|
Post by mymerlincat on Apr 10, 2020 13:41:01 GMT -5
Which cats do you believe will be dead by the end of this arc? Mine are:
Mistystar Squirrelflight Leafstar Mothwing Graystripe Tawnypelt Cloudtail Imposter's spirit Kestrelflight Crowfeather Tree
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 10, 2020 13:46:00 GMT -5
All the younger cats with a lot of potential, will be killed off in favor of the fan favorites who have been around forever.
|
|
|
|
Post by Pixie on Apr 10, 2020 14:10:17 GMT -5
I'm scared that they're going to kill off Twigbranch.
|
|
|
Post by *Ottersplash* on Apr 10, 2020 14:19:15 GMT -5
Mistystar and Graystripe, maybe Daisy
I don't think Tawnypelt is going anywhere. Rowanstar told her when she traveled to the Tribe that she would live a long, long life. Really, they're going to mainly focus on killing off young, side characters like they did in VoS
|
|
|
Post by dragonfruit on Apr 10, 2020 14:37:44 GMT -5
Greystripe is definitely screwed, and I wouldn’t be surprised if Bramblestar died too. Mistystar needs to go though.
|
|
|
Post by *Ottersplash* on Apr 10, 2020 14:51:08 GMT -5
Greystripe is definitely screwed, and I wouldn’t be surprised if Bramblestar died too. Mistystar needs to go though. I forgot about Bramblestar. I think he'll die too. I'm p sure Daisy is also getting an end of life trip in her novella. I'll be surprised if she isn't screwed like Graystripe
|
|
#add8e6
Name Colour
*Ravenpaw*
Warrior Fanatic
*reads books in a corner*
|
Post by *Ravenpaw* on Apr 10, 2020 21:59:43 GMT -5
Mistystar Leafstar A few more background characters that were just there Mothwing Graystripe Impostor(obviously)
|
|
Heterosexual
Spinestar
Got The Ashfur Tattoo!
|
Post by Spinestar on Apr 10, 2020 22:17:54 GMT -5
Mistystar Leafstar A few more background characters that were just there Mothwing Graystripe Impostor(obviously) agreed except I think imposter will go to Dark Forest, not die
and to add on to that list:
Thornclaw Reedwhisker Lionblaze Thriftear Oakfur Brightheart Birchfall some others
Honestly, based off the disappointing VOS battle, I'll be surprised if more than 5 cats die in the next 3 books.
|
|
|
Post by Skypaw13 on Apr 11, 2020 0:15:04 GMT -5
Not gonna make any hard and fast predictions because Warriors seems to always go more off of fan pandering than what actually makes sense, but I found myself a tad concerned for Jayfeather's safety in the first half of VoS.
|
|
|
Post by icefurs on Apr 11, 2020 1:02:45 GMT -5
Thriftear(i thought that the "she's dead and I killed her" quote was about her and Bristlefrost at first) Snaptooth Honeyfur Graystripe (we can only hope) Tigerstar II losing a life
I can also see all the current apprentices (not just TC) being killed off as warriors.
|
|
|
Post by vectoring34 on Apr 11, 2020 8:49:22 GMT -5
Mistystar Leafstar A few more background characters that were just there Mothwing Graystripe Impostor(obviously) agreed except I think imposter will go to Dark Forest, not die
and to add on to that list:
Thornclaw Reedwhisker Lionblaze Thriftear Oakfur Brightheart Birchfall some others
Honestly, based off the disappointing VOS battle, I'll be surprised if more than 5 cats die in the next 3 books.
The VOS battle kills more cats than any other battle in the series barring the Dark Forest battle, and it gets called disappointing. What kind of battle would make people happy? Because the problem is you start to break the setting and contradict the way every other battle has been fought in the series.
|
|
|
Post by wolfcry32 on Apr 11, 2020 10:23:19 GMT -5
I'd be appeased if more of the older generations and less of the newer ones died.
Mistystar has to be on her way out. I'd imagine Cloudtail, Brightheart, Thornclaw, Brackenfur, and Daisy might be on the chopping block too.
|
|
Heterosexual
Spinestar
Got The Ashfur Tattoo!
|
Post by Spinestar on Apr 11, 2020 10:46:59 GMT -5
agreed except I think imposter will go to Dark Forest, not die
and to add on to that list:
Thornclaw Reedwhisker Lionblaze Thriftear Oakfur Brightheart Birchfall some others
Honestly, based off the disappointing VOS battle, I'll be surprised if more than 5 cats die in the next 3 books.
The VOS battle kills more cats than any other battle in the series barring the Dark Forest battle, and it gets called disappointing. What kind of battle would make people happy? Because the problem is you start to break the setting and contradict the way every other battle has been fought in the series. The First Battle battle killed almost 15 cats
|
|
|
Post by vectoring34 on Apr 11, 2020 12:15:32 GMT -5
The VOS battle kills more cats than any other battle in the series barring the Dark Forest battle, and it gets called disappointing. What kind of battle would make people happy? Because the problem is you start to break the setting and contradict the way every other battle has been fought in the series. The First Battle battle killed almost 15 cats Which cats? The wiki names only six cats dead in that battle, that's two less than VOS at least(Bristlefrost didn't know the name of every body). Two of the dead are rogues as well, which brings the count down even further to only having a mere HALF as many clan cat deaths. I really am curious if there's any actual proof of such a huge number or not.
|
|
|
Post by Ivyfalcon on Apr 11, 2020 12:26:15 GMT -5
The VOS battle kills more cats than any other battle in the series barring the Dark Forest battle, and it gets called disappointing. What kind of battle would make people happy? Because the problem is you start to break the setting and contradict the way every other battle has been fought in the series. The First Battle battle killed almost 15 cats The only cats that died were Fircone, Frost, Rainswept Flower, Falling Feather, Jackdaw’s Cry, and Hawk Swoop.
|
|
|
Post by Ivyfalcon on Apr 11, 2020 12:27:27 GMT -5
I think/hope Graystripe, Mistystar, Leafstar, Thornclaw, Daisy, Crowfeather, and probably some more younger background characters will die.
|
|
Heterosexual
Spinestar
Got The Ashfur Tattoo!
|
Post by Spinestar on Apr 11, 2020 12:54:55 GMT -5
I think/hope Graystripe, Mistystar, Leafstar, Thornclaw, Daisy, Crowfeather, and probably some more younger background characters will die. Why not kill someone as important as a leader off when Ashfur is still at the height of his power or at least undefeated rather than waiting to kill them off after the main villain is defeated
|
|
|
Post by Ivyfalcon on Apr 11, 2020 13:10:50 GMT -5
I think/hope Graystripe, Mistystar, Leafstar, Thornclaw, Daisy, Crowfeather, and probably some more younger background characters will die. Why not kill someone as important as a leader off when Ashfur is still at the height of his power or at least undefeated rather than waiting to kill them off after the main villain is defeated Yeah, I would’ve liked for either Leafstar or Mistystar to die in the VOS battle, but since that didn’t happen I’d take anytime this arc.
|
|
|
Post by Skypaw13 on Apr 11, 2020 18:19:38 GMT -5
agreed except I think imposter will go to Dark Forest, not die
and to add on to that list:
Thornclaw Reedwhisker Lionblaze Thriftear Oakfur Brightheart Birchfall some others
Honestly, based off the disappointing VOS battle, I'll be surprised if more than 5 cats die in the next 3 books.
The VOS battle kills more cats than any other battle in the series barring the Dark Forest battle, and it gets called disappointing. What kind of battle would make people happy? Because the problem is you start to break the setting and contradict the way every other battle has been fought in the series. (responding to both you and Spinestar ) I was also really disappointed with the VoS battle. Not because of the number of deaths, but for many, many other reasons. For example, one of my favorite midseries battles (so not in any book 6), is the Battle of the Eclipse in... well, Eclipse. I don't recall anyone getting killed in that fight, but it was still one of the best battles for me. There was enough tension in the first half of the book that the fight didn't come out of nowhere, but was still suitably shocking (considering it was a surprise attack on our focal Clan, I don't expect overt statements-- you can build tension without being obvious). It hits you in the face, gives you a brief moment to recover, and then starts a long battle that involves multiple locations, characters, emotional events, and roles.
The battle goes for almost a third of Eclipse's chapters, and when it ended, there was still tension; we still didn't know whether the battle would start up again later on.
We had three unique perspectives- Lionpaw actually fighting, Hollypaw runnning and sending messages and gaining allies, and Jaypaw healing and being a generally badass combat medic.
We saw multiple locations- scenes of active fighting, scenes of ShadowClan being convinced to come fight, and scenes of ThunderClan queens and elders hearing the fighting outside and there being this low sense of dread. There's even a serious conversation of what happens if the camp is taken.
While no one (that I remember) died, we did have at least one serious injury of not only a major character to the audience, but an important character in our protagonists' lives. This injury affects and weighs on our main character's minds for the rest of the book, and another book beyond that. Comparing that to the VoS battle, I can't help but be supremely disappointed. Going in roughly the same order as the paragraph above... I didn't feel the tension in this book until about four chapters before the battle happened. I definitely saw the Impostor getting more and more unhinged, but this didn't translate into "imminent Clan war" until so much later in the book. I did like how Leafstar straight up betrayed ThunderClan, but I like it more in idea than in execution.
The battle itself lasts for a single chapter (or least the comparable length of one). It ends very abruptly and disappointingly as we just see every single cat minus the Impostor change to the same side. There's no questioning about this-- every single cat on the Impostor's side admits they were wrong, and every cat against the Impostor feels validated. When y'all talk about the Darkness Within battle, I feel like you must be referring to outside-of-book sources, because there's nothing in Veil of Shadows that made me feel like there would be a big battle in the next book. Most of the tension just straight up disappeared.
We had one perspective in this battle. Bristlefrost was in the middle of active fighting, and seemed to just observe her surroundings with very little thought. Rootspring and Shadowsight had chapters afterward, but if you want me to be satisfied with a "big bad battle", then I need to see these two actually participating in the action.
Similar to the one perspective, there was one location. The ShadowClan camp. Most of my points in this spoiler tag are things I thought of after reading the whole battle, but this one I was thinking while actually reading it. There needs to be more locations to this fight. Have Bristlefrost get chased out and run aimlessly around ShadowClan territory for two pages, that's all it takes! If we include my last point as well, we could keep Bristlefrost fighting in camp and have had a chapter of Rootspring up in the trees with TC warriors chasing him, or have Shadowsight running to the Exile's camp and telling them about the battle. Anything other than straight up fighting in the single location would have done leagues to make this battle way less disappointing.
This battle did kill multiple cats, but the problem is that the battle doesn't feel like it killed multiple cats. Bristlefrost is strangely detached from everyone around her. The only cat who died this entire book that she had an actual reaction to was Stemleaf, and that wasn't even in the battle. She sees Berrynose die and pretty much goes "wow, that looks bad" and continues fighting. She sees multiple bodies strewn across the ground and goes "Oh no..." and that's it! We don't even have serious injuries that cause her to even worry about the cat in question's safety. (This is a wider problem with Bristlefrost as a character, by the way. She's pretty much exclusively a camera with barely any thoughts outside of surface reactions to the things she's witnessing-- same problem that Dovewing had in the DF battle, except all the time). I didn't feel like Berrynose, Rosepetal, etc. died in an honorable battle-- I felt like they just disappeared like cats who die from offscreen greencough. Not helped by the fact that Bristlefrost doesn't even think about any of this after it happens, and Shadowsight and Rootspring don't have enough of a relationship with any cat who died to make it feel weighty. I can see why some people would correlate a high death toll to the satisfaction of a battle. It's very important to be able to feel the weight of a battle, especially when said battle has been hyped up so much. Death is usually a good way to add weight, but a fight is not more satisfying because of its high death toll-- the DF battle in TLH was disappointing to many people despite having the highest death count of pretty much any other fight up to that point. You can't even really make the point that the death toll is correlated in any way with how disappointing or not the battle was. There are satisfying battles with high and low death counts, and disappointing battles with high and low death counts. What's important is the stakes and how any deaths or injuries affect life moving forward.
|
|
|
Post by vectoring34 on Apr 11, 2020 19:43:30 GMT -5
The VOS battle kills more cats than any other battle in the series barring the Dark Forest battle, and it gets called disappointing. What kind of battle would make people happy? Because the problem is you start to break the setting and contradict the way every other battle has been fought in the series. (responding to both you and Spinestar ) I was also really disappointed with the VoS battle. Not because of the number of deaths, but for many, many other reasons. For example, one of my favorite midseries battles (so not in any book 6), is the Battle of the Eclipse in... well, Eclipse. I don't recall anyone getting killed in that fight, but it was still one of the best battles for me. There was enough tension in the first half of the book that the fight didn't come out of nowhere, but was still suitably shocking (considering it was a surprise attack on our focal Clan, I don't expect overt statements-- you can build tension without being obvious). It hits you in the face, gives you a brief moment to recover, and then starts a long battle that involves multiple locations, characters, emotional events, and roles.
The battle goes for almost a third of Eclipse's chapters, and when it ended, there was still tension; we still didn't know whether the battle would start up again later on.
We had three unique perspectives- Lionpaw actually fighting, Hollypaw runnning and sending messages and gaining allies, and Jaypaw healing and being a generally badass combat medic.
We saw multiple locations- scenes of active fighting, scenes of ShadowClan being convinced to come fight, and scenes of ThunderClan queens and elders hearing the fighting outside and there being this low sense of dread. There's even a serious conversation of what happens if the camp is taken.
While no one (that I remember) died, we did have at least one serious injury of not only a major character to the audience, but an important character in our protagonists' lives. This injury affects and weighs on our main character's minds for the rest of the book, and another book beyond that. Comparing that to the VoS battle, I can't help but be supremely disappointed. Going in roughly the same order as the paragraph above... I didn't feel the tension in this book until about four chapters before the battle happened. I definitely saw the Impostor getting more and more unhinged, but this didn't translate into "imminent Clan war" until so much later in the book. I did like how Leafstar straight up betrayed ThunderClan, but I like it more in idea than in execution.
The battle itself lasts for a single chapter (or least the comparable length of one). It ends very abruptly and disappointingly as we just see every single cat minus the Impostor change to the same side. There's no questioning about this-- every single cat on the Impostor's side admits they were wrong, and every cat against the Impostor feels validated. When y'all talk about the Darkness Within battle, I feel like you must be referring to outside-of-book sources, because there's nothing in Veil of Shadows that made me feel like there would be a big battle in the next book. Most of the tension just straight up disappeared.
We had one perspective in this battle. Bristlefrost was in the middle of active fighting, and seemed to just observe her surroundings with very little thought. Rootspring and Shadowsight had chapters afterward, but if you want me to be satisfied with a "big bad battle", then I need to see these two actually participating in the action.
Similar to the one perspective, there was one location. The ShadowClan camp. Most of my points in this spoiler tag are things I thought of after reading the whole battle, but this one I was thinking while actually reading it. There needs to be more locations to this fight. Have Bristlefrost get chased out and run aimlessly around ShadowClan territory for two pages, that's all it takes! If we include my last point as well, we could keep Bristlefrost fighting in camp and have had a chapter of Rootspring up in the trees with TC warriors chasing him, or have Shadowsight running to the Exile's camp and telling them about the battle. Anything other than straight up fighting in the single location would have done leagues to make this battle way less disappointing.
This battle did kill multiple cats, but the problem is that the battle doesn't feel like it killed multiple cats. Bristlefrost is strangely detached from everyone around her. The only cat who died this entire book that she had an actual reaction to was Stemleaf, and that wasn't even in the battle. She sees Berrynose die and pretty much goes "wow, that looks bad" and continues fighting. She sees multiple bodies strewn across the ground and goes "Oh no..." and that's it! We don't even have serious injuries that cause her to even worry about the cat in question's safety. (This is a wider problem with Bristlefrost as a character, by the way. She's pretty much exclusively a camera with barely any thoughts outside of surface reactions to the things she's witnessing-- same problem that Dovewing had in the DF battle, except all the time). I didn't feel like Berrynose, Rosepetal, etc. died in an honorable battle-- I felt like they just disappeared like cats who die from offscreen greencough. Not helped by the fact that Bristlefrost doesn't even think about any of this after it happens, and Shadowsight and Rootspring don't have enough of a relationship with any cat who died to make it feel weighty. I can see why some people would correlate a high death toll to the satisfaction of a battle. It's very important to be able to feel the weight of a battle, especially when said battle has been hyped up so much. Death is usually a good way to add weight, but a fight is not more satisfying because of its high death toll-- the DF battle in TLH was disappointing to many people despite having the highest death count of pretty much any other fight up to that point. You can't even really make the point that the death toll is correlated in any way with how disappointing or not the battle was. There are satisfying battles with high and low death counts, and disappointing battles with high and low death counts. What's important is the stakes and how any deaths or injuries affect life moving forward. I agree that there are much better battles and that kill count doesn't determine how satisfying a battle is. However, the comment I was responding to was directly correlating those two factors "Honestly, based off the disappointing VOS battle, I'll be surprised if more than 5 cats die in the next 3 books." And that is simply incorrect. If you're talking body count as the comment was, then the VOS battle is objectively not disappointing, having the absolute highest death toll of any battle between the clans in the whole series. In terms of plot or which characters died, sure, that's something else, but I was examining the idea that the VOS battle was somehow below par in terms of body count. I don't think that death count makes or breaks a battle, but I was examining it under that context because I feel like people have a skewed memory of kill counts in earlier battles. As an example, I saw 15 deaths being touted as a number for the amount of deaths in TFB(and a standard for battles which are devastating numbers wise), when in reality it's almost a mere third of that number.
|
|
|
Post by Skypaw13 on Apr 11, 2020 20:31:21 GMT -5
(responding to both you and Spinestar ) I was also really disappointed with the VoS battle. Not because of the number of deaths, but for many, many other reasons. For example, one of my favorite midseries battles (so not in any book 6), is the Battle of the Eclipse in... well, Eclipse. I don't recall anyone getting killed in that fight, but it was still one of the best battles for me. There was enough tension in the first half of the book that the fight didn't come out of nowhere, but was still suitably shocking (considering it was a surprise attack on our focal Clan, I don't expect overt statements-- you can build tension without being obvious). It hits you in the face, gives you a brief moment to recover, and then starts a long battle that involves multiple locations, characters, emotional events, and roles.
The battle goes for almost a third of Eclipse's chapters, and when it ended, there was still tension; we still didn't know whether the battle would start up again later on.
We had three unique perspectives- Lionpaw actually fighting, Hollypaw runnning and sending messages and gaining allies, and Jaypaw healing and being a generally badass combat medic.
We saw multiple locations- scenes of active fighting, scenes of ShadowClan being convinced to come fight, and scenes of ThunderClan queens and elders hearing the fighting outside and there being this low sense of dread. There's even a serious conversation of what happens if the camp is taken.
While no one (that I remember) died, we did have at least one serious injury of not only a major character to the audience, but an important character in our protagonists' lives. This injury affects and weighs on our main character's minds for the rest of the book, and another book beyond that. Comparing that to the VoS battle, I can't help but be supremely disappointed. Going in roughly the same order as the paragraph above... I didn't feel the tension in this book until about four chapters before the battle happened. I definitely saw the Impostor getting more and more unhinged, but this didn't translate into "imminent Clan war" until so much later in the book. I did like how Leafstar straight up betrayed ThunderClan, but I like it more in idea than in execution.
The battle itself lasts for a single chapter (or least the comparable length of one). It ends very abruptly and disappointingly as we just see every single cat minus the Impostor change to the same side. There's no questioning about this-- every single cat on the Impostor's side admits they were wrong, and every cat against the Impostor feels validated. When y'all talk about the Darkness Within battle, I feel like you must be referring to outside-of-book sources, because there's nothing in Veil of Shadows that made me feel like there would be a big battle in the next book. Most of the tension just straight up disappeared.
We had one perspective in this battle. Bristlefrost was in the middle of active fighting, and seemed to just observe her surroundings with very little thought. Rootspring and Shadowsight had chapters afterward, but if you want me to be satisfied with a "big bad battle", then I need to see these two actually participating in the action.
Similar to the one perspective, there was one location. The ShadowClan camp. Most of my points in this spoiler tag are things I thought of after reading the whole battle, but this one I was thinking while actually reading it. There needs to be more locations to this fight. Have Bristlefrost get chased out and run aimlessly around ShadowClan territory for two pages, that's all it takes! If we include my last point as well, we could keep Bristlefrost fighting in camp and have had a chapter of Rootspring up in the trees with TC warriors chasing him, or have Shadowsight running to the Exile's camp and telling them about the battle. Anything other than straight up fighting in the single location would have done leagues to make this battle way less disappointing.
This battle did kill multiple cats, but the problem is that the battle doesn't feel like it killed multiple cats. Bristlefrost is strangely detached from everyone around her. The only cat who died this entire book that she had an actual reaction to was Stemleaf, and that wasn't even in the battle. She sees Berrynose die and pretty much goes "wow, that looks bad" and continues fighting. She sees multiple bodies strewn across the ground and goes "Oh no..." and that's it! We don't even have serious injuries that cause her to even worry about the cat in question's safety. (This is a wider problem with Bristlefrost as a character, by the way. She's pretty much exclusively a camera with barely any thoughts outside of surface reactions to the things she's witnessing-- same problem that Dovewing had in the DF battle, except all the time). I didn't feel like Berrynose, Rosepetal, etc. died in an honorable battle-- I felt like they just disappeared like cats who die from offscreen greencough. Not helped by the fact that Bristlefrost doesn't even think about any of this after it happens, and Shadowsight and Rootspring don't have enough of a relationship with any cat who died to make it feel weighty. I can see why some people would correlate a high death toll to the satisfaction of a battle. It's very important to be able to feel the weight of a battle, especially when said battle has been hyped up so much. Death is usually a good way to add weight, but a fight is not more satisfying because of its high death toll-- the DF battle in TLH was disappointing to many people despite having the highest death count of pretty much any other fight up to that point. You can't even really make the point that the death toll is correlated in any way with how disappointing or not the battle was. There are satisfying battles with high and low death counts, and disappointing battles with high and low death counts. What's important is the stakes and how any deaths or injuries affect life moving forward. I agree that there are much better battles and that kill count doesn't determine how satisfying a battle is. However, the comment I was responding to was directly correlating those two factors "Honestly, based off the disappointing VOS battle, I'll be surprised if more than 5 cats die in the next 3 books." And that is simply incorrect. If you're talking body count as the comment was, then the VOS battle is objectively not disappointing, having the absolute highest death toll of any battle between the clans in the whole series. In terms of plot or which characters died, sure, that's something else, but I was examining the idea that the VOS battle was somehow below par in terms of body count. I don't think that death count makes or breaks a battle, but I was examining it under that context because I feel like people have a skewed memory of kill counts in earlier battles. As an example, I saw 15 deaths being touted as a number for the amount of deaths in TFB(and a standard for battles which are devastating numbers wise), when in reality it's almost a mere third of that number. I did say I was responding to both you and spinestar. My response to you was where I compared Eclipse and Veil of Shadows, since you asked "what kind of battle would make people happy?" So I told you what kind of battle would make me happy. Your response to spinestar was also not just responding to them, but including more people as well. Instead of saying "you call it disappointing. What kind of battle would make you happy?" which would imply you're asking a question directly to spine, you say "It gets called disappointing. What kind of battle would make people happy?", which to me looks like you're calling out a wider part of the fandom. I happen to fall into said part of the fandom who found the battle disappointing. So I responded to you. My response to spinestar was saying that death counts don't have any correlation with how satisfying the battle is. Since that was a much smaller part of my post, I tagged them and quoted you.
|
|
|
Post by vectoring34 on Apr 11, 2020 21:09:43 GMT -5
I agree that there are much better battles and that kill count doesn't determine how satisfying a battle is. However, the comment I was responding to was directly correlating those two factors "Honestly, based off the disappointing VOS battle, I'll be surprised if more than 5 cats die in the next 3 books." And that is simply incorrect. If you're talking body count as the comment was, then the VOS battle is objectively not disappointing, having the absolute highest death toll of any battle between the clans in the whole series. In terms of plot or which characters died, sure, that's something else, but I was examining the idea that the VOS battle was somehow below par in terms of body count. I don't think that death count makes or breaks a battle, but I was examining it under that context because I feel like people have a skewed memory of kill counts in earlier battles. As an example, I saw 15 deaths being touted as a number for the amount of deaths in TFB(and a standard for battles which are devastating numbers wise), when in reality it's almost a mere third of that number. I did say I was responding to both you and spinestar. My response to you was where I compared Eclipse and Veil of Shadows, since you asked "what kind of battle would make people happy?" So I told you what kind of battle would make me happy. Your response to spinestar was also not just responding to them, but including more people as well. Instead of saying "you call it disappointing. What kind of battle would make you happy?" which would imply you're asking a question directly to spine, you say "It gets called disappointing. What kind of battle would make people happy?", which to me looks like you're calling out a wider part of the fandom. I happen to fall into said part of the fandom who found the battle disappointing. So I responded to you. My response to spinestar was saying that death counts don't have any correlation with how satisfying the battle is. Since that was a much smaller part of my post, I tagged them and quoted you. I was referring to the fandom complaint regarding deaths, as that was another thread on the forums in and of itself and it seems to be based on not recalling prior battles generally having even less death.
|
|