|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 9, 2020 23:44:50 GMT -5
Toss something at me. A book, character, arc, whatever, I'll give you my opinion on it.
Edit: I'm not here to debate, just to have a little fun. Also, please don't take any offense to these opinions, these are just my own. You don't have to agree.
|
|
Genderfluid
Cloud
resident Tribe of Rushing Water enthusiast
|
Post by Cloud on Feb 9, 2020 23:47:43 GMT -5
Books: The Raging Storm, Hawkwing's Journey, and Into the Wild Character: Dovewing, Tree, Firestar, Onestar, Brackenfur, and Half Moon Arc: The New Prophecy and Dawn of the Clans
(yes, some of these are on purpose)
|
|
|
Post by Hollyfall on Feb 9, 2020 23:50:59 GMT -5
Characters: Reedwhisker, Twigbranch, Dovewing, Tigerstar II, Mapleshade, and Shrewtooth Books: The Silent Thaw, Crowfeather's Trial, The Last Hope, Moonrise, and Squirrelflight's Hope Arcs: DOTC, AVOS, TBC
|
|
|
Post by Ivyfalcon on Feb 9, 2020 23:56:04 GMT -5
Characters: Squirrelflight, Hollyleaf, Hawkwing, Ivypool
Arc: Power of Three
Books: Leafpool’s Wish, Bluestar’s Prophecy
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 10, 2020 0:01:43 GMT -5
Books: The Raging Storm, Hawkwing's Journey, and Into the WildCharacter: Dovewing, Tree, Firestar, Onestar, Brackenfur, and Half Moon Arc: The New Prophecy and Dawn of the Clans(yes, some of these are on purpose) Books: The Raging Storm- Anti climactic as hell, worst sixth book out there, with the exception of Sunset.
Hawkwing's Journey- I freaking love this book. It was so fresh, the plot was great, the background characters were great. It's my favorite traveling book (close second is The Sun Trail). It was so great having the book be about someone we knew pretty much nothing about, and now Hawkwing's one of my favorite characters. Into the Wild- I really love this book, despite its flaws. It's where it all began, if I ever hated that I wouldn't have continued the series otherwise. Firepaw/heart is a great protagonist. I love Graypaw/stripe. Characters: Dovewing- I can't stand her, I hate her POV and probably always will. I think she's slightly more tolerable in The Broken Code, still wouldn't mind her dying regardless. Tree- I love him, I think he's really interesting despite the amount of endless hate he seems to get. I'm really excited for his novella, and to know more about him. His POV should be interesting. Firestar- I love him! He's one of my favorite cats. I loved him a lot more in his POV, though. I thought he got kind of uninteresting as leader, barring several subplots he had in books such as Midnight, Dark River, and The Forgotten Warrior. Kind of hard to hate the character that started it all. Onestar- This guy is literal trash. One of my least favorite characters of all time. I cheered when I found out he was a dead man (cat). Brackenfur- I think he's okay, a little boring, but okay. I preferred him when he was a younger cat, though. Half Moon- Despite me harping on about wanting her to get a Super Edition, I think she's just okay. I only want her to get an SE cause it's the perfect one for the Ancient Tribe/old cats by the lake. I don't think much of her as a character, though. Arcs: The New Prophecy: You know, it wouldn't be so low on my list if it didn't have such a trashy last half. The first half was pretty alright. The last half was terrible. Dawn of the Clans: Here we go. This arc is literally the best one out there, I don't care what anyone says. The characters are so dang good, and having a new cast after four arcs of the same was really refreshing. They're really complex and all have personalities, even the bg ones. StarClan being absent for most of it really made it great too, their meddling in the later arcs was starting to get tiresome. The buildup to The First Battle and then the event itself was really magnificent. The last half wasn't even too terrible either, which is a plus. I love this arc and could go on about it for days.
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 10, 2020 0:13:24 GMT -5
Characters: Reedwhisker, Twigbranch, Dovewing, Tigerstar II, Mapleshade, and Shrewtooth Books: The Silent Thaw, Crowfeather's Trial, The Last Hope, Moonrise, and Squirrelflight's Hope Arcs: DOTC, AVOS, TBC Characters: Reedwhisker- Cardboard. Couldn't care less about him, although I do hope he has kits to carry on Bluestar's bloodline. I really don't want him to get a Super Edition, nor do I want him as RiverClan's next leader. Twigbranch- I utterly despise her. One of my least favorite characters. I couldn't stand her constant whining in every chapter, and most of her storylines were terrible. Dovewing- See Twigbranch. Tigerstar II- I've loved this guy since he first appeared in Power of Three. He was a little bad and OOC in The Raging Storm, but he got his act together again in The Broken Code. Love him, probably always will. Mapleshade- Ugh. She was great, in just Crookedstar's Promise. After that she was way overused. Mapleshade this, Mapleshade that. I don't care much for her anymore because of that. I did genuinely enjoy her novella, though. The dark tone was awesome. It was also refreshing not seeing ThunderClan be PerfectClan for once. Shrewtooth- I love this guy, and his character development. It's a shame he vanished off the face of the earth. Books: The Silent Thaw- Oh, lordy. Where to start with this one. Literally all the main characters are fantastic. The plot is so dark, chilling, and suspenseful. The cliffhanger is truly something else. My favorite book in the series now. Crowfeather's Trial- I really liked Crowfeather's POV, but thought this was mostly garbage. I hated how it was basically a Breezepelt redemption book, when he's way too far gone for that. Nightcloud was great, though. The Last Hope- Meh. It's not trash, but...it's not good, either. I think I would like it more if it wasn't the finale to two arcs combined. It was very anti-climactic. Firestar's death should have been from his POV. Moonrise- Boring. Squirrelflight's Hope- This book is utter trash. Too many OOC characters, plot's a mess...just ugh. Why did this need to happen again?
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 10, 2020 0:20:24 GMT -5
Characters: Squirrelflight, Hollyleaf, Hawkwing, Ivypool Arc: Power of Three Books: Leafpool’s Wish, Bluestar’s Prophecy Characters: Squirrelflight- She's pretty good, not one of my all time favorites though. I love the amount of development she's gotten, how she went from a nuisance to a really respected Clan deputy. Hollyleaf- Easily one of my all time favorite characters. She's really complex, and her story arc from the third arc to fourth was extremely well done. I only wish she hadn't died a book after returning. Hawkwing- Again, easily one of my favorite characters. His Super Edition was so great, I love his personality. I hope we see him as leader soon. Ivypool- Another one of my favorites. She was my favorite part of the fourth arc, hands down. (Besides Jayfeather, of course.) Arc: Power of Three- Despite its flaws, this arc was really enjoyable to me. I loved Jayfeather and Hollyleaf, and Lionblaze was okay. The story was great, and the build up to the cliffhanger in book five was awesome, with that scene on the clifftop. The sixth book was handled pretty well, except for the Sol patrol. It's not my favorite arc, but it introduce my favorite cat. Books: Leafpool's Wish- This was trash. I hated it. Bluestar's Prophecy- My all time favorite of the Super Editions thus far. I've always loved Bluestar (one of my favorite cats) and her story was really well done to me. It does a good job at explaining how she is the way she is when she's nearing the end of her life. Her backstory was written perfectly.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 10, 2020 9:08:26 GMT -5
Characters: Sandynose, Tornear, Star Flower, Ravenwing, Hawkheart
Books: Goosefeather's Curse, Redtail's Debt
|
|
#a3c5e6
Name Colour
𝓣𝓲𝓷𝓾𝓿𝓲𝓮𝓵
Warrior Fanatic
All hail me, the flower-flushing queen of Prague
|
Post by 𝓣𝓲𝓷𝓾𝓿𝓲𝓮𝓵 on Feb 10, 2020 9:36:22 GMT -5
Characters: Skystar, Bluestar, Sandstorm, Firestar, Leafstar, Needletail, Violetshine, Bristlefrost
Books: Bluestar's Prophecy and the SkyClan Saga overall (so from FQ to HJ)
|
|
Heterosexual
Spinestar
Got The Ashfur Tattoo!
|
Post by Spinestar on Feb 10, 2020 13:02:28 GMT -5
Characters: Thornclaw, Cloudtail, Harestar, Mistystar, Shadowstar, Riverstar, Mousewhisker Books: Moonrise, Long Shadows, Darkest Night, Path of Stars, Redtail's Debt, Shadowstar's Life, Moth Flight's Vision
|
|
#add8e6
Name Colour
*Ravenpaw*
Warrior Fanatic
*reads books in a corner*
|
Post by *Ravenpaw* on Feb 10, 2020 14:03:31 GMT -5
Characters: Shadowstar and Windstar Books: Firestar's Quest
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 10, 2020 15:32:29 GMT -5
Characters: Sandynose, Tornear, Star Flower, Ravenwing, Hawkheart Books: Goosefeather's Curse, Redtail's Debt Characters: Sandynose- Meh. I liked him better when he was a younger cat. Tornear- Generic WindClan warrior. Star Flower- Could be worse? Ravenwing- Bad. Hawkheart- I'm torn. I hate him, but also like him. Books: Goosefeather's Curse- Best novella. It had such a dark tone to it, and it was so great to see Goosefeather be slowly driven mad. It should have been a Super Edition, though. Redtail's Debt- Bad. If they didn't retcon a lot of stuff and make Ravenpaw weirdly OOC, it would be better.
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 10, 2020 15:41:53 GMT -5
Characters: Thornclaw, Cloudtail, Harestar, Mistystar, Shadowstar, Riverstar, Mousewhisker Books: Moonrise, Long Shadows, Darkest Night, Path of Stars, Redtail's Debt, Shadowstar's Life, Moth Flight's Vision Characters: Thornclaw- He was better when he was younger, just want him to be killed off already. Cloudtail- He's alright. Harestar- He's pretty cool. Mistystar- I love her, especially as Mistyfoot, but please, just die already. Shadowstar- She's great. I'm mad she had such a short reign, though. Riverstar- He's awesome. This cat needs a Super Edition. Mousewhisker- He's okay. Don't care much about him anymore, though. Books: Long Shadows- Amazing. The build up to the climax and the secret mentioned in the blurb being revealed was fantastic. The cliffhanger at the end was great, too. Good suspense build up for the sixth installment. I remember I genuinely thought Squirrelflight had killed Ashfur, and was eager to see what was going to happen next. Darkest Night- Decent, could have been better. Don't remember too much of it, though. Path of Stars- It could've been better for a finale book, but it was great seeing the Clans finally be founded, and Gray Wing's death scene is the best ever written in Warriors, period. Shadowstar's Life- I enjoyed it, really irritated about the time it takes place in though. I assumed it would be far future, her reign shouldn't have been cut so short. Moth Flight's Vision- One of my favorite Super Editions by far. I loved revisiting the DOTC cast again.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 10, 2020 15:42:06 GMT -5
Characters: Sandynose, Tornear, Star Flower, Ravenwing, Hawkheart Books: Goosefeather's Curse, Redtail's Debt Characters: Sandynose- Meh. I liked him better when he was a younger cat. Tornear- Generic WindClan warrior. Star Flower- Could be worse? Ravenwing- Bad. Hawkheart- I'm torn. I hate him, but also like him. Books: Goosefeather's Curse- Best novella. It had such a dark tone to it, and it was so great to see Goosefeather be slowly driven mad. It should have been a Super Edition, though. Redtail's Debt- Bad. If they didn't retcon a lot of stuff and make Ravenpaw weirdly OOC, it would be better. I agree about what you said about the books. I completely forgot about the retconning things, and Ravenpaw's personality, because I was too focused on Stagleap and baby Mudclaw.
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 10, 2020 15:43:16 GMT -5
Characters: Shadowstar and Windstar Books: Firestar's Quest Characters: Windstar- Bleh. Okay, I guess. Books: Firestar's Quest- It's decent. Not one of my favorites, though. There was way too much traveling. The reformation of SkyClan was well done, however.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 10, 2020 16:17:25 GMT -5
Thunderstar, Lionblaze, Breezepelt, Violet Dawn, Cinderheart The First Battle
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 11, 2020 20:43:31 GMT -5
Thunderstar, Lionblaze, Breezepelt, Violet Dawn, Cinderheart The First Battle Characters: Thunderstar- He's decent. Lionblaze- He's meh. He was better in Power of Three. Breezepelt- I hate him. Worst character. Violet Dawn- Meh. Cinderheart- Meh. The First Battle- Second best book in the series. So good, the build up, the climax, the aftermath, everything. Then when you take into account that it all happened in like, three or so days makes it even better.
|
|