, in my opinion, as he's just such a fun menace there.
Exile from ShadowClan was good but I just prefer the other three over it. Nightpelt/star was a great protagonist there though and I also enjoyed seeing more details of Brokenstar's villainous ways from back in the first book of the original arc.
Kinda sad that we'll never get to see a new SkyClan Graphic Novel in the style of James L. Barry though. Was really looking forward to that for next year but it's not going to happen now that he's parted ways with the
Warriors project (still wish him all the best of luck and success with his future projects, of course).