|
Post by Deleted on Feb 10, 2020 15:25:16 GMT -5
So why not?
Give me random characters, arcs, novellas, and SEs, and I'll tell you my opinions on them.
I'm not going to do any main series separate books, because I don't remember what happened in which book...because in The Prophecy Begins, my favorite book is the book where they find WindClan, and my least favorite book, is the book where Silverstream x Graystripe happen, and I'm pretty sure those things happen in the same book lol.
Anyway, without further ado...
|
|
ashheart19
Formerly known as totaldramaforever on the old forums!
|
Post by ashheart19 on Feb 10, 2020 16:28:49 GMT -5
Characters: Dovewing, Ivypool, Hawkfrost, Firestar, Gray Wing Arc: DoTC SE: Crookedstar's Promise
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 10, 2020 16:37:09 GMT -5
Characters: Dovewing, Ivypool, Hawkfrost, Firestar, Gray Wing Arc: DoTC SE: Crookedstar's Promise Dovewing - I really like her, I thought she was a very sweet cat, and I feel bad for her with everything she had to go through. Having these powers, and feeling like an outsider, not to mention, getting unfairly hated by her sister because of something she couldn't control, having the stress of being a part of a prophecy since the day she was born, and then losing her powers, a part of her that she had since birth. Ivypool - I really like her too, it can't be easy being outshone by your littermate at every turn. I can understand why she would feel bitter and jealous towards Dovewing, especially when other cats like Blossomfall, would constantly praise Dovewing, while putting Ivypool down. Hawkfrost - a boring clone of his father really, he was cute in the Sasha manga though, but what kit isn't adorable? Firestar - An amazing cat, who always tried to do the right thing. I was really upset to see him go. The only questionable thing about him, is the fact that he gave Bramblestar, the same exact suffix as his father, who he (Brambleclaw) spent his whole life trying to prove that's who he wasn't like. Gray Wing - A really sweet and nice cat, who took care of Turtletail's kits, and Clear Sky's kits, even though he didn't have to. Even though he did have his annoying moments (who doesn't?) he is still one of my favorite characters from Dawn of the Clans Dawn of The Clans - this was amazing, it added a fresh concept, with a cast of super likeable characters, like Shattered Ice, Red Claw, and more... I really hope they end up doing more books from this era Crookestar's Promise - It was a pretty good SE, I really liked the characters, everyone except Rainflower was super nice. Beetlenose was a brat for a little while, but he grew out of that after he became a warrior. I didn't like the whole Mapleshade thing, but it makes way more sense for her to be there, than her being in Tigerclaw's Fury does. Crookestar's Promise isn't my favorite SE, but it def isn't my least favorite.
|
|
|
Post by aether on Feb 10, 2020 16:56:18 GMT -5
Crowfeather Berrynose Mistyfoot Mothwing
The Power Of Three
|
|
|
Post by Fireleap on Feb 10, 2020 17:00:44 GMT -5
AVoS Hawkwing's Journey Breezepelt Blossomfall
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 10, 2020 17:04:22 GMT -5
aetherCrowfeather - One of my least favorite characters in the entire series, he's an entitled brat. I also don't buy that he's only the way he is, because of Feathertail. He was a brat before he even met her. Berrynose - (not counting the most recent spoiler thread) I think he's a very hard working and loyal warrior, who can sometimes be a bit extreme when it comes to following the code. Though, he's not as extreme as Hollyleaf. Other than that, I think he's one of the best dads in the series. Mistyfoot - I love her, she's very level-headed and kind, I really like how she is always grateful of the help that ThunderClan gives her, rather than snubbing them like ShadowClan and WindClan does. I also found her and Silverstream's friendship to be really nice Mothwing - As a medicine cat, I find her to be a bit incompetent, but as a cat, I find her to be really likeable. She and Bramblestar are tied for being my favorite kit of Tigerclaw The Power of Three - my least favorite arc, 2/3s of the POV characters were super unlikeable. Though, I did enjoy when Hollyleaf, Hazeltail, Brackenfur, Birchfall, and some other cats went to go find Sol. I loved the scene between Hazeltail and her father, Smoky.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 10, 2020 17:08:31 GMT -5
AVoS Hawkwing's Journey Breezepelt Blossomfall AVOS - I liked this arc, I loved seeing more of ShadowClan, even if it was them at a bad time. My favorite part though, was when Onestar died. However, I kind of wish he could have lived longer, to face the consequences of his actions, and also, to see him as a nice cat again. Hawkwing's Journey - It was a fine book, but not one that I'd read again. It was super sad, everyone died. But Sandynose was in it, so that raises the rating a lot Breezepelt - I kind of pity him, but I also can't stand him, I like that he was trying to be a better cat in Crowfeather's Trial, and he is surprisingly part of the pro-code breaker group, so I guess he is getting better. I do wish that he would be held accountable for Poppyfrost, Jayfeather, Molewhisker, and Cherryfall though Blossomfall - I don't like her at all, I think she's a brat
|
|
ashheart19
Formerly known as totaldramaforever on the old forums!
|
Post by ashheart19 on Feb 10, 2020 19:28:20 GMT -5
I'm gonna do more if that's okay!
Mapleshade, Leafpool, Sasha, Cloudtail, Needletail, Jagged Peak
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 10, 2020 19:37:55 GMT -5
I'm gonna do more if that's okay! Mapleshade, Leafpool, Sasha, Cloudtail, Needletail, Jagged Peak That's perfectly fine The more the merrier! Mapleshade - I honestly can't stand her. I do sympathize with her losing her kits though Leafpool - She was alright as an apprentice, but I didn't really like her as a medicine cat. I hated how rude she was to Jayfeather, when he found out about the Cinderpelt/Cinderheart thing, and she seemed to care more about Cinderpelt/Cinderheart, than she did Jayfeather. I know she was just trying to protect Cinderpelt/Cinderheart, but still. I did really like her in Squirrelflight's Hope though Sasha - I don't care about her honestly, I don't really have an opinion Cloudtail - One of my favorites..at first, I close to hated him, I was soo happy when the twolegs took him away, because I thought I would never have to read about him again. However, I'm glad he came back, because after the Brightheart incident, he proved himself to be a very kind, and caring cat, who isn't afraid to stand up for what's right, and he's grew into an amazing and helpful warrior, and a fantastic mentor as well. Needletail - I actually liked her before she met The Kin, I found her to be hilarious, like how she was imitating the goats and stuff, after meeting The Kin though...she went downhill Jagged Peak - I thought he was a brat at first, but I guess that's just the normal behavior of a kit/young cat lol. I did really like him in the middle of the series though, I loved how caring he was towards the kits, and how he wanted to do everything he could to help out. I didn't really like his attitude after he met Holly though. Like, I'm really happy he got his confidence back, but he seemed to be kind of a jerk at times
|
|
Bisexual
#ffc5c5
Official Queen of Fan Clans
Name Colour
ʀᴀɪɴʟᴇᴀғ 🍁
Official ThunderClan & ElmClan Leader
Easing back in
|
Post by ʀᴀɪɴʟᴇᴀғ 🍁 on Feb 10, 2020 19:58:48 GMT -5
Squirrelflight, Willowshine, Leafstar, Plumwillow, Leopardstar
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 10, 2020 20:05:19 GMT -5
Squirrelflight, Willowshine, Leafstar, Plumwillow, Leopardstar Squirrelflight - I really couldn't stand her as an apprentice, she was alright as a warrior though, I'm pretty neutral on her to be honest Willowshine - I thought she was cute when she was a kit helping Mothwing out...I don't really care for her though, I thought she was kind of snobby about getting her medicine cat name before Jayfeather, even though she was about to be apprenticed, before he was even born, so that's not really an achievement XD Leafstar - I'll probably have more of an opinion of her after I read SkyClan's Destiny, but so far, she seems like a great leader, who is holding her clan together, even after everything they've been through. I really have to respect her for that Plumwillow - she's alright, I really liked her in Hawkwing's Journey, other than that, she seems to be a little rude at times, but I don't dislike her or anything. Leopardstar - I honestly can't stand her, I never liked her, though, I do appreciate that she realized her mistakes, and she learned from them, and she was alright in Mistystar's Omen.
|
|
|
Post by Ivyfalcon on Feb 10, 2020 20:32:10 GMT -5
Hawkwing, Tawnypelt, Goldenflower
The Prophecies Begin arc
Bluestar’s Prophecy, Leafpool's Wish
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 10, 2020 20:42:16 GMT -5
Hawkwing, Tawnypelt, Goldenflower The Prophecies Begin arc Bluestar’s Prophecy, Leafpool's Wish Hawkwing - he seems like a very nice and caring cat, I love how he helped Plumwillow raise her kits, that was really sweet of him. I also think he'll be a great leader for SkyClan one day. Tawnypelt - I'm a bit iffy on her tbh, I do wish she had a more prominent role in The New Prophecy. I didn't really like how she compared Tigerheart to Tigerclaw in her novella. I know he insulted Rowanstar, but if I remember correctly, the argument started, because she was wanting to take his sick kit on a long journey, in leaf-bare, after he had just gotten back from a long journey. Yes, it turned out to be the right thing to do, but from Tigerheart's perspective, I can really understand where he's coming from. Anyway, I think Tawnypelt is a bit overrated, and she's my third favorite Tigerclaw kit. Goldenflower - She's a sweetheart, I love how she showed concern for Ravenpaw, when he came into the camp and fainted. Even though she's a sweetheart, she's tough too, I like how miffed she got at Firestar, for the way he was acting around Bramblekit. She was also a really great apprentice, I loved that scene, where her ear got nicked or something, and she thought it was cool (Am I remembering this right?) She's probably my favorite of the first series queens The Prophecies Begin - I really liked this arc, the plot-line was pretty simple, while still being interesting, most of the characters were likeable. My only problem with this arc is, the lack of close family bonds that you see in the later books. Bluestar's Prophecy - I didn't really like this one. Bluestar's POV annoyed me to be honest. Goosefeather was adorable though, I'm really surprised at how chatty and friendly he was in the first part of the book, when Bluestar and Snowfur were kits. Leafpool's Wish - It was kind of boring, but I did like seeing Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather as sweet, carefree kits, and not angsty cats weighed down by the prophecy on their shoulders
|
|
|
Post by Uмвяᴀ on Feb 10, 2020 20:44:08 GMT -5
Clear Sky?
|
|
|
Post by platinum blond death on Feb 10, 2020 20:47:23 GMT -5
Characters: Onestar, Firestar, Graystripe, Oakstar, Appledusk, Shadowstar, Turtle Tail Books: The Last Hope, Crowfeather's Trial, Yellowfang's Secret
sorry if there are any repeats
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 10, 2020 20:49:02 GMT -5
Clear Sky - On one hand, I find him super interesting, and can understand why he acted the way he did. On the other, he went way too far, and there is no excuse for the things he did. I'll break it down a little bit more though. First book - he was my favorite out of the three brothers, I thought he was caring, brave, and I loved how when Gray Wing blamed himself for Bright Stream's death, Clear Sky was like, "I never blamed you." Or something like that, I found that to be pretty sweet. However, at the end of the book, I didn't like how angry he got at Gray Wing, and practically disowned him, because Gray Wing accidentally killed Fox, while defending himself. Though, from Clear Sky's perspective, things probably looked differently. I also hated how he threw Jagged Peak out of the forest, just because he deemed him useless. That brings me to my next point...him throwing cats out because they can't hunt or fight? That's very cruel. I can kind of understand why he did it though, he was SUPER haunted by the death of his sister, he had to watch her, along with a lot of other cats, just starve to death and die. It makes sense why he'd only want the best of the best, he's terrified of losing more cats close to him. To keep a long post short, I think he's a huge jerk, who made terrible mistakes, but I'm really glad he grew as a character, and learned from those mistakes.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 10, 2020 21:00:50 GMT -5
Characters: Onestar, Firestar, Graystripe, Oakstar, Appledusk, Shadowstar, Turtle Tail Books: The Last Hope, Crowfeather's Trial, Yellowfang's Secret sorry if there are any repeats Oh, this is going to be fun Onestar - Absolutely hate this piece of rat crap. He is so lame! Not only did he take Tallstar's hopes, and throw them into the dirt pile, but he also threw his and Firestar's friendship, his forbidden mate, and their kit along with it. I could rant for hours about this guy. I absolutely 100% hate him, he's my least favorite character in the series. Firestar - I think I did him earlier Graystripe - I really like him, other than Fire and Ice, he's always been a very supportive friend to Firestar, and I love how he kept putting Onestar in his place in Power of Three/Omen of the Stars, I don't really remember what arc it was. Oakstar - he was a jerk, who should have never exiled kits, but I can't help but to feel a little bad for him. Not only did he lose his son, but he also lost his daughter not too long after that. Appledusk - other than him cheating, I don't have a problem with him, I love his name, and I thought his death was really heroic. Shadowstar - She is probably my favorite founding leader, she is so calm, kind, respectful, and I love how much she cared about her brother, and she's just a 10/10 for me. Turtle Tail - I adore Turtle Tail, she's probably my favorite out of Gray Wing's mates, though, Slate is really cool too. It's super sad how she was killed off. The Last Hope - I hated how everyone died, including Tornear Crowfeather's Trial- I actually liked this book, which shocked me, because I wasn't expecting to, since I can't stand Crowfeather. However, after looking past his entitlement, and him insulting everyone, his POV actually wasn't that bad. I also loved how Weaselfur got a pretty big part in the book, as well as some other background WindClan cats. I thought it was awesome how Breezepelt saved Lionblaze, and I was really glad, that Jayfeather didn't forgive Crowfeather, because that's a realistic ending, and those are my favorite kinds of endings Yellowfang's Secret - This is probably my favorite SE. I loved all the characters in this book, except for lame Lizardtail and Brokentail, Raggedstar was also SUPER annoying. Other than those cats though, everyone was pretty likeable. I loved that it took place in the old forest of ShadowClan. I also found the rat raids super interesting, and it gave more insight on why ShadowClan chased WindClan out. They weren't doing it to be jerks, or because they could, Brokenstar manipulated them into believing, that WindClan had killed their leader. I also liked seeing different sides of certain characters, like Cedarheart and Stonetooth. Also, like Crowfeather's Trial, I wasn't expecting to like this book, since I didn't really care for Yellowfang, but I actually really liked her in this book, and I can understand why she was the way she was. My only complaint, is the lack of respect for medicine cats, especially from Raggedstar.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 11, 2020 15:00:48 GMT -5
I decided that I'll share my opinion on ships as well, canon ones, like Sorreltail x Brackenfur, and non-canon ones like Heavystep x Beetlewhisker or something
|
|
|
Post by platinum blond death on Feb 11, 2020 17:31:50 GMT -5
I decided that I'll share my opinion on ships as well, canon ones, like Sorreltail x Brackenfur, and non-canon ones like Heavystep x Beetlewhisker or something your opinion on heavystep x beetlewhisker? 👀
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 11, 2020 17:38:23 GMT -5
I decided that I'll share my opinion on ships as well, canon ones, like Sorreltail x Brackenfur, and non-canon ones like Heavystep x Beetlewhisker or something your opinion on heavystep x beetlewhisker? 👀 I think they'd be really great together, neither of them would have to live without the other, because they never die. They're also both in RiverClan, so their relationship wouldn't be against the code. The only problem is, they're from different arcs, and have never had a scene... Wait...they're from RiverClan, RiverClan never gets attention, so they probably have had hundreds of scenes together, heck, they could be mates right now, and we'll never know it
|
|