best arc?

The original series, closely followed by TNP.

tpb wasnt that great imo and i still think ppl only like it for nostalgia

i think asc is going great so far so i picked that
anyways dotc is DEFINITELY not the best one lol

Tbh, I'm always glad to see someone else who didn't like TPB. Maybe it's because I got into the series pretty late (2012) and was familiar with the tropes being used, but it really was a very boring arc, imo.

me when im in a misogyny competition and my opponent is Warrior Cats: Dawn of the Clans

TPB. TBC is a very close second

TNP. And yes, I know that might be seen as a controversial choice considering just how many issues this arc has (the tribe, the messy second half, the rushed romance drama of LeafCrow and annoying love triangle between BrambleSquirrelAsh). And yes, I will freely admit that it has a lot to do with my childhood nostalgia of reading most of this arc (in German) during a vacation under the sun of Portugal (back in 2011). But I also still see potential here and would hope to eventually rewrite my favorite arc to live up to that potential one day.

It's not the best arc though. That title goes to TPB for me (again will admit that nostalgia plays a huge part here). But I also think it was pretty good in terms of writing (full of known tropes and such but still) and it gave me my favorite hero and villain (Firestar and Tigerstar) that I've been a fan of ever since 2007 (when reading the first book in German). 

TBC is currently in third place for me (the horror elements and Ashfur finally getting portrayed as the villain and no longer excused by StarClan as a misunderstood uwu baby who "just loved too much" like in OotS made for a great read). I only properly read this arc in January of this year and really enjoyed it (except for the forced RootBristle romance).

We'll see how ASC turns out but it's looking good so far and might be shaping up to become one of my favs too (perhaps in fourth place depending how it continues this year and ends next year). Again, dislike the romance between NightSun so far though (which might be a pattern for me lol).

TBC followed by POT/OOTS/ASC, followed by TPB/TNP/DOTC, followed by AVOS which was a mess especially The Raging Storm which is definitely my least favorite warrior cat book ever.

I'm surprised Broken Code is doing better than DOTC. IMO I think TBC is one of the worst arcs.

I love both TPB and DOTC, but I have to go with TPB. While I like ASC, the original arcs were so much simpler and easier to understand, so I have to go with TPB.

OotS is actually my second favorite arc. A lot of people hate it because the arc is so messy, but that’s what I love about it lol

TNP, TPB being a close second.

TPB is the best arc.

Darkest Night and River of Fire were actually very good. AVOS based on the first 5 books would probably be tied with POT, OOTS, ASC. The disaster book of The Raging Storm brings the arc down to the bottom.