|
Post by đąđđđđđđđđđđ on Nov 16, 2023 10:40:57 GMT -5
warriorcats.com/content/article/guess-that-cat-fire-and-birdLast week's cat was Honeyfern. This week's hints are: - flame symbol - bird symbol (possibly a magpie) - pale blue eyes - appeared in one arc - had a PoV - she-cat Spottedleaf is automatically out due to her having amber eyes while Bluestar and Feathertail appeared in more than one arc. So it has to be Frostpaw. Even though the flame and bird symbol fit very well with Bluestar (since the two had to do with signs/omens her uncle Goosefeather received during her Super Edition).
|
|
|
Post by ÚŠÛŲاŲ on Nov 16, 2023 13:41:06 GMT -5
It's Bluestar.
- Goosefeather told her that she was like fire. - Speaking of Goosefeather, I assume the bird refers to him. - She was alive for a single arc. - She has a POV (super edition). - Everyone in this list is a she-cat. - She has blue eyes.
It's not Spottedleaf (wrong color), Feathertail (alive for two arcs), or Frostpaw (doesn't have anything to do with fire).
|
|
|
Post by đąđđđđđđđđđđ on Nov 16, 2023 13:51:57 GMT -5
It's Bluestar. - Goosefeather told her that she was like fire. - Speaking of Goosefeather, I assume the bird refers to him. - She was alive for a single arc. - She has a POV (super edition). - Everyone in this list is a she-cat. - She has blue eyes. It's not Spottedleaf (wrong color), Feathertail (alive for two arcs), or Frostpaw (doesn't have anything to do with fire). But Bluestar appared in more than one arc. The hint states that the cat in question appared in one arc. Otherwise, I'd also say that it's her. But you're of course right that Frostpaw had nothing to do with fire, so there's that. Guess we'll see by next week.
|
|
|
Post by ÚŠÛŲاŲ on Nov 16, 2023 13:53:25 GMT -5
It's Bluestar. - Goosefeather told her that she was like fire. - Speaking of Goosefeather, I assume the bird refers to him. - She was alive for a single arc. - She has a POV (super edition). - Everyone in this list is a she-cat. - She has blue eyes. It's not Spottedleaf (wrong color), Feathertail (alive for two arcs), or Frostpaw (doesn't have anything to do with fire). But Bluestar appared in more than one arc. The hint states that the cat in question appared in one arc. Otherwise, I'd also say that it's her. And in how many of those arcs was she alive?
|
|
|
Post by đąđđđđđđđđđđ on Nov 16, 2023 13:57:37 GMT -5
But Bluestar appared in more than one arc. The hint states that the cat in question appared in one arc. Otherwise, I'd also say that it's her. And in how many of those arcs was she alive? One. I'm perfectly aware of that. But the hint did not say "was alive for one arc" and rather "appeared in one arc". Although perhaps that wording would have thus made it be too obvious. Either way, I'm pretty sure this isn't the first time that specific hint got used in one of these so I'll just check how those other previous ones turned out. Since I forgot.
|
|
|
Post by ÚŠÛŲاŲ on Nov 16, 2023 13:59:45 GMT -5
And in how many of those arcs was she alive? One. I know that. But the hint did not say "was alive for one arc" and rather "appeared in one arc". Although perhaps that wording would have thus made it be too obvious. You do you, I personally think Bluestar fits the camp of "appeared alive in one arc".
|
|
|
Post by đąđđđđđđđđđđ on Nov 16, 2023 14:08:08 GMT -5
One. I know that. But the hint did not say "was alive for one arc" and rather "appeared in one arc". Although perhaps that wording would have thus made it be too obvious. You do you, I personally think Bluestar fits the camp of "appeared alive in one arc". I'm fine with turning out to be wrong about this one, to be honest lol. It's not that deep, after all. Just a fun, little guessing game. Guess the wording just bugged me in this case. It was used before in other "Guess the cat" editions though. The 10th one for Runningwind and the 11th one for Jaggedtooth are the most recent examples. Just checked Runningwind's wiki page (Jaggedtooth really did only appear in the first arc and some additional books) and apparently he showed up in The Last Hope as a StarClan spirit which I forgot about. So I guess the hint seemingly isn't meant to be taken literal all the time if the cat in question only appears in other arcs after they died. Like with Bluestar in this case. Turns out you were right, so have a cookie :-)
|
|