|
Post by Fireleap on Sept 22, 2019 17:21:01 GMT -5
Like Nightstep's thread, but over the entire series. (I'm not bothering to search for when/if they had apprentices so assume they all had one at some point before the canon deputy was appointed.)
ThunderClan: Replace Bluefur with either Adderfang or Swiftbreeze. Adderfang was already the temporary deputy for Tawnyspots, why not just keep him as a deputy? And, if Sunstar had shown a little consideration for those two, Mosskit likely wouldn't have died. ShadowClan: Replace Raggedpelt with Deerleap. Flintfang would be my top choice, but I'm pretty sure he was only a little older than Brokenstar. WindClan: Replace Mudclaw with Ashfoot or Onewhisker. Ashfoot was a capable deputy when she was made one, and if Onewhisker had been made deputy from the start maybe he wouldn't have been so antagonistic. SkyClan: I'm fine with all the main SkC deputies. Sparrow Fur, Hawkwing, and even Waspwhisker for the .5 pages he was deputy were all good choices. Slightly less enthused with Sharpclaw, but he wasn't awful. RiverClan: Replace Leopardfur with Mosspelt I guess? Can't find very many choices, but Mosspelt seems good enough. Stonefur would be a good choice too.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 22, 2019 17:28:25 GMT -5
ThunderClan - I'm not really feeling Bramblestar, since that's all he seemed to care about in TNP, was being deputy, I'm not sure who I'd replace him with though, I'm not really feeling Mousefur, Longtail, or Dustpelt either.
WindClan - Replace Mudclaw with Tornear. Tallstar wanted someone more aggressive than he was at first, but then he wanted someone who wasn't as aggressive as Mudclaw, Tornear is the perfect guy for this.
ShadowClan - Brokenstar being replaced with someone else
Everyone else is fine
|
|
|
Post by *Ottersplash* on Sept 22, 2019 20:30:13 GMT -5
Windclan: Mudclaw with Ashfoot all the way. She has consistently shown herself to be a levelheaded cat, who doesn't start fights with people for no reason.
Thunderclan: Bluefur with anyone, Brambleclaw with someone else too. I'm not sure for them. I would have loved a Longstar or Duststar but I think they were probably too old to replace Firestar. Maybe Brackenfur?
Riverclan: Leopardstar with someone else. Stonefur. Wouldn't have led to Riverclan teaming up with Tigerstar
|
|
|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Sept 23, 2019 2:38:49 GMT -5
WindClan: I would have kept with Mudclaw or go with Tornear. Ashfoot was kind of a doormat, and I'm disappointed that Deadfoot bit the dust. Nightcloud is another option imo since she's well respected in her clan.
ThunderClan: Brackenfur or Longtail, more so the latter, I think Longtail was a fully capable warrior if not for the accident. And if not him then maybe Dustpelt.
RiverClan: Beetlewhisker if he had lived, and Stonefur should have became leader over Mistystar tbh. In the event, Misty is still leader I would have wanted Stormfur as deputy.
ShadowClan: Cloverfoot currently is a fine choice, but Dawnpelt should have been deputy after Crowfrost and become leader.
|
|