This is fun
Let's see
Characters: Birchfall, Icecloud, Toadstep, Whitewing, and Shrewclaw
Manga: SkyClan and the Stranger
Novella: Tigerclaw's Fury
SE: Tallstar's Revenge
Birchfall- I like him well enough. Training in the Dark Forest was not his best moment, but he seemed like a pretty good dad (keeping in mind I haven't read OotS in years) and overall a good guy. It was really sad when Dustpelt lashed out at him after Ferncloud died.
Icecloud- She's a good and sweet background character! She and Foxleap do not get enough love, they're my favorite FernDust littter.
Toadstep- I love him! He was really cute as a kit, and he's shown to be an adept warrior. His interactions with Jayfeather and Lionblaze are great, even if he doesn't interact with them often.
Whitewing- She is so underrated. She's a great mom, and her protectiveness over her cousins is one of my favorite parts of Firestar's Quest.
Shrewclaw- I hate him. He was such a bully and he never really grew out of it. When Tallstar was leaving WindClan his only excuse was "I was only teasing" even though it was clear Tallstar hated it.
SkyClan and the Stranger- Really good! I always love seeing more of SkyClan's background cats and my best boy Shrewtooth got some attention which is always a plus. Leafstar's a good POV character too.
Tigerclaw's Fury- Mediocre. There were a bunch of really noticeable mistakes too which dragged it down for me. I did like the scene where Tigerstar saw Firestar save Bramblestar during the forest fire.
Tallstar's Revenge- It's my second favorite super edition. Tallstar is a really entertaining POV character and most of the background cats were super likeable too! Dawnstripe, Doespring, Barkface, Brackenwing, the loner group, Ryestalk, Stagleap, Cloudrunner, Deadfoot, I could go on for days. Plus! Jake and Tallstar! They're one of my favorite ships.