|
Post by barberz on Mar 15, 2020 16:38:09 GMT -5
Ashfur is the most likely candidate right now, but lets say it isn't. Who would it be, and if it is Ashfur, who would be helping him?
Yes, I know, probably a decent amount of you are wondering, why would he need help? I just don't think Ashfur alone could dismantle the clans' entire connection with Starclan just like that. So it makes sense in my head that he has an accomplice.
Share your thoughts below, and I'm putting other candidates that I think are within reason, even if it is very stretched, so you guys can also debate on that.
1. Sol - He is my most likely candidate to either be or help the impostor, as he has some major beef with all 5 clans. He is also very mysterious and could probably hold enough knowledge to figure out how to sever that connection that the clans' have with starclan. He also tried to destroy the lake clans by using the code against them, and we know the impostor is once again manipulating the code to their will. 2. Tigerstar - Yes, we know he died two times, but I can't deny the fact that at least I personally am not comfortable with the cats just "disappearing" after dying two times. We know the spirit has to go somewhere, and it could have gone back to the ground as a punishment of some sort. He also has beef with the clans and may want to have another go at destroying them, by coming back as his own son, who betrayed him. Like, why did they pick Bramblestar? They could've picked any other leaders, and still could've done the same thing, but they picked Bramblestar. Tigerstar also despised codebreakers, and could be trying to destroy them with the code.
These are the only two I can think of right now, but I add some later if I think of them.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 15, 2020 16:48:11 GMT -5
Maybe it's a cat we haven't met yet? Which would be a little lame, but I think it'd be better than bringing back Tigerstar for the 18th time, and I really don't want Sol to be dead, but both of those are really good ideas.
|
|
|
|
Post by barberz on Mar 16, 2020 11:20:05 GMT -5
It’d have to be Sol. He is the number one cat who’d want to destroy the warrior code More than likely yes. I really want the impostor have an accomplice because otherwise the whole thing really doesn't make sense in my head
|
|
|
Post by jayfeather1234 on Mar 18, 2020 18:38:19 GMT -5
Maybe it is Rock as he is very mysterious, he is cursed with immortality for an unknown reason, and not that much is known about him. Why would he be cursed with immortality if is a good character? I have a theory where he is the future version of Jayfeather/Jay’s Wing.
The possessor could also maybe be Midnight as she is a ghost.
I don’t think that the possessor is Sol as he clearly wields his power through nonmagical means. Though I do believe that if he does not appear in a subplot to take advantage of the situation, then he would be a missed opportunity. I just want Sol to say something like “Knowledge is power” or “Chaos is a ladder” or something similar as cats don’t know what a ladder is.
|
|
Heterosexual
Spinestar
Got The Ashfur Tattoo!
|
Post by Spinestar on Mar 18, 2020 19:16:37 GMT -5
Maybe it is Rock as he is very mysterious, he is cursed with immortality for an unknown reason, and not that much is known about him. Why would he be cursed with immortality if is a good character? I have a theory where he is the future version of Jayfeather/Jay’s Wing. The possessor could also maybe be Midnight as she is a ghost. I don’t think that the possessor is Sol as he clearly wields his power through nonmagical means. Though I do believe that if he does not appear in a subplot to take advantage of the situation, then he would be a missed opportunity. I just want Sol to say something like “Knowledge is power” or “Chaos is a ladder” or something similar as cats don’t know what a ladder is. Well the choices for the imposter should at least be logical, rather than naming two characters who were by no means controversial, let alone evil as Kate said, "A controversial character would be returning" on BlogClan
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 18, 2020 19:17:41 GMT -5
Maybe it is Rock as he is very mysterious, he is cursed with immortality for an unknown reason, and not that much is known about him. Why would he be cursed with immortality if is a good character? I have a theory where he is the future version of Jayfeather/Jay’s Wing. The possessor could also maybe be Midnight as she is a ghost. I don’t think that the possessor is Sol as he clearly wields his power through nonmagical means. Though I do believe that if he does not appear in a subplot to take advantage of the situation, then he would be a missed opportunity. I just want Sol to say something like “Knowledge is power” or “Chaos is a ladder” or something similar as cats don’t know what a ladder is. Well the choices for the imposter should at least be logical, rather than naming two characters who were by no means controversial, let alone evil as Kate said, "A controversial character would be returning" on BlogClan
Was it ever stated that the impostor was the controversial character that would be returning though?
|
|
Heterosexual
Spinestar
Got The Ashfur Tattoo!
|
Post by Spinestar on Mar 18, 2020 19:36:38 GMT -5
Well the choices for the imposter should at least be logical, rather than naming two characters who were by no means controversial, let alone evil as Kate said, "A controversial character would be returning" on BlogClan
Was it ever stated that the impostor was the controversial character that would be returning though? This is where logic, common sense, and educated guesses all come into play.
And even if they somehow end up being 2 different characters, Rock and Midnight are two of the many considered characters should not even be considered at all. The Erins/HC would not put so much evidence pointing to someone who is murderously evil and a Squirrelflight-fanatic, and have all of it point to literally only one cat, and then all of a sudden be: BELATED APRIL FOOLS or GOTCHA or whatever, giving us a random character (and in the above case, a character who has only been portrayed as maybe good/helpful/well-intentioned with no hint of villainy and no clues pointing to them whatsoever) who almost no one was expecting. HC knows that the fandom won't appreciate that
and I am not trying to demean anyone here
|
|
|
Post by Moonrose on Mar 19, 2020 11:53:25 GMT -5
I think Thistleclaw could be the imposter. My reasons for this are:
1. Kate stated that it was a 'controversial' character; Thistleclaw was considered controversial in Spottedleaf's Heart, when he flirted with her and asked her to be his mate while she was still an apprentice.
2. Thistleclaw was known for his slightly more 'radical' views on Clan life; i.e. his fanatical hatred of rulebreakers and his wanting to go to war over a slight step over a border.
3. His time in the Dark Forest and training sessions for the Great Battle could have shown him how to use certain power, such as a very old warrior in the Dark Forest teaching him how to take the place of a living cat.
I honestly feel like the imposter is someone we have seen before, and while Ashfur is a good guess (and I honestly won't be shocked if it is him in the end), Thistleclaw is the only controversial cat I can think of. At least, he's the only one I think Kate would consider controversial.
|
|
|
Post by jayfeather1234 on Mar 23, 2020 18:54:07 GMT -5
I think Thistleclaw could be the imposter. My reasons for this are: 1. Kate stated that it was a 'controversial' character; Thistleclaw was considered controversial in Spottedleaf's Heart, when he flirted with her and asked her to be his mate while she was still an apprentice. 2. Thistleclaw was known for his slightly more 'radical' views on Clan life; i.e. his fanatical hatred of rulebreakers and his wanting to go to war over a slight step over a border. 3. His time in the Dark Forest and training sessions for the Great Battle could have shown him how to use certain power, such as a very old warrior in the Dark Forest teaching him how to take the place of a living cat. I honestly feel like the imposter is someone we have seen before, and while Ashfur is a good guess (and I honestly won't be shocked if it is him in the end), Thistleclaw is the only controversial cat I can think of. At least, he's the only one I think Kate would consider controversial. What if it is both? What I mean is that what if both of them are possessing Bramblestar at the same time?
|
|
|
Post by *Ottersplash* on Mar 23, 2020 20:48:47 GMT -5
I think Thistleclaw could be the imposter. My reasons for this are: 1. Kate stated that it was a 'controversial' character; Thistleclaw was considered controversial in Spottedleaf's Heart, when he flirted with her and asked her to be his mate while she was still an apprentice. 2. Thistleclaw was known for his slightly more 'radical' views on Clan life; i.e. his fanatical hatred of rulebreakers and his wanting to go to war over a slight step over a border. 3. His time in the Dark Forest and training sessions for the Great Battle could have shown him how to use certain power, such as a very old warrior in the Dark Forest teaching him how to take the place of a living cat. I honestly feel like the imposter is someone we have seen before, and while Ashfur is a good guess (and I honestly won't be shocked if it is him in the end), Thistleclaw is the only controversial cat I can think of. At least, he's the only one I think Kate would consider controversial. What if it is both? What I mean is that what if both of them are possessing Bramblestar at the same time? While Ashfur might be willing to do this, Thistleclaw is headstrong and would never share a body.
|
|
|
Post by Stonetoe on Mar 23, 2020 21:01:42 GMT -5
Probably Yellowfang.
|
|
|
Post by valleylight on Mar 24, 2020 3:29:13 GMT -5
Sol and Tigerstar make a lot of sense. Tigerstar especially, despite the fact that he’s very dead, given his similar theatrics with punishing code-breakers (and by that I mean imprisoning and murdering half-clan cats). His being very dead is hard to get around though. Maybe one of his nine lives escaped as a ghost when Scourge fricasseed him, and Tigerstar Voldemorted into his Horcrux life after Firestar killed him?
This is not at all likely, since this cat is about as controversial as a slice of whole grain bread, but I thought it would be interesting if Shrewpaw was the imposter. He’s the only dead cat besides Ashfur who showed some interest in Squirrelpaw (unless Stormfur died off screen recently). I thought about it being Shrewpaw after seeing Moonkitti suggest that there might be a faction of code-abiding background characters in StarClan who are upset that StarClan seems to be run by the forbidden love crew. I mean, Shrewpaw didn’t do a thing wrong that we know of, but maybe he’s like Needletail once was— a normal, seemingly inconsequential apprentice who wants to shake up the status quo and leads a revolution.
Edit: Whelp
|
|
|
Post by Swampamus on Mar 24, 2020 3:44:42 GMT -5
My bets are on Onestar.
|
|