Best:
Firestar - Well written
Squirrelflight - Entertaining
Jayfeather - Plot-driven
Ivypool - Plot-driven
Gray Wing - Well written
Sun Shadow - Interesting
River Ripple - Interesting
Violetshine - Entertaining
Needletail - Interesting
Bristlefrost - Plot-driven
Rootspring - Entertaining
Crookedstar(CP) - Entertaining
Tallstar(TR) - Well written
Hawkwing(HJ) - Well written
Crowfeather(CT) - Entertaining
Graystripe(GV) - Well written
Cloudstar(Novel) - Well written
Ravenpaw(Novel) - Well written
Shadowstar(Novel) - Entertaining
Tree(Novel) - Entertaining
Okay:
Leafpool - Late plot development
Hollyleaf - Late plot development
Feathertail - Interesting
Flametail - Interesting
Alderheart - Late character development
Twigbranch - Late character development
Leafstar(SD) - Interesting
Moth Flight(MV) - Late plot development
Tigerstar(Novel) - Entertaining
Dovewing(Novel) - Late character development
Mapleshade(Novel) - Entertaining
Thunderstar(Novel) - Entertaining
Tawnypelt(Novel) - Interesting
Pebbleshine(Novel) - Late character development
Mothwing(Novel) - Interesting
Worst:
Lionblaze - Boring plotline
Dovewing - Unnecessary side drama
Rock - Boring
Clear Sky - Inconsistent character
Thunderstar - Boring
Shadowsight - Boring plotline
Bluestar(BP) - Plot bias
Yellowfang(YS) - Inconsistent character
Bramblestar(BrS) - Inconsistent character
Tigerheart(ThS) - Unnecessary side drama
Squirrelflight(SH) - Unnecessary Trash
Hollyleaf(Novel) - Boring
Mistystar(Novel) - Boring
Leafpool (Novel) - Boring plotline
Goosefeather(Novel) - Plot bias
Spottedleaf(Novel) - Unnecessary Trash
Pinestar(Novel) - Boring
Redtail(Novel) - Inconsistent plotline