Post by ᦓρ꠸ᥴꫀᠻꪖꪀᧁ on Oct 22, 2023 6:32:04 GMT -5
Inspired by Yuki’s thread
Im severely bored, give me cats to admire or roast. Also no DotC characters because I’m not done with the arc yet.
Cats done already:
Im severely bored, give me cats to admire or roast. Also no DotC characters because I’m not done with the arc yet.
Cats done already:
Needletail: 5.5/10 - I don’t think she deserves the hate she gets but overall I’m incredibly neutral on her
Tawnypelt: 8/10 - I really love her personality and think she should have gotten more love during TNP. Also her shutting down her father’s offer to train her was so badass. We should have gotten Tawnystar
Hollyleaf: 7.5/10 - I think she’s an interesting character who imo had well written character development along her path to going insane and coming back as a more calmed down cat in OotS
Tallstar: 8.5/10 - He’s the best and I really hope he found out Firestar was Jake’s son and that’s why he was such a great father figure to him. His character development in his SE is amazing too, and he’s a gay icon
Blackstar: 9/10 - This may sound weird but I love Blackstar while hating Leopardstar?? I think it’s because Blackstar owned up to his mistakes while Leopardstar didn’t. He’s such an interesting character being the deputy of both Tigerstar and Brokenstar and then being manipulated my Sol. I really love him and believe he has PTSD over Stonefur’s death
Nightstar: 7/10 - He’s a well written character and is very interesting during ITW and his GN. Actually, his GN was my favorite GN, so that’s brings him up a bit.
Sorreltail: 9/10 - I really enjoyed her character and she was a great friend for Leafpool (*silently ships LeafSorrel*). She is also one of the minor characters who has an actual personality and it shows. Another thing is that she went through A LOT of trauma (Being poisoned by her older brother as a kit, watching Cinderpelt die protecting her while giving birth, losing her littermate, giving birth to her second litter out of camp, etc.) and the authors don’t ignore that either, she is mentioned to have nightmares about death berries.
Brackenfur: 4.5/10 - I’m sorry, but the people who say he’s just a loyal piece of cardboard are so right imo lol
Spiderleg: 3/10 - I just don’t like this guy because I can’t really name anything he did other than leave Daisy and her kits. Also I don’t like it when people blame his behavior on Dustpelt because Dustpelt was NOT a neglectful dad, in fact he spent a lot of time with Ferncloud and his kits iirc. Their could be some cool backstory around it but for now there’s no reason behind it
Longtail: 10/10 - I LOVE THIS BOY!! I live his redemption from being one of Tigerstar’s biggest allies and one of Firestar’s biggest rivals into the opposite, becoming a friend of Firestar’s. He’s also such an wholesome elder, Although I do wish he hadn’t been blinded and instead made deputy.
Crookedstar: 7/10 - His SE was a fun read and he’s overall an interesting character. I wish he was the father of Bluestar’s kits instead of Oakheart, but oh well.
Sparkpelt: 6/10 - Genuinely neutral on her, I enjoyed her interactions with Nightheart in Shadow though
Dovewing: 6.5/10 - She’s a tough one. I loved her a lot when she was an apprentice, but now I’m very eh on her. I’ll go neutral.
Silverstream: 5.5/10 - Another one I’m neutral on. I don’t hate her, but I don’t love her. She’s honestly kind of a bland love interest for me? Idk, her death was sad though
Feathertail: 2/10 - For some reason I really don’t like her, she’s just not my vibe.
Squirrelflight: 7.5/10 - I like her, I like how she speaks for what she thinks is right. With that being said, she can be a bit annoying to read about though. However, she’s been through so much and is a trooper through it all <3
Lionblaze: 7/10 - Wasted potential. I’m telling you, a cat who can’t loose in battle that uses it for GOOD?? Come on Erins, you can do better than that. Although I did like him being a trainee and him completely praying that he isn’t gonna be made deputy in the Thunder preview is hilarious.
Cinderpelt: 8/10 - She’s so wholesome. I don’t think she had to be shoved in the medicine den *cough cough warrior cats ableism* but she definitely handled it well and even though she says she wanted to be a warrior, you can tell she enjoys being a medicine cat too. She truly cares about her clanmates and I love it.
Cinderheart: 6.5/10 - Her Cinderpelt soul’s in her side plot was boring and unnecessary, but otherwise she’s a decent character. She could make a good deputy, overall neutral.
Poppyfrost: 9.5/10 - She’s amazing. Amazing I tell you, and I can’t explain why she’s so amazing but she deserves better than Berrynose. I think her friendship with Jayfeather is so sweet and she’s just an amazing cat in general.
Ivypool: 10/10 - I LIVE FOR IVYPOOL SUPREMACYYYY. So happy she’s getting the
SPOILER: Click to show
She’s such an interesting cat and as Ivypool she’s a jealous little bitch and I love her for it. She’s grown so much in the books it’s amazing.
Violetshine: 5/10 - Neutral, not much to say.
Hawkfrost: 4.5/10 - The only reason he ranks so low is because he has so much wasted potential imo. He could have done so much but did so little
Onestar: 1/10 - He’s a jerk and I hate him. He had no reason to attack ThunderClan so many times, no reason to abandon Smoke and Darktail, and no reason to be so rude in general.
Mapleshade: 1/10 - I explain farther why I hate her in this thread (whoops link didn’t work on this post, look in the original post rating Mapleshade below to find it) but please don’t post on it as it’s now over a month old
Jayfeather: 10/10 - MY BOY!! He’s so grumpy and I love it. Also the fandom totally ignores the amount of trauma that was dumped on him.
Yellowfang: 9/10 - Completely ignoring StarClan Yellowfang (who I refuse to believe is the same Yellowfang as TPB Yellowfang) she is an amazing mother figure to Firestar and is so wholesome. I love her sm.
Littlecloud: 9/10 - He’s a big comfort character of mine. Extremely underrated and wholesome, the guy needs more love.
Sunstar: 5/10 - Neutral, his leadership just seems like filler to me tbh
Whitestorm: 9/10 - HE’S BI AND HE LOVES LIONHEART AND HE WILLOWPELT AND USED TO LOVE TIGERSTAR. Also he’s an amazing father figure to Firestar. And he didn’t marry Brindleface, I refuse to consider that cannon
Brambleclaw: 7/10 - He’s a good guy, I genuinely like him. Don’t understand what the deal is with the people who say he’s “abusive” towards Squilf. Toxic, maybe, but abusive? Huh? Squirrelflight drama side, I respect his decision to retire and his relationship with Nightheart is cute.
Firestar - 100/10 - MY BABY HE’S MY NUMBER ONE. I love him sm, he’s the main character in the first arc meaning he went through a lot of bs and pushes through. He’s just the best.
Tigerstar l - 9/10 - I used to say my favorite villain was Sol, but recently I reread ITW and nope, it’s this dude. His ambitions are so well thought and he probably would have succeeded if Firepaw hadn’t joined the clans.
Goldenflower - 11/10 - I LOVE HER TOO. She has so much potential and went through so much. I thing I feel like is overshadowed is the fact that Swiftpaw is her son, meaning her ex-mate was the reason her kit died. We need a Goldenflower novella if those ever come back. Or a GN if we get new standalone GN artists.
Gray Wing - 7/10 - Okay so I’m basing this off the first half of the first book because that’s all I’ve read in DotC. He’s a good boy but genuinely seems kinda boring so far? Idk I’m guessing he gets better.
Crowfeather - 6.5/10 - I have mixed feelings on this guy. On one hand I think he’s a jerk, but on the other one I feel bad for him because life treats him shitty and he doesn’t deserve it. But he’s an interesting character and he’s been deputy forever lol
Leafpool - 10/10 - Absolutely love her. Now she’s really been through a lot of shit. And yet still keeps an happy face on through out it all? How Leafpool?? Teach me your ways. Anyways she’s just so compassionate yet selfish at the same time and she’s definitely suffering from depression but pushed through. She doesn’t deserve any of the trauma she got <3
Tawnypelt: 8/10 - I really love her personality and think she should have gotten more love during TNP. Also her shutting down her father’s offer to train her was so badass. We should have gotten Tawnystar
Hollyleaf: 7.5/10 - I think she’s an interesting character who imo had well written character development along her path to going insane and coming back as a more calmed down cat in OotS
Tallstar: 8.5/10 - He’s the best and I really hope he found out Firestar was Jake’s son and that’s why he was such a great father figure to him. His character development in his SE is amazing too, and he’s a gay icon
Blackstar: 9/10 - This may sound weird but I love Blackstar while hating Leopardstar?? I think it’s because Blackstar owned up to his mistakes while Leopardstar didn’t. He’s such an interesting character being the deputy of both Tigerstar and Brokenstar and then being manipulated my Sol. I really love him and believe he has PTSD over Stonefur’s death
Nightstar: 7/10 - He’s a well written character and is very interesting during ITW and his GN. Actually, his GN was my favorite GN, so that’s brings him up a bit.
Sorreltail: 9/10 - I really enjoyed her character and she was a great friend for Leafpool (*silently ships LeafSorrel*). She is also one of the minor characters who has an actual personality and it shows. Another thing is that she went through A LOT of trauma (Being poisoned by her older brother as a kit, watching Cinderpelt die protecting her while giving birth, losing her littermate, giving birth to her second litter out of camp, etc.) and the authors don’t ignore that either, she is mentioned to have nightmares about death berries.
Brackenfur: 4.5/10 - I’m sorry, but the people who say he’s just a loyal piece of cardboard are so right imo lol
Spiderleg: 3/10 - I just don’t like this guy because I can’t really name anything he did other than leave Daisy and her kits. Also I don’t like it when people blame his behavior on Dustpelt because Dustpelt was NOT a neglectful dad, in fact he spent a lot of time with Ferncloud and his kits iirc. Their could be some cool backstory around it but for now there’s no reason behind it
Longtail: 10/10 - I LOVE THIS BOY!! I live his redemption from being one of Tigerstar’s biggest allies and one of Firestar’s biggest rivals into the opposite, becoming a friend of Firestar’s. He’s also such an wholesome elder, Although I do wish he hadn’t been blinded and instead made deputy.
Crookedstar: 7/10 - His SE was a fun read and he’s overall an interesting character. I wish he was the father of Bluestar’s kits instead of Oakheart, but oh well.
Sparkpelt: 6/10 - Genuinely neutral on her, I enjoyed her interactions with Nightheart in Shadow though
Dovewing: 6.5/10 - She’s a tough one. I loved her a lot when she was an apprentice, but now I’m very eh on her. I’ll go neutral.
Silverstream: 5.5/10 - Another one I’m neutral on. I don’t hate her, but I don’t love her. She’s honestly kind of a bland love interest for me? Idk, her death was sad though
Feathertail: 2/10 - For some reason I really don’t like her, she’s just not my vibe.
Squirrelflight: 7.5/10 - I like her, I like how she speaks for what she thinks is right. With that being said, she can be a bit annoying to read about though. However, she’s been through so much and is a trooper through it all <3
Lionblaze: 7/10 - Wasted potential. I’m telling you, a cat who can’t loose in battle that uses it for GOOD?? Come on Erins, you can do better than that. Although I did like him being a trainee and him completely praying that he isn’t gonna be made deputy in the Thunder preview is hilarious.
Cinderpelt: 8/10 - She’s so wholesome. I don’t think she had to be shoved in the medicine den *cough cough warrior cats ableism* but she definitely handled it well and even though she says she wanted to be a warrior, you can tell she enjoys being a medicine cat too. She truly cares about her clanmates and I love it.
Cinderheart: 6.5/10 - Her Cinderpelt soul’s in her side plot was boring and unnecessary, but otherwise she’s a decent character. She could make a good deputy, overall neutral.
Poppyfrost: 9.5/10 - She’s amazing. Amazing I tell you, and I can’t explain why she’s so amazing but she deserves better than Berrynose. I think her friendship with Jayfeather is so sweet and she’s just an amazing cat in general.
Ivypool: 10/10 - I LIVE FOR IVYPOOL SUPREMACYYYY. So happy she’s getting the
SPOILER: Click to show
She’s such an interesting cat and as Ivypool she’s a jealous little bitch and I love her for it. She’s grown so much in the books it’s amazing.
Violetshine: 5/10 - Neutral, not much to say.
Hawkfrost: 4.5/10 - The only reason he ranks so low is because he has so much wasted potential imo. He could have done so much but did so little
Onestar: 1/10 - He’s a jerk and I hate him. He had no reason to attack ThunderClan so many times, no reason to abandon Smoke and Darktail, and no reason to be so rude in general.
Mapleshade: 1/10 - I explain farther why I hate her in this thread (whoops link didn’t work on this post, look in the original post rating Mapleshade below to find it) but please don’t post on it as it’s now over a month old
Jayfeather: 10/10 - MY BOY!! He’s so grumpy and I love it. Also the fandom totally ignores the amount of trauma that was dumped on him.
Yellowfang: 9/10 - Completely ignoring StarClan Yellowfang (who I refuse to believe is the same Yellowfang as TPB Yellowfang) she is an amazing mother figure to Firestar and is so wholesome. I love her sm.
Littlecloud: 9/10 - He’s a big comfort character of mine. Extremely underrated and wholesome, the guy needs more love.
Sunstar: 5/10 - Neutral, his leadership just seems like filler to me tbh
Whitestorm: 9/10 - HE’S BI AND HE LOVES LIONHEART AND HE WILLOWPELT AND USED TO LOVE TIGERSTAR. Also he’s an amazing father figure to Firestar. And he didn’t marry Brindleface, I refuse to consider that cannon
Brambleclaw: 7/10 - He’s a good guy, I genuinely like him. Don’t understand what the deal is with the people who say he’s “abusive” towards Squilf. Toxic, maybe, but abusive? Huh? Squirrelflight drama side, I respect his decision to retire and his relationship with Nightheart is cute.
Firestar - 100/10 - MY BABY HE’S MY NUMBER ONE. I love him sm, he’s the main character in the first arc meaning he went through a lot of bs and pushes through. He’s just the best.
Tigerstar l - 9/10 - I used to say my favorite villain was Sol, but recently I reread ITW and nope, it’s this dude. His ambitions are so well thought and he probably would have succeeded if Firepaw hadn’t joined the clans.
Goldenflower - 11/10 - I LOVE HER TOO. She has so much potential and went through so much. I thing I feel like is overshadowed is the fact that Swiftpaw is her son, meaning her ex-mate was the reason her kit died. We need a Goldenflower novella if those ever come back. Or a GN if we get new standalone GN artists.
Gray Wing - 7/10 - Okay so I’m basing this off the first half of the first book because that’s all I’ve read in DotC. He’s a good boy but genuinely seems kinda boring so far? Idk I’m guessing he gets better.
Crowfeather - 6.5/10 - I have mixed feelings on this guy. On one hand I think he’s a jerk, but on the other one I feel bad for him because life treats him shitty and he doesn’t deserve it. But he’s an interesting character and he’s been deputy forever lol
Leafpool - 10/10 - Absolutely love her. Now she’s really been through a lot of shit. And yet still keeps an happy face on through out it all? How Leafpool?? Teach me your ways. Anyways she’s just so compassionate yet selfish at the same time and she’s definitely suffering from depression but pushed through. She doesn’t deserve any of the trauma she got <3