|
Post by Fireleap on Feb 27, 2020 19:55:47 GMT -5
(I haven't read most of these books in years) TPB- Worst is Fire and Ice, best is Forest of Secrets TNP- Worst is Midnight, best is Dawn Po3- Worst is Outcast, best is Long Shadows OotS- Worst is The Fourth Apprentice, best is The Last Hope DotC- Worst is Thunder Rising, best is Path of Stars AVoS- Worst is Darkest Night, best is Thunder and Shadow (Haven't read The Raging Storm) TBC- Haven't read either
Edit: SE- Worst is Bramblestar's Storm, best is Crookedstar's Promise (Haven't read Tigerheart's Shadow, Crowfeather's Trial, or Squirrelflight's Hope) Novella- Worst is Spottedleaf's Heart, best is Goosefeather's Curse
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 27, 2020 19:58:22 GMT -5
Here we go! Best/worst.
OG: Forest of Secrets/Rising Storm TNP: Dawn/Twilight or Sunset POT: Eclipse/Outcast OOTS: The Forgotten Warrior/The Fourth Apprentice DOTC: The First Battle/Thunder Rising AVOS: Shattered Sky/River of Fire
Not included: TBC, since it just started.
Super Editions: Hawkwing's Journey/Bluestar's Prophecy /Yellowfang's Secret Novellas: Goosefeather's Curse/Spottedleaf's Heart
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 27, 2020 20:07:00 GMT -5
I don't really remember what events happened in which books...so I might not be listing any titles, but here we go..
TPB: Best - I guess the first one, Worst - the one where Swiftpaw dies, and Brightpawheart gets a terrible name.
TNP: Best - The one where everyone is moving to the new territories, and all the clans are acting like friends, and Brackenfur saves Marshkit, Worst - The one where Onestar starts acting like a jerk.
POT: Best - I guess Dark River, I found Heathertail and Lionblaze's friendship cool, and it was fun to see some light hearted aspects, like them role-playing as their own clan XD.. Worst - After Hollyleaf got her warrior name.
OOTS: Best - The one where they went on the beaver trip, Worst - The Last Hope, everyone died.
DOTC: Best - The one where Red Claw came into the series, Worst - The one where Clear Sky started a huge war, and Rainswept Flower died.
AVOS: Best - I guess the first book, Worst - The one where Crowfrost dies.
|
|
|
Post by platinum blond death on Feb 27, 2020 20:27:06 GMT -5
TPB Worst: Fire and Ice, I found that one to be boring. Best: Into the Wild or A Dangerous Path. Both are pretty interesting, both sucked me into the series.
NP Worst: They all suck, tbh. Best: If I had to pick a best book it would be either Dawn or Sunset.
POT Worst: None of them sucked hardcore but it was boring to me. Best: Either Eclipse or Long Shadows. I found those to be the most interesting.
OOTS Worst: I've repressed these books from my mind. Best: None, they all kinda suck.
DOTC Worst: Probably The Blazing Star. Best: The First Battle. Battles are always fun to read about, idk why.
AVOS Worst: Darkest Night or River of Fire. The Raging Storm was mildy interesting but still not very good. Best: Shattered Sky . . . up until they killed Darktail.
SEs Worst: Yellowfang's Secret. God, I cannot stand anyone in that book except for Nutwhisker, Rowanberry, Nightpelt, Cloudpelt, and Runningnose. Best: Hawkwing's Journey. I loved reading about SkyClan, and following Hawkwing on his journey, both physical and metaphorical.
Novellas Worst: ...I think y'all know. Best: Thunderstar's Echo or Ravenpaw's Farewell. Both were bittersweet, both included beloved characters of mine.
|
|
|
|
Post by Brindlefern on Feb 27, 2020 20:54:58 GMT -5
Best is on left, Worst is on right.
TPB- Darkest Hour or Forest of Secrets/Fire and Ice TNP- Dawn/Moonlight or Twilight Po3- The Sight/Outcast OotS- Fading Echoes/Sign of the Moon DotC- The Blazing Star/Thunder Rising or Path of Stars AVoS- Shattered Sky/The Raging Storm TBC- Haven't read
|
|
|
Post by Hollyfall on Feb 27, 2020 20:58:17 GMT -5
TPB Best: Into the Wild or Forest of Secrets Worst: Fire and Ice
TNP Best: Sunset Worst: Starlight
POT Best: Eclipse Worst: Outcast
OOTS Best: Night Whispers or The Last Hope Worst: Sign of the Moon
DOTC Best: The First Battle Worst: Thunder Rising
AVOS Best: Shattered Sky Worst: The Apprentice's Quest
Super Editions Best: Tigerheart's Shadow or Hawkwing's Journey Worst: Squirrelflight's Hope
Novellas Best: Shadowstar's Life Worst: Redtail's Debt or Spottedleaf's Heart
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 27, 2020 21:05:19 GMT -5
It seems like everyone is adding Super Editions/Novellas, so here's mine
Super Editions
Best: Yellowfang's Secret Worst: I guess Hawkwing's Journey? It was cool seeing Sandynose, but I hated how everyone died.
Novellas:
Best: Tigerclaw's Fury Worst: Thunderstar's Echo I guess, the only thing I remember, was Lightning Tail died, and Violet Dawn had some kits.
|
|
|
Post by Uмвяᴀ on Feb 27, 2020 23:44:14 GMT -5
TPB best: Into the Wild/Forest of Secrets TPB worst: Fire and Ice
TNP best: Midnight TNP worst: Sunset
POT best: Long Shadows POT worst: Outcast
OOTS best: Night Whispers OOTS worst: Sign of the Moon
DOTC best: The First Battle DOTC worst: Path of Stars
AVOS best: Shattered Sky AVOS worst: River of Fire
SE best: Tallstar's Revenge/Crookedstar's Promise/Hawkwing's Journey SE worst: Yellowfang's Secret
Novella best: Tawnypelt's Clan Novella worst: Spottedleaf's Heart
Manga Best/worst: idk. None of them stand out to me and I haven't read them in forever.
Field Guide best: Code of the Clans Field Guide worst: The Ultimate Guide
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 28, 2020 9:31:14 GMT -5
TPB Best: A Dangerous Path Worst: Into the Wild
TNP Best: Sunset Worst: Dawn
POT Best: Eclipse Worst: Outcast
OOTS They're all bad tbh, I can't decide.
DOTC Best: The First Battle Worst: The Blazing Star
Haven't read AVOS or TBC.
|
|
|
Post by Card against Humanity on Feb 28, 2020 15:31:15 GMT -5
og: worst is fire and ice bc its boring and focuses too mush on silvergrey, best is a dangerous path
tnp: worst is probably twilight, between the crowleaf annoyingness and onestar's legendary transformation into a moron. best is probably dawn bc theres the least amount of romance drama and the clans are actually working together
po3: worst is the one where they visit the tribe. i didnt really like any of them but eclipse had Sol so it was the most enjoyable
oots: they're all bad but the last hope is especially bad. ig the best is the forgotton warrior bc hollyleaf came back
dotc: worst is thunder rising bc it's boring. best are the first battle and the blazing star
avos: worst are all three of the last books, best are all thre of the first books
super editions: worst is yellowfang's secret lol. best is crookedstar's promise
|
|
|
Post by Skypaw13 on Feb 29, 2020 5:20:26 GMT -5
Not doing DotC and TBC because I haven't read them all, not doing AVoS because I can't distinguish the books in my memory.
Order is TPB, TNP, Po3, OotS, SE, Novella
Favorites: Forest of Secrets, Moonrise, Dark River, The Fourth Apprentice, Crookedstar's Promise, Leafpool's Wish.
Least Favorites: Fire and Ice, Starlight, Eclipse, Fading Echoes, Bluestar's Prophecy, Dovewing's Silence.
Best: Into the Wild, Dawn, The Sight, The Fourth Apprentice, Crookedstar's Promise, Goosefeather's Curse.
Worst: Fire and Ice, Sunset, Eclipse, Night Whispers, Bluestar's Prophecy, Spottedleaf's Heart.
|
|