Warriors 20 questions!

Q5: If you're asking if she was born one, then yes.

Q6: If we're talking about appearences specifically then yes

Q7: No

Q9: No

Q10: No

Q11: Yes

Was she mentioned in a super edition that took place before TPB?

Has she ever been a loner/rogue?

Is it Jay?

Okay, so, a she-cat kittypet who was born a kittypet, became a loner, then a kittypet. She never appeared in the main series, only in a super edition that took place around TPB, probably either Yellowfang's secret, Leopardstar's honor, or Bluestars prophecy. She may have been mentioned in the main series, and has never been in a graphic novel. SHe has also never joined a Clan, even if only temporarily, and she doesn't have brown on her pelt. The only kittypets in Bluestar's Prophecy are Jake, Scourge, and Rusty, but those are all toms so it's not BP. In YS, the only she-cat kittypets are Jay, Pixie and Red, but it can't be Jay because she was already guessed, and it can't be Red because she later becomes Russetfur. However, assuming that your cat is currently a kittypet, it couldn't be Pixie as she was last known as a loner. This only leaves LH. However, I cannot find any LH outside-of-Clan characters besides Scourge. This either means there is another Super Edition that takes place around the time of TPB that I missed, or it's Pixie. ---Now, I just looked back at it, and I realized that it must be the first one, becuase Onestar's Confession took place not only around TPB, but at the same time! In OC, we have: Bailey, Dudley, Leo/Brushpaw, Melody/Tansypaw, Nettle, Nutmeg, Rain, Raven, Roach, Silt, Smoke, and Barley. It can't be Brushpaw, Bailey or Melody, as they were alll part of a Clan at some point. It can't be Dudley, Nettle, Nutmeg, Rain, Roach, or Barley, as they are all toms. It can't be Raven or Silt, as they both appeared in AVoS. This leaves only Smoke. Smoke was not specifically a loner, but she was a not-kittypet, and everything else matches up.

Is it Smoke?

Okay, I have one!

Q1: No

Q2: Yes

Q3: Yes